TLDR
Pod Save America host Tommy Vietor interviews CNN chief data analyst Harry Enten two days before the 2026 midterms. They analyze historical midterm patterns, polling reliability concerns, and walk through key Senate races (Texas, Michigan, Alaska, Ohio, Maine, Iowa, Kansas, South Carolina) and House projections. Enten argues Democrats are favored to take the House, possibly by a wide margin, but expresses skepticism about polling in states with large white working-class populations like Ohio. He highlights early vote data showing increased Black turnout as a positive sign for Democrats in Southern states.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Only three midterms since the Civil War have seen the White House party not lose House seats: 1934 (FDR), 1998 (Clinton), 2002 (Bush post-9/11).
Trump is one of only three presidents since the Civil War with a net approval below -15 points entering a midterm; the other two (Truman 1946, Bush 2006) saw their parties lose both chambers badly.
James Talarico is the first Democrat in 30+ years to poll this competitively in a Texas Senate race, and he's winning non-MAGA Republicans by nearly 30%.
In Michigan, voters who say Israel is their top issue are *more* likely to support El-Sayed, not Rogers — contradicting the prevailing narrative.
Alaska has elected only one Democratic senator in the 21st century (Mark Begich, 2008, against a just-convicted Ted Stevens); before that, Mike Gravel in 1974.
Kansas has shifted left relative to the nation faster than almost any state — from the 9th-10th most Republican to 18th-19th — and now votes only slightly more Republican than Texas.
The 2000 Florida recount was decided by absentee ballots: Bush won the absentee vote while Gore won Election Day in-person voting — the opposite of today's partisan voting patterns.
Key takeaways
Historical precedent suggests the party of a president with a net approval below -15 points (like Trump) typically suffers severe midterm losses in both House and Senate, as seen with Truman in 1946 and Bush in 2006.
Democrats currently lead in enough 'lean/likely/solid' House districts to win a majority without needing any toss-ups — an unusual position that makes 225 seats feel like a floor rather than a ceiling, with models projecting north of 230.
Polling in the Trump era has underestimated Republicans by ~4 points on average in close Senate races in Trump-won states, but 2022 saw Democrats outperform final polls in every close Senate race, leaving the current direction of polling error uncertain.
In Texas, James Talarico polls strongly against Ken Paxton, winning ~30% of non-MAGA Republicans and leading Latinos by 30-40 points — a dramatic shift from Trump's +10 with Latinos in 2024 — and Enten trusts these polls more than most because Beto O'Rourke outperformed his polls in 2018.
Michigan's Senate race shows a stark disconnect: Abdul El-Sayed leads in recent polling (CNN +7) and has higher favorables than Mike Rogers, yet the media narrative focuses on attacks about Israel and loyalty that the data suggests aren't moving voters.
Ohio is the state where Enten is most skeptical of polling showing Sherrod Brown ahead, due to a history of underestimating Republicans among white working-class voters and the complication of Brown facing an appointed incumbent (Husted) whom some voters may not realize is the incumbent.
Susan Collins has outperformed her polls by 5+ points in each of her last three races, but her net favorability is now negative (-10 to -12) for the first time, and Trump's deep unpopularity in Maine may finally overcome her personal brand advantage.
Early vote data shows significantly higher Black turnout, which Enten believes could be most impactful in Georgia (governor), Texas (Senate and governor), and South Carolina — though he cautions early vote is ambiguous and election-day Republican turnout remains a wildcard.
Notable quotes
“It would be highly unusual for the White House party not to lose at least some seats going into a midterm election.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:45“In both of those cases, their parties didn't just lose seats. They got absolutely shellacked. And they didn't just lose the US House, they lost the US Senate as well.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:24“We know that in the Trump era, especially in states that Donald Trump won in the prior presidential election, there has been an underestimation of Republican strength. It's been four points on average in close Senate races.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:05“In 2022, the last midterm that we had, in fact, what you saw was that in 100% of the races that in which they were the close Senate races, right? Five points on either side, the Democrats outperform their final polling in all of them.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:55“James Talarico is getting nearly 30% of non-MAGA Republicans. That is a huge huge number.”
▸ Notable quotes · 18:14“I look at that race and I say would it surprise me if Josh Scherk won? No, it wouldn't surprise me, but it's also the race where if I were a Democrat, I I I would be more worried about that race in terms of the close race I'm looking at than any other.”
▸ Notable quotes · 39:56Chapters
2:58 — Historical midterm patterns and Trump's approval: Enten outlines the historical rule that the president's party loses House seats in midterms, noting only three exceptions since the Civil War. With Trump's net approval below -15 — joining only Truman (1946) and Bush (2006) — history suggests Democrats could win the House decisively, possibly north of 230 seats.
5:31 — Polling anxiety and response bias: Vietor raises concerns about polling missing Republicans, citing a Minnesota poll showing a 14-point Democratic lead that contradicts other data. Enten acknowledges a 4-point average Republican underestimation in Trump-won states but notes 2022 saw Democrats outperform polls in every close Senate race, leaving the error direction uncertain.
9:04 — House projections and bellwether districts: Enten agrees with Cook Political Report's 227-240 seat range for Democrats but thinks 225 is a floor. Models project 230+. He identifies Kentucky-6 and Indiana's Spartz district as early bellwethers, plus NC, FL Latino districts for signals on Democratic strength.
17:07 — Texas Senate: Talarico vs. Paxton: Talarico leads Paxton by 3-6 points, winning ~30% of non-MAGA Republicans and leading Latinos by 30-40 points — a massive shift from Trump's +10 with Latinos. Enten trusts these polls more than most because Beto outperformed polls in 2018 and Paxton is the least popular GOP Senate nominee in Texas this century.
22:06 — Michigan Senate: El-Sayed vs. Rogers: CNN shows El-Sayed +7; Fox had Rogers +4. The average has shifted toward El-Sayed. Voters prioritizing Israel favor El-Sayed, and his favorables exceed Rogers's — contradicting the media narrative that Israel attacks will hurt him.
24:55 — Alaska, Ohio, Maine, Iowa Senate races: Alaska: Peltola leads but history is daunting (one Dem senator since 1974); ranked-choice voting complicates a 'Dan Sullivan' spoiler effort. Ohio: Brown leads but Enten is most skeptical here due to white working-class polling misses. Maine: Collins has outperformed polls by 5+ points three cycles running, but her favorability is now negative. Iowa: Scherk/Hinson tied; not a must-win for Dem majority.
45:31 — Stretch states, Black turnout, and election night timing: Kansas is the most likely stretch flip (Hamilton competitive, Marshall unpopular). South Carolina is racially polarized and inelastic. Early vote shows surging Black turnout, which Enten says helps most in GA gov, TX, and SC. He predicts a relatively early night (2-3 AM ET) unless MI or AK delay things.
57:16 — Future of polling and data analytics: Enten argues horse-race polling hasn't become less accurate — races have just gotten closer (every popular vote since 1988 within single digits). He advocates using all data sources (polls, prediction markets, registration, national indicators) and vetting pollster transparency. Skeptical of anonymous/opaque pollsters.
Speakers
Tommy Vietor — Host
Harry Enten — Guest