Sandra Birchmore trial: twin cop takes stand with disgusting admission — questions about mystery man

Original Media · 48m · English · YouTube · Brian Entin

TLDR

In the federal trial of former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell for the murder of Sandra Birchmore, the state medical examiner admitted she ruled the death a suicide without viewing crime scene photos, knowing the ligature was a duffel bag strap (not a scarf), or being told five witnesses — including Birchmore's therapist and school principal — had called police saying it wasn't suicide. Farwell's twin brother Billy testified under immunity that he also had on-duty sex with Birchmore (when she was an adult), but denied knowledge of Matthew's crimes. Criminal defense attorney Mark Bednar explains the prosecution faces a high bar: they must prove beyond reasonable doubt not just homicide, but that Farwell killed Birchmore to prevent her from becoming a federal witness, under an obstruction-of-justice statute — making this far harder than a state murder case. The initial state investigation is portrayed as incompetent or corrupt, ignoring red flags and protecting "their buddy Matt."

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The state medical examiner ruled a death a suicide without ever seeing the scene, photos, or witness statements — and admitted she would have conducted evidence collection differently if she had known it was a suspected homicide.

•

A police officer (Billy Farwell) received federal immunity to testify about having on-duty sex with the victim, while his twin brother is on trial for murdering her — and the immunity covers crimes like stealing time, not the murder itself.

•

The federal prosecution does not need to prove murder per se; they must prove the killing was done to obstruct a potential federal investigation — meaning a juror who believes Farwell killed Birchmore but not for that motive could acquit.

•

Five credible witnesses (therapist, principal, family) independently called police saying Birchmore wasn't suicidal, yet the state police and DA's office never treated Farwell as a suspect or person of interest.

Key takeaways

•

The state medical examiner, Dr. Capo Martinez, ruled Sandra Birchmore's death a suicide without ever seeing crime scene photos, visiting the scene, or receiving witness statements; she was told by Lt. John Fanning there was "nothing more to report" and was not asked to consider homicide.

•

The medical examiner was told the ligature was a "scarf" when it was actually a duffel bag strap with a clasp; she also was not informed of Birchmore's pregnancy, history of consensual choking, or the five witness calls disputing suicide.

•

Billy Farwell, Matthew's twin and a former Stoughton officer, testified under federal immunity that he began having on-duty sex with Birchmore in summer 2018 (when she was an adult), but claimed he knew nothing about his brother's relationship with her; his immunity covers crimes like stealing time and on-duty sexual conduct.

•

Sandra Birchmore's cousin Barb Wright does not believe Billy's denial, stating twins know everything about each other; she also revealed a longer surveillance video shows a "mystery man" walking by the apartment doorway just before Matthew Farwell exited the night Birchmore died.

•

Five separate people — including Birchmore's therapist, her school principal, and family members — called police after her death saying they did not believe it was suicide, yet the state police and Norfolk DA's office did not treat Matthew Farwell as a person of interest.

•

Mark Bednar explains the federal charge is not murder but obstruction of justice (18 USC §1512): prosecutors must prove Farwell killed Birchmore with intent to prevent her from reporting a crime that would likely lead to a federal investigation — a higher, more complex burden than state murder.

•

Bednar argues the initial state investigation was "comically bad" — state police interviewed Farwell in the back of a police car, took no notes, misdescribed evidence, and ignored multiple warnings; this incompetence helps the feds undermine the suicide ruling but also shows systemic protection of "their buddy Matt."

•

The defense may rest without calling witnesses, forcing the jury to decide solely on whether the prosecution met its burden; Bednar predicts a short defense case focused on reasonable doubt about homicide and the federal jurisdictional hook.

Notable quotes

“I don't know that I've ever seen anything like this.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:33

“So, the medical examiner didn't have any photos and didn't even know what the scene looked like where Sandra Birchmore was found dead.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:43

“I was not asked to consider if this was a homicide. I was not asked to consider if this was a homicide, the medical examiner testified.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:18

“Yes, evidence collection.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:39

“It was not a scarf. Okay, if you look at the pictures, it was a part of and I've talked about this in past episodes. It was part of a duffel bag.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:00

“No, I don't.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:56

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & case overview: Brian Entin introduces the latest developments in the Matthew Farwell federal trial, including the medical examiner's testimony, twin brother Billy Farwell taking the stand, and interviews with Sandra Birchmore's cousin and a defense attorney.

•

2:14 — Medical examiner testimony: Dr. Capo Martinez admits she ruled Birchmore's death a suicide without scene photos, ligature details, witness statements, or knowledge of the pregnancy; she was told by state police there was "nothing more to report" and was not asked to consider homicide.

•

6:16 — Billy Farwell (twin) testimony: Matthew Farwell's twin brother Billy testifies under immunity, admitting to on-duty sex with Birchmore (when she was an adult) but denying knowledge of his brother's crimes; he appeared uncomfortable and avoided looking at his brother or mother.

•

8:23 — Interview with Barb Wright (cousin): Sandra's cousin Barb Wright describes Billy as uncomfortable and untruthful, reveals a longer surveillance video shows a "mystery man" near the apartment the night of the death, and shares Birchmore was ecstatic about her pregnancy and not suicidal.

•

19:54 — Interview with Mark Bednar (defense attorney): Criminal defense attorney Mark Bednar analyzes the medical examiner's failures, the unusual immunity deal for Billy Farwell, and why the federal obstruction-of-justice charge makes this case harder for prosecutors than a state murder trial.

•

32:59 — Federal charges explained: Bednar details 18 USC §1512: prosecutors must prove Farwell killed Birchmore to prevent her from becoming a federal witness — a jurisdictional hook that could allow acquittal even if jurors believe he murdered her.

•

35:36 — Defense strategy & systemic corruption: Bednar predicts a short or nonexistent defense case focused on burden of proof; he describes the initial state investigation as corrupt and incompetent, with police protecting "their buddy Matt" despite five credible warnings.

•

41:58 — Closing reflections: Entin and Bednar discuss the broader scandal: state authorities didn't just fail to prosecute Farwell — they refused to investigate him, depriving Birchmore's family of a good-faith inquiry and allowing a likely murder to be framed as suicide.

Speakers

•

Brian Entin — Host

•

Barb Wright — Witness

•

Mark Bednar — Legal analyst

•

Michelle McPhee — Reporter

⋮