Are Teens REALLY Using Less Drugs? | Dr. Scott Hadland

Original Media · 1h 58m · English · YouTube · Doctor Mike

TLDR

Dr. Scott Hadland, chief of adolescent medicine at Mass General, discusses evidence-based approaches to teen health including motivational interviewing for vaccine hesitancy, building rapport with substance-using teens rather than demanding immediate abstinence, and the critical importance of confidential one-on-one time with adolescents. He explains why DARE failed, how prevention actually works by fostering mental health coping skills, and why confidential visits are under political attack despite strong evidence they improve outcomes. The conversation also covers rising teen mental health crises amid declining substance use, LGBTQ+ youth care, and Dr. Hadland's experience as a gay physician navigating stigma in medical training.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Teen substance use rates have hit historic lows (two-thirds of high school seniors used no drugs or alcohol in the past month), yet anxiety and depression rates are at historic highs — safer behaviors coexist with worse mental well-being.

•

The recent decline in adolescent overdose deaths may be driven more by changes in the illicit drug supply (less lethal fentanyl analogs) than by public health interventions, a possibility Dr. Hadland finds humbling.

•

Parents supplying alcohol to teens in a 'safe' home setting actually increases the risk of heavy drinking and future substance use disorders, contrary to the 'European model' many assume is protective.

•

Dr. Hadland was advised not to come out during residency applications in 2009 because it might hurt his chances — a concern that proved unfounded in his program but reflects persistent stigma in medical training.

•

A family once refused to let Dr. Hadland examine their newborn because he is gay, fearing he would 'groom' their male baby — an explicit stigma encounter that still happens, though rarely.

Key takeaways

•

Motivational interviewing — listening first, exploring patient motivations, and letting families reach their own conclusions — is more effective than prescriptive advice for vaccine hesitancy and substance use, because it builds trust and team-based decision-making.

•

In adolescent addiction treatment, the first visit's goal is often simply building enough rapport for the teen to return, not achieving immediate abstinence; change happens over multiple visits as the clinician helps the teen identify their own reasons to cut back.

•

Cannabis use disorder is defined by functional impairment (grades, relationships, money, risky behavior), not physical withdrawal severity; many teens don't recognize their use as problematic until a clinician helps them see the consequences.

•

Effective prevention programs focus on mental health coping skills (mindfulness, stress management, healthy relationships) rather than refusal skills alone; the decline in teen substance use over two decades correlates with this shift, not with DARE.

•

Confidential one-on-one time with teens is the evidence-based standard of care: randomized trials show adolescents disclose more risk behaviors and return for follow-up when parents step out, yet several states have introduced bills to restrict this practice.

•

The 'grooming' fear — that clinicians can convince a child to adopt a different gender identity or sexual orientation — is contradicted by data; clinicians create safe spaces for youth to explore identity, not impose one.

•

Parents should lead with curiosity ('What are you seeing at school?') rather than prohibition, make clear health-based recommendations against use, and use nuanced consequences (praise for calling for a safe ride, limits like curfews) rather than punishment that shuts down communication.

•

Social media creates a distortion bias where negative healthcare anecdotes are amplified while routine good care is invisible, fueling public figures' claims about overprescription and driving policy attacks on evidence-based practices.

Notable quotes

“I think that the best care is delivered when the doctor asks the parent to step out and the parent obliges and gives that doctor one-on-one time with the teen.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:07

“It's not possible for a clinician to convince a young person that they're a gender different from the one that they walked into that room thinking that they were. It's just not possible.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:23

“One of the single most important key ingredients of a good prevention program is helping a young person understand that substance use isn't inevitable. That not everybody uses drugs and alcohol and that in fact most people don't use drugs and alcohol.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:01

“The natural history of addiction in a person is that the thermometer keeps changing. It gets worse over time, right? And you will cross that line and I can reflect that back to a patient.”

▸ Notable quotes · 24:18

“If you want your child to continue to call you for a safe ride, you probably don't want to come down too hard on the consequence. I think you can actually provide praise to your child and say, 'Thank you so much for calling me.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 62:14

“Board scores are not terribly important to me. I deemphasize them. For me, what is really important is to understand the relationships that people are forming and that really rises out of letters of recommendation.”

▸ Notable quotes · 111:52

Chapters

•

2:00 — HPV vaccine & motivational interviewing: Dr. Hadland describes his listening-first approach to vaccine-hesitant families: explore their concerns, share data without pressure, and disclose his own parenting choices to build trust and team-based decision-making.

•

8:00 — Adolescent substance use treatment philosophy: The goal of early visits is rapport-building, not immediate abstinence. Using motivational interviewing, Dr. Hadland helps teens identify what they get from substance use (sleep, fitting in) and find their own reasons to cut back, like saving money.

•

15:00 — Cannabis use disorder vs. addiction definitions: Dr. Hadland explains cannabis use disorder is defined by functional impairment and loss of control, not severe physical withdrawal. He uses a 'line-crossing' exercise where patients define their own red flags for future reference.

•

19:00 — Nicotine products & harm reduction tensions: Discussion of nicotine pouches and e-cigarettes as harm-reduction tools for adults versus youth initiation risks from flavors. Dr. Hadland supports FDA regulation as medical products, not consumer goods with bubble-gum flavors.

•

25:30 — DARE failure & effective prevention science: DARE's focus on refusal skills failed. Effective programs build mental health coping skills (mindfulness, stress management, relationships). Teen substance use has hit historic lows while anxiety and depression have surged — a paradox Dr. Hadland calls a 'tradeoff' worth examining.

•

67:00 — Confidential teen visits under political attack: Confidential one-on-one time is the evidence-based standard (randomized trials show more disclosure and return visits). Several states have introduced bills to restrict it, fueled by 'grooming' fears Dr. Hadland says are contradicted by data.

•

74:00 — LGBTQ+ youth care & physician identity: Dr. Hadland shares his experience as a gay physician advised to stay closeted during residency applications, and a family refusing his care for their newborn. He describes supporting teens coming out, sometimes witnessing the conversation in the exam room.

•

102:00 — AI, fellowship selection & career reflections: Dr. Hadland discusses AI's role in speeding information retrieval and documentation, his NIH-funded research on addiction treatment gaps for Medicaid youth, and his fellowship selection criteria: prioritizing relationship-building anecdotes over board scores.

Speakers

•

Host — Family medicine physician, podcast host, social media creator

•

Dr. Scott Hadland — Chief of Adolescent and Young Adult Medicine, Mass General for Children; Associate Professor of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School

⋮