TLDR
Eric Boss ranks 100 actors for the DCU Batman based on James Gunn's criteria: age 28-40 (same as Superman David Corenswet, 33), no active MCU/DCU/Matt Reeves Batman actors, must convey brooding 'goth freak' energy, and fit the Clayface movie's Liverpool-set Gotham. The list prioritizes acting talent over physique, includes diverse casting, and favors HBO/Warner Bros connections. Top pick is Bill Skarsgård for his Pennywise franchise success, height match with Corenswet, and ability to embody a creature of the night.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Batman will be the same age as Superman, not a decade older as previously assumed from Creature Commandos timeline hints.
Michael Keaton wasn't a huge star when cast as Batman in 1989 — he was known for comedic roles and Mr. Mom, similar to where Bill Skarsgård is now.
James Gunn considers The Suicide Squad (2021) a 'hypothetical audition piece' and not DCU canon, yet is open to recasting its actors in new roles.
The Clayface movie's Gotham City (shot in Liverpool) is the template for the DCU's Gotham, making British/working-class actors a natural fit.
Actors who've played vampires (Pattinson, Matt Smith, Sam Reid) are seen as having a built-in advantage for Batman because both are 'nightstalkers.'
Bill Skarsgård's Pennywise performance is viewed as the modern equivalent of Michael Keaton's Beetlejuice — a 'freak' role that proves he can handle Batman's theatricality.
Key takeaways
James Gunn wants Batman to be the same age as Superman (33), so the casting range is 28-40, contradicting assumptions that Batman would be older and more experienced.
Physical build is secondary to acting talent; 'rat boy' actors can bulk up like Robert Pattinson did for The Batman, and trainers can transform any physique in 2-3 years before filming.
The DCU Gotham is based on the Clayface movie's Liverpool setting — a nightmarish, crime-ridden port city — so Batman must feel like a 'weird loner freak' who belongs in that specific atmosphere.
HBO and Warner Bros connections give actors a significant advantage; Game of Thrones, House of the Dragon, and other HBO alumni dominate the list because they've proven they can handle physically demanding, dark roles.
The Sky Dance merger creates pressure to cast a known star with billion-dollar box office credentials rather than an unknown, even if James Gunn prefers a 'goth freak' character actor.
James Gunn is open to recasting actors from his own Suicide Squad and Peacemaker projects, meaning Freddy Stroma (Vigilante) could theoretically become Batman.
Non-white actors are seriously considered for Bruce Wayne — Black, Asian, Indian, Latino — though Eric suspects Sky Dance leadership may default to a white actor.
British actors have a leg up since Gotham is filmed in Liverpool; a working-class English Batman would fit the setting naturally.
Bill Skarsgård is the top pick because he matches Corenswet's 6'4" height, has billion-dollar franchise experience (IT Chapter 1 & 2), can emote under heavy makeup, and embodies the 'brood king' energy Gunn wants.
The top 10 includes Paul Mescal, Alden Ehrenreich, Jack O'Connell, Jamie Campbell Bower, Jack Lowden, Jeremy Allen White, Aaron Taylor-Johnson, Tom Brittney, and Austin Butler — all actors who bring 'freaky' energy over traditional leading-man looks.
Notable quotes
“I think James Gun's going to look for a goth freak and just someone who's a really good actor, not necessarily a star.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:16“We need our own weird freaky Batman. All right, that's going to be a theme for a lot of my picks here.”
▸ Notable quotes · 24:43“If Will Poulter can go from that skinny little twerp in Black Mirror to what he is now, any of these rat boys who I'm gonna tell you can beef up to be Batman.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:51“You should see Batman in the face of every actor in his 30s.”
▸ Notable quotes · 45:12“He is the brood king. And if Andy Musketi is somehow involved with this movie... Bill Scarsgard is like the first name he wants to play Batman.”
▸ Notable quotes · 102:04“I feel like you need this generation's Beetlejuice to be playing the Batman here. And I think there's just the stars are aligned perfect.”
▸ Notable quotes · 103:36Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and Ground Rules: Eric Boss introduces the live stream ranking of 100 actors for DCU Batman, explains James Gunn's criteria: age 28-40 (same as Superman David Corenswet), no active MCU/DCU/Matt Reeves actors, must brood, diverse casting encouraged, and Gotham based on Clayface's Liverpool setting.
16:00 — Courtesy Picks and Early Rankings (100-90): Starts with Jensen Ackles (48, too old) and Daniel Radcliffe (37, Warner Bros alum) as courtesy picks, then moves through Steven Yeun, Dev Patel, Rami Malek, Matt Smith, and other established actors mostly in their 40s who are slightly above the age range.
29:00 — The 'Rat Boy' Tier and HBO Connections (80s-70s): Features younger, thinner actors like Kieran Culkin, Noah Centineo, Nate Mann, and HBO alumni Tom Pelphrey, Alfie Allen, Sam Claflin. Emphasizes 'freak energy' over traditional looks and HBO/Warner Bros connections as casting advantages.
50:00 — Mid-List: Rising Stars and Genre Veterans (60s-50s): Includes Darren Criss, Freddy Stroma (Peacemaker's Vigilante, eligible for recasting), Jake Gyllenhaal, Alan Ritchson, Jonathan Groff, and younger actors like Oscar Morgan, Kyle Gallner, Adam DiMarco. Highlights physical transformation potential.
59:00 — Top 50: Major Names and Franchise Alumni (50-40): Michael B. Jordan at 50, then Jack Quaid, Dylan O'Brien, Jonathan Bailey, Jesse Plemons, Glenn Powell, Brandon Perea, Michael Gandolfini, Charles Melton, Josh Hutcherson, Tom Glynn-Carney, Austin Abrams. Mix of stars and 'who?' actors.
75:00 — Top 30: Bond Shortlist and Critical Darlings (30-20): Kit Harington, Michael Johnston, Charlie Vickers, Harris Dickinson, Leo Woodall, James Norton, Evan Peters, Oliver Jackson-Cohen, Theo James, Fabian Frankel, Taron Egerton, Will Poulter. Heavy Game of Thrones/House of the Dragon and Ryan Murphy verse representation.
89:00 — Top 15: The Serious Contenders (15-10): Callum Turner (rumored Bond), Brandon Sklenar (Gunn interested), Jacob Elordi (maybe too tall), Cosmo Jarvis (Shogun), George MacKay (1917), Austin Butler (10), Tom Brittney (9, Superman runner-up).
96:00 — Top 5 and Number One Reveal (5-1): Aaron Taylor-Johnson (8), Jeremy Allen White (7), Jack Lowden (6), Jamie Campbell Bower (5), Jack O'Connell (4), Alden Ehrenreich (3), Paul Mescal (2), Bill Skarsgård (1). Detailed reasoning for each, especially Skarsgård's Pennywise franchise success, height match, and 'brood king' status.
Speakers
Eric Boss — Host
Brian — Producer
Josh — Producer
Chat/Super Chat Participants — Audience