TLDR
This 20/20 investigation examines the disappearances of two teenage girls in Putnam County, New York — Josette Wright (12) in October 1994 and Robin Murphy (17) in April 1995 — and the wrongful convictions of Anthony DePippo and Andy Krivak for Josette's murder. The case unravels when DePippo, from prison, discovers that Howard Gombert, the last person to see Robin alive, was also a suspect in Josette's case and a serial sexual predator. Gombert is later convicted of assaulting his partner Jane and her 7-year-old daughter Sarah, and police find Robin's underwear with her DNA in Gombert's possession. DePippo and Krivak are eventually exonerated after serving 20+ years, winning multi-million dollar settlements, but Robin Murphy remains missing after 30 years, with volunteer divers still searching the Tilly Foster mine where Gombert may have dumped her body. Gombert is due for release soon, terrifying his survivors.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The police initially dismissed both disappearances as runaways despite the girls' distinct profiles — Josette was a 12-year-old who loved Disney and Mickey Mouse, Robin a 17-year-old with a job and plans to leave town.
DePippo's trial lawyer had previously represented Gombert on sex crime charges involving a 13-year-old and a 19-year-old, but never disclosed this conflict of interest to DePippo.
Gombert tried to kill himself a week after Robin disappeared, telling a reporter it was over a custody battle, but later admitted the police questioning about Robin was 'the final push.'
The van where the prosecution claimed Josette was raped and murdered was described as 'an ashtray on wheels' with filthy shag carpet and beer bottles, yet no trace of Josette's DNA was ever found in it.
A psychic led police to the Tilly Foster mine by claiming to see a 'little light' there, and volunteer divers have since searched it 419 times based partly on that lead.
Gombert kept a meticulously organized 'trophy collection' — underwear in Ziploc bags labeled with victims' names and dates, jewelry, purses, and Polaroids — hidden in a tan suitcase and at his father's house.
Key takeaways
Two girls vanished six months apart in the same small town, but police initially treated them as runaways rather than potential victims of a serial predator.
Anthony DePippo and Andy Krivak were wrongfully convicted of Josette Wright's 1994 murder based on a coerced confession and the testimony of Denise Rose, a witness with credibility issues who only came forward after facing her own charges.
Howard Gombert, a laundromat attendant who was the last person to see Robin Murphy alive, emerged as the likely perpetrator in both cases after DePippo discovered Gombert's name repeatedly in witness statements while studying his case file in prison.
Gombert had a documented history of sexual violence against minors, including assaulting a 12-year-old when he was 16, and later his partner's 7-year-old daughter Sarah and the partner herself, Jane, during a three-day siege.
Police found Robin Murphy's underwear with her DNA in a hidden suitcase at Gombert's Connecticut home, along with labeled trophies from other victims and newspaper clippings about Robin's disappearance, but Gombert was never charged in her case.
DePippo and Krivak were exonerated in separate retrials (2016 and 2020) after defense teams presented Gombert as the alternative suspect and introduced testimony from Gombert's victims Sarah and Jane, plus jailhouse informant Joe Santoro who claimed Gombert confessed to both murders.
The men won $12 million and $20 million settlements from Putnam County, though the county admitted no wrongdoing, and Andy Krivak's release came 24 years after his arrest.
Robin Murphy has never been found; volunteer technical divers have conducted 419 dives in the 500-foot-deep Tilly Foster mine, discovering a Doc Martens boot matching Robin's missing footwear, but her body remains missing as Gombert's potential release approaches.
Notable quotes
“The longer I searched, the more focused I was. I became fixated on finding her. Today could be the day, and it kept me going, kept me coming back here.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:01“The first words out of Josette Wright's mother's mouth were: 'Howard Gombert killed my daughter.'”
▸ Notable quotes · 37:51“He actually sodomized me and then he actually took pictures with a camera that like the instant cameras and he took his nasty white tank top off and he shoved it in my mouth.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:05“If you scream if you tell anybody and um i did not say anything and it actually happened again.”
▸ Notable quotes · 47:22“I was at one point a victim. At one point, I am not. I am Sarah. That's who I am.”
▸ Notable quotes · 58:46“The not knowing is a nightmare because you can never close that wound. You can't grieve totally. You can't bury it. It's just always that question mark.”
▸ Notable quotes · 65:35Chapters
0:00 — Robin Murphy's Disappearance: Robin Murphy, 17, vanishes from a Carmel shopping center on April 9, 1995 after meeting Howard Gombert at the laundromat. Her car is found parked at Burger King where her boyfriend Matt worked, but she never meets him. Friends and family organize searches, finding her personal items in woods behind the plaza.
16:00 — Josette Wright's Murder and Wrongful Convictions: Six months earlier, 12-year-old Josette Wright disappeared walking home. Her remains are found 13 months later by hunters on Fields Lane, bound and with underwear in her mouth. Anthony DePippo and Andy Krivak are convicted based on a coerced confession and testimony from Denise Rose, despite no physical evidence linking them to the crime scene.
34:00 — DePippo Discovers Howard Gombert from Prison: While studying his case file in prison, DePippo notices Howard Gombert's name repeatedly in witness statements. Gombert was the last person to see Robin Murphy and had been accused of sexual assault by multiple girls. Josette's mother had immediately named Gombert as her daughter's killer.
38:00 — Gombert's Pattern of Sexual Violence Revealed: Multiple women come forward alleging Gombert assaulted them as children. His partner Jane describes a three-day siege of sexual violence; her daughter Sarah recounts being abused at age 7 in a 'ritualistic' clearing in the woods. Gombert is convicted and sentenced to 30 years for these crimes.
52:00 — Physical Evidence Links Gombert to Robin Murphy: Police search Gombert's Connecticut home and find a hidden suitcase with labeled underwear — one pair contains Robin Murphy's DNA. Also found: jewelry, purses, Polaroids, and a manila folder of newspaper clippings about Robin's disappearance. Gombert's thumbprint is on Robin's driver's license found near the laundromat.
60:00 — Exoneration and Settlements: DePippo wins a new trial based on his lawyer's conflict of interest (having represented Gombert). At retrial, defense presents Gombert's victims and jailhouse informant Joe Santoro who claims Gombert confessed to both murders. DePippo acquitted in 2016; Krivak in 2020. They win $12M and $20M settlements.
71:00 — Ongoing Search for Robin Murphy: Volunteer technical divers have conducted 419 dives in the 500-foot Tilly Foster mine, a former dumping ground. They find a Doc Martens boot matching Robin's missing footwear, renewing hope. Gombert is due for release soon, terrifying survivors. A task force has been formed to reinvestigate both cold cases.
Speakers
Paul Solitaroff — Host/Reporter
Anthony DePippo — Exoneree
Andy Krivak — Exoneree
Howard Gombert — Suspect/Convicted Sex Offender
Sarah — Survivor/Victim
Jane — Survivor/Victim
Joe Santoro — Jailhouse Informant
Deborah Roberts / David Muir — 20/20 Anchors