Ep. 733 | The Giant in the Fog - MrBallen

Original Media · 1h 58m · English · YouTube · MrBallen’s Medical Mysteries Podcast

TLDR

This episode presents a compilation of nine distinct dark historical and true crime stories, ranging from a 19th-century mountain encounter with a natural optical illusion to a 2006 clinical trial disaster, a catfishing murder plot, a sailing trip turned deadly, a cave diving tragedy, a Soviet cannibal island, the Hiroshima atomic bomb shadows, a submarine murder, and a prom date with a future serial killer.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The 'Big Grey Man' legend persisted for over a century before digital cameras confirmed it was just the hikers' own shadows.

•

The catfisher (Thomas Montgomery) and his victim ('Jesse') were both pretending to be someone else; the '17-year-old girl' was actually a 46-year-old married woman using her daughter's photos.

•

The TGN1412 drug had been tested successfully in animals, but those animals (macaques) lack the CD28 receptor distribution that makes humans susceptible to cytokine storms, so the risk was invisible in preclinical trials.

•

The Plur Cave traverse required specialized underwater scooters because the distance is too great to swim on breath-hold; a single equipment failure or mistake is fatal.

•

On Nazino Island, the Soviet guards appointed criminal prisoners as 'brigadiers' to distribute flour, but the brigadiers hoarded it, accelerating the descent into cannibalism.

•

Peter Madsen, a famous DIY rocket/submarine builder, lured Kim Wall onto his submarine under the guise of an interview, then murdered and dismembered her.

•

Jeffrey Dahmer's prom date had no idea she was with a future serial killer; he killed his first victim just days after the prom.

Key takeaways

•

The 'Big Grey Man' of Ben Macdui is a real but harmless weather phenomenon called a Brocken spectre, where a person's shadow is magnified and distorted in fog.

•

Thomas Montgomery, a 46-year-old factory worker, created an elaborate online persona as an 18-year-old Marine sniper, leading to a catfishing scheme that ended in the murder of his coworker Brian Barrett.

•

Both Thomas Montgomery and his online love interest 'Jesse' (Tall Hot Blonde) were catfishing each other; Jesse was actually a 46-year-old woman named Mary Shieler using her daughter's identity.

•

In 2011, a freelance journalist Kim Wall was murdered by inventor Peter Madsen aboard his homemade submarine after accepting an interview ride.

•

The 2006 TGN1412 clinical trial caused catastrophic cytokine storms in six healthy volunteers because the drug was administered 10 times faster than the recommended rate, and the animal models used in testing could not predict this human-specific reaction.

•

Nazino Island in Siberia became a 'Cannibal Island' in 1933 when thousands of deportees were abandoned without food, shelter, or tools, leading to rampant cannibalism within weeks.

•

A group of experienced Finnish cave divers attempted a dangerous 2 km traverse in Plur Cave; a fatal accident occurred when one diver became wedged, blocking the only exit and leading to multiple drownings.

•

The atomic bombing of Hiroshima left permanent 'shadows' on surfaces where people were instantly vaporized, such as the Hiroshima shadow on the Sumitomo Bank steps.

•

Jeffrey Dahmer's first prom date in 1978 was with Bridget Guyer; just days later he committed his first murder, beginning a 13-year killing spree that claimed 17 lives.

Notable quotes

“It would turn out that the legendary monster was totally real, but it was not dangerous. It was actually the result of a very rare and quite creepy weather phenomenon called a brocken spectre.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:01

“On January 2, 2006, Tom Montgomery, 46 years old, ceases to exist and is replaced by an 18-year-old battle-hardened Marine.”

▸ Notable quotes · 29:33

“The drug TGN1412 had tested so well in animals that he had complete confidence that today's trial would go smoothly. But when Dr. Bradford burst into Bay 1, he found a truly chaotic scene.”

▸ Notable quotes · 87:15

“It would take them months, but the health inspectors would eventually discover why this had happened. It would turn out Dr. Bradford and his team were missing some crucial information because even though this drug had been successfully tested on animals, those animals weren't capable of experiencing cytokine storms.”

▸ Notable quotes · 100:44

“Right after this picture was taken of Jeffrey and Bridget, right before they headed off to prom together, Jeffrey would kill his first victim and start that 13-year killing spree.”

▸ Notable quotes · 115:30

Chapters

•

0:00 — The Big Grey Man of Ben Macdui: In 1891, chemistry professor Norman Collie encounters a terrifying giant figure while hiking in the Scottish Highlands. The legend of the 'Big Grey Man' persists for over a century until digital cameras reveal it is a Brocken spectre — an optical illusion where the observer's own shadow is magnified and distorted in fog.

•

9:45 — The Catfishing Murder of Thomas Montgomery: Factory worker Thomas Montgomery creates an online persona as an 18-year-old Marine sniper on Pogo.com, seducing a '17-year-old girl' named Jesse. The relationship escalates to virtual sex and a marriage proposal. When Montgomery's coworker Brian Barrett discovers the truth and also falls for Jesse, Montgomery murders Barrett in a parking lot. Investigation reveals Jesse was actually a 46-year-old woman, Mary Shieler, catfishing Montgomery using her daughter's identity.

•

55:56 — Death in the Marquesas: The Stefan Ramen Murder: Sailors Hikah Dorsch and Stefan Ramen explore the remote Marquesas Islands. They meet a local man, Arihano, who offers to guide Stefan on a goat hunt. Arihano attacks Stefan, ties him up, builds a massive fire, shoots him, and burns his body — likely cannibalizing him. Hikah escapes after being tied up and beaten, surviving to alert authorities. Arihano is convicted but never admits to cannibalism.

•

63:44 — The Plur Cave Traverse Tragedy: Five Finnish divers attempt a 2 km underwater traverse in Plur Cave, Norway, using rebreathers and scooters. A diver becomes wedged in a narrow ascent, blocking the exit. He panics, loses his mouthpiece, and drowns. The three following divers encounter the body; two panic and drown, while the third painstakingly pushes his gear past the corpse and rockets to the surface, skipping decompression. Three survive with intense survivor's guilt; they later illegally retrieve the bodies.

•

73:06 — Nazino Island: Cannibal Island: In 1933, Stalin deports nearly 7,000 people to Nazino Island in Siberia with no food, shelter, or tools. Guards withhold flour, then appoint criminal 'brigadiers' to distribute it, but they hoard it. Starvation leads to rampant cannibalism within days. Only 2,000 survive the first month before Stalin shuts down the island.

•

77:34 — The TGN1412 Clinical Trial Disaster (The Elephant Men): Eight healthy volunteers receive the experimental drug TGN1412 at Northwick Park Hospital. Six receive the active drug, administered 10 times faster than protocol. All six develop catastrophic cytokine storms, suffering multi-organ failure and massive swelling ('elephant men'). Intensive care specialist Dr. Suntharalingam guesses correctly to use immunosuppressants, saving their lives. The disaster leads to 22 new European clinical trial safety regulations.

•

103:03 — The Hiroshima Shadow: The atomic bombing of Hiroshima on August 6, 1945, instantly vaporizes 70,000 people. An elderly person sitting on the Sumitomo Bank steps leaves a permanent shadow on the stone — the 'Hiroshima shadow' — preserved for over 20 years before being moved to a museum.

•

104:56 — Peter Madsen and the Submarine Murder of Kim Wall: Inventor Peter Madsen lures freelance journalist Kim Wall onto his homemade submarine for an interview. He murders and beheads her, disposes of her body, and sinks the submarine. Madsen claims an accident but is convicted and sentenced to life in prison after her remains wash ashore.

•

109:44 — Prom Date with a Serial Killer: Jeffrey Dahmer: In 1978, Bridget Guyer goes to prom with awkward classmate Jeffrey Dahmer. The date is disastrous; Dahmer leaves her at a food cart to eat cheeseburgers outside. Days later, Dahmer kills his first victim, beginning a 13-year spree murdering 17 men and boys. Bridget only realizes years later when she sees his face on the news.

Speakers

•

Narrator — Host/Storyteller

⋮