TLDR
Annie Elise and Amy Cole cover seven true crime updates: David (D4VD) appears depressed at a status hearing with trial aimed for early 2027; Nolan Wells' friends' Snapchat messages show concern but no clear cover-up despite a grand jury clearing them; Timothy Hudson's trial for killing stepsister Anna Kepner is delayed to January 2027 with a possible plea deal; Bella Torres fought off a home intruder in Arizona whose attorney claims her husband posted a Reddit role-play ad; David Prevatt's murder trial ends in mistrial after seven jurors committed misconduct; Matthew Stone Sr. killed eight family members in Erie, PA, after a history of control and domestic violence; Metallica Harrison murdered her husband and 3-year-old son at Great Wolf Lodge after a three-week stay that appears premeditated. The hosts also announce $111,000 in donations this year.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The same handgun from a 2019 domestic violence case (charges dropped) was used seven years later to kill eight family members in Erie.
A 20-year-old intruder claimed the victim's husband recruited him via Reddit for a 'rape role-play' scenario, and the judge ruled that even if true, it's not a legal defense.
Metallica Harrison told paramedics she took blood thinners to bleed out faster and was frustrated her blood was clotting, showing calculated premeditation alongside her alleged suicidal ideation.
Seven jurors in the David Prevatt trial were removed for discussing his criminal history and racism allegations not presented in court, forcing a mistrial due to insufficient alternates.
Key takeaways
David's demeanor shifted dramatically at his October 19 status hearing — clean-shaven, no glasses, hunched over, and looking 'depressed, sad, and almost hopeless' compared to his previous smiling, joking appearances, which the hosts interpret as reality setting in as evidence mounts.
The 300-page forensic report on Nolan Wells includes Snapchat messages from July 5-6 where friends express genuine worry ('Nolan, where the fuck are you, dog? Coast Guards are on the search for you') and discuss getting attorneys, but Annie reads the full messages and sees no cover-up narrative, noting many deleted messages could be Snapchat's disappearing feature.
A Mississippi grand jury already found no criminal wrongdoing in Nolan Wells' death, and legal analysts say the new messages don't change that, though Nolan's father maintains his son wouldn't have stayed behind on the island voluntarily.
Timothy Hudson's attorneys filed a second continuance motion citing an unspecified 'outstanding issue' before he decides on a plea or trial; prosecutors didn't oppose it, and the judge set trial for January 25, 2027, with a January 15 plea deadline — Annie predicts a plea deal given the sealed evidence.
In the Bella Torres home invasion, the intruder Adrian Ayala claimed on video 'Your boyfriend sent me. I met him on Reddit' and said the husband told him Bella would be into a rape role-play; the judge rejected this as a defense, but police seized the husband's phone to check for Reddit posts.
Matthew Stone Sr. used the same handgun from a 2019 domestic violence incident (charges dropped after Michelle changed her statement) to kill his wife, three adult children, two grandchildren, and two other relatives in Erie; his pregnant daughter Angelina had packed bags and texted that her father was kicking them out and had been physically abusive to her brothers.
Metallica Harrison brought 12 teal-handled knives from home (two recovered at the scene, ten found in a search of their house), cashed out her 401k, and stayed at Great Wolf Lodge for nearly three weeks at $300/night before stabbing her husband and son; relatives described her as controlling, jealous of her son, and isolating Charles from his family.
Notable quotes
“He reportedly looked very different than how he had looked in his past hearings. In other hearings, even the prelim a couple of months ago, he seemed kind of happy, he was smiling, he was joking with his attorneys, and really just seemed like he didn't even have a single care in the world. However, this time, people who were in the courtroom said he was the complete opposite. His face was clean-shaven, he wasn't wearing his glasses, his hair had gotten longer. Some people said he even looked like he had some gray hair in there now, but he was sitting kind of like hunched over, slouched down a little bit in his chair, and his facial expressions reportedly looked depressed, sad, and almost hopeless, which I love that for him.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:17“All I keep seeing is white folk made it home and the one black kid didn't.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:09“He understood from the victim's boyfriend that this is something that they did and that the victim was consenting to it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:20“I don't care if her husband said that he could go in there and do that. That is not a defense. That is problematic.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:27“Every day I work so hard to be the best person, the best mother, the best wife. It wasn't supposed to end like this. I was supposed to have my happy family. That's what I envisioned since I was a child.”
▸ Notable quotes · 44:28“Yesterday, I totaled up what we've been do what we have donated so far this year, $111,000.”
▸ Notable quotes · 51:01Chapters
0:46 — Podcast Intro & Case Overview: Annie Elise welcomes listeners and co-host Amy Cole, previewing updates on seven cases: D4VD, Nolan Wells, Anna Kepner, Bella Torres home invasion, David Prevatt mistrial, Erie family massacre, and Great Wolf Lodge double murder.
4:27 — D4VD Status Hearing Update: David appeared in court on October 19 for a brief status hearing; trial targeted for February-March 2027 with a January 11 status date. His demeanor shifted from smiling and joking to clean-shaven, no glasses, hunched over, and looking hopeless, which the hosts welcome as evidence mounts.
11:07 — Nolan Wells Forensic Report & Texts: A 300-page forensic report released Snapchat messages from July 5-6 showing friends searching for Nolan, discussing attorneys, and one racial comment. A grand jury found no criminal wrongdoing; Annie reads the messages as genuine concern, not a cover-up, though deleted messages remain a question.
22:21 — Anna Kepner Case Delay: Timothy Hudson's trial delayed again to January 25, 2027, with a January 15 plea deadline. Attorneys cite an unspecified outstanding issue; prosecutors didn't oppose. Hosts speculate a plea deal is likely given the evidence.
25:43 — Bella Torres Home Invasion: On October 16, Adrian Ayala entered Bella Torres' Arizona home, attacked her and her 1-year-old, and claimed her husband sent him via Reddit for a rape role-play. Police seized the husband's phone; the judge rejected the role-play claim as a defense. Ayala released on $25,000 bond.
33:39 — David Prevatt Mistrial: David Prevatt's 2017 murder trial ended in mistrial after seven jurors discussed his criminal history and racism allegations not in evidence. The judge removed all seven, but insufficient alternates forced a mistrial.
36:13 — Erie Family Massacre: Matthew Stone Sr. killed eight family members on October 9, including his wife, three adult children, two grandchildren, and two relatives. History of control, 2019 domestic violence (same gun used), and pregnant daughter Angelina planning to leave. ShotSpotter detected gunfire three minutes after aunt and friend arrived.
42:40 — Great Wolf Lodge Double Murder: Metallica Harrison stabbed husband Charles and 3-year-old son after a three-week stay at Great Wolf Lodge. She brought knives from home, cashed out 401k, and told paramedics she took blood thinners. Relatives describe her as controlling and jealous of her son. Charged with two counts of criminal homicide, denied bail.
Speakers
Annie Elise — Host
Amy Cole — Co-host