TLDR
In 1995, Mark Winger shot and killed Roger Harrington, claiming self-defense after finding him beating his wife Donna with a hammer. The case was closed as justifiable homicide, but four years later Donna's friend Deianne Schulz revealed an affair with Mark and that he had said life would be easier if Donna were dead. Re-examination of Polaroid photos and blood spatter proved Mark's account was fabricated — he had invited Roger to the house under false pretenses, killed Donna himself, then shot Roger to stage a home invasion. Mark was convicted of both murders in 2001 and later tried to arrange hits on witnesses from prison. Rebecca Simick, the nanny he married after Donna's death, left with their children.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The murder weapon (hammer) belonged to the Wingers and was left out because Donna wanted to remind Mark to hang a coat rack — not brought by the attacker.
Roger Harrington brought cigarettes and a coffee mug into the house but left a tire iron and knife in his car, inconsistent with a planned murder.
Mark Winger personally called Roger's employer to set up a face-to-face meeting, and the employer gave Mark Roger's personal number without hesitation — a practice unthinkable today.
The Polaroid photos that broke the case open were taken by a responding officer who only had three shots left in his camera, and they sat unseen in a filing cabinet for years because the case was closed too quickly.
Neighbors heard two gunshots separated by minutes, not seconds, but this was initially dismissed despite being captured in the background of Mark's own 911 call.
Mark visited the police station multiple times after the case closed — first to retrieve his gun and ask detailed questions about the investigation, later to announce his remarriage to Rebecca — behavior detectives found suspicious but superiors ignored.
Key takeaways
Mark Winger staged a home invasion to cover up the murder of his wife Donna, inviting Roger Harrington to the house under the pretense of discussing a driving complaint, then killing Donna with a hammer and shooting Roger to make it look like self-defense.
Critical physical evidence contradicted Mark's story: Polaroid photos showed Roger's body positioned 180 degrees from where Mark claimed he shot him, blood spatter proved Roger was shot twice with a time gap (rolled over between shots), and neighbors heard two distinct gunshots minutes apart.
A note in Roger's car with Mark's name, address, and '430' (4:30 PM meeting time) revealed Roger had been invited — not breaking in — and Mark had obtained Roger's contact info through his employer after Donna reported Roger's disturbing behavior during an airport shuttle ride.
Detectives Doug Williamson and Charlie Cox suspected Mark from day one due to lack of forced entry, Roger leaving weapons in his car, and the appointment note, but superiors refused to reopen the case until Deianne Schulz's 1999 confession about Mark's affair and statements wishing Donna dead.
Mark received $175,000 in insurance and victim compensation after Donna's death, providing financial motive alongside his affair with Deianne and desire to be free of the marriage.
After conviction, Mark attempted to orchestrate multiple murders from prison — including kidnapping a wealthy acquaintance for ransom, forcing Deianne to recant her testimony, and killing Donna's stepfather — proving ongoing dangerousness and lack of remorse.
Rebecca Simick, hired as nanny five months after Donna's death, married Mark and adopted Bailey, but left with all four children after his arrest, relocating to Kentucky to start new lives.
Roger Harrington's family maintained his innocence for years; police had dismissed his sister's pleas despite documented history of mental illness but no history of targeted violence against strangers.
Notable quotes
“Never let anyone's emotions cloud your vision when you're investigating a crime.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:08“This man, he made my wife. I shot him.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:16“Oh my god, that's the guy that's been harassing my wife and me.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:04“I thought I was going to jail because I just shot a man in the head.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:58“Roger Harrington killed my wife. It's all with my own eyes.”
▸ Notable quotes · 40:39“Just get a divorce.”
▸ Notable quotes · 47:32Chapters
0:00 — The 911 Call and Initial Scene: Mark Winger calls 911 claiming he shot an intruder attacking his wife Donna with a hammer. First responders find both Donna and Roger Harrington barely alive; both die shortly after.
4:28 — Mark and Donna's Background: Mark and Donna met on a blind date in 1987-88, married in 1989, moved to Illinois, and adopted daughter Bailey in 1995 after Donna was told she couldn't conceive.
11:00 — The Airport Shuttle Incident: Donna took an airport shuttle driven by Roger Harrington, who drove erratically and made disturbing comments about killing people and out-of-body experiences. She reported him; he was suspended.
8:00 — The Murder and Staged Self-Defense: Mark claims he was in the basement, heard commotion, found Roger beating Donna, and shot him. Police accept self-defense; case closed. Mark hires nanny Rebecca Simick, they marry and have more children.
20:48 — Deianne Schulz's Confession: In 1999, Donna's friend Deianne confesses to an affair with Mark and reveals he said life would be easier if Donna were dead, and suggested getting Roger to the house so Deianne would only need to 'find the body.'
26:00 — Detectives' Long-Standing Suspicions: Detectives Williamson and Cox always doubted Mark: no forced entry, Roger's weapons left in car, appointment note in Roger's car with Mark's name/address/time. Superiors refused to reopen until Deianne came forward.
34:00 — Physical Evidence Contradicts Mark: Polaroid photos show Roger's body positioned opposite to Mark's account. Blood spatter proves Roger was shot twice with a time gap (rolled over between shots). Neighbors heard two shots minutes apart; 911 call captures moaning between shots.
40:28 — Arrest, Trial, and Aftermath: Mark arrested six years post-murder. Convicted of both murders in 2001, sentenced to life without parole. Rebecca leaves with children. Mark later tries to arrange hits on Deianne and others from prison.
Speakers
Annie Eliss — Host/Narrator
Mark Winger — Perpetrator
Donna Winger — Victim
Roger Harrington — Victim
Rebecca Simick — Nanny/Second Wife
Deianne Schulz — Key Witness
Detective Doug Williamson — Lead Investigator
Detective Charlie Cox — Partner Investigator