TLDR
A federal judge dismissed Donald Trump's $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the Wall Street Journal with prejudice, ending the case permanently. Legal analyst Glenn Kirschner explains that the dismissal signals the suit was frivolous and brought in bad faith, and discusses implications for Trump's similar $10 billion lawsuit against the BBC and the broader pattern of media outlets settling with Trump.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A dismissal with prejudice is a severe judicial rebuke that goes beyond losing on merits — it brands the lawsuit as an abuse of the legal process.
Trump's own lawyers were previously sanctioned nearly $1 million for bringing a frivolous suit, yet he continued the same pattern with the WSJ case.
The judge explicitly used the word 'manufacture' to describe Trump's attempt to create false flaws in the Journal's reporting, implying deliberate deception.
Key takeaways
Judge Darren Gales dismissed Trump's lawsuit against the Wall Street Journal with prejudice, meaning it cannot be refiled.
The judge found Trump failed to make even a prima facie case of actual malice or falsity, and accused him of attempting to 'manufacture flaws' in the Journal's reporting.
Dismissal with prejudice is reserved for frivolous, meritless, or bad-faith lawsuits, not merely procedural errors.
The Wall Street Journal may seek attorney's fees, as happened in a prior Trump lawsuit against Hillary Clinton where sanctions were imposed.
The ruling undermines Trump's claim that the Epstein birthday letter was fabricated; the letter's authenticity is supported by the close Trump-Epstein relationship and Ghislaine Maxwell's role.
The dismissal may influence the pending BBC lawsuit, as judges often look to similar rulings for guidance, and Trump's pattern of baseless suits could weigh against him.
Media outlets that settle with Trump (e.g., ABC News) gain no goodwill and only encourage further attacks, while those that fight (WSJ, BBC) retain dignity and legal ground.
Notable quotes
“This order addresses President Trump's second attempt to plead that the defendants... acted with actual malice... As with his first attempt, he has failed.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:22“Oh, and by the way, I am dismissing it with prejudice.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:51“Trump in bringing this case actually tried to... attempt to manufacture flaws in The Wall Street Journal's investigative reporting.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:03“Based on all the public reporting... you could easily conclude as a rational, fact-based human being that Donald Trump wrote the birthday letter.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:26“The news outlets and organizations that capitulate to Trump... are doing democracy no favors.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:16Chapters
0:00 — Judge Dismisses Trump's $10B Lawsuit Against WSJ With Prejudice: A federal judge permanently threw out Trump's second attempt to sue the Wall Street Journal over the Epstein birthday letter, dismissing with prejudice after finding he failed to state a claim.
1:51 — Why Dismissal With Prejudice Matters: Glenn Kirschner explains that dismissal with prejudice bars refiling and is reserved for frivolous, meritless, or bad-faith lawsuits — not mere procedural mistakes.
4:01 — Legal Standard: Prima Facie Case and Actual Malice: To proceed, Trump needed minimal evidence of falsity or actual malice; the judge found he had none, and accused him of trying to 'manufacture' flaws in the reporting.
6:00 — Wall Street Journal's Recourse: Attorney's Fees: The Journal may move for reimbursement of legal fees, as courts have sanctioned Trump and his lawyers before for bringing baseless suits.
7:24 — Implications for the Epstein Letter's Authenticity: The failed lawsuit and the context — Ghislaine Maxwell compiling letters from Epstein's close friends — strongly support the letter's authenticity.
9:28 — Impact on Pending BBC Lawsuit and Media Strategy: While not binding precedent, the ruling may guide the BBC case judge; Trump's pattern of bad-faith suits hurts him. Media outlets that fight back retain dignity, while those that settle gain nothing.
Speakers
Brian Tyler Cohen — Host
Glenn Kirschner — Legal Analyst