Ezra Klein Is An Ass

Original Media · 31m · English · YouTube · The Majority Report w/ Sam Seder

TLDR

Two left-leaning political commentators dissect the 2022 midterm results, arguing that progressive candidates like Abdul El-Sayed, Angie Nixon, and Victoria Brderick overperformed despite active sabotage from the Democratic establishment (Schumer, Pelosi, DSCC, AIPAC). They contend Ezra Klein and other pundits are manufacturing a 'progressives underperformed' narrative to protect the moderate consultant class and preserve the electability argument used to marginalize the left.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Democratic strategists and Republican strategists *agreed* privately that Democrats would have won Florida if the national party had invested in Angie Nixon — but publicly the establishment claims her race was unwinnable.

•

Chuck Schumer's DSCC recruited Haley Stevens, who then endorsed the Republican (Mike Rogers) in the final days to kneecap the progressive nominee Abdul El-Sayed — and the party let it happen.

•

Troy Jackson, a working-class logger running in Maine, was pressured by Schumer-aligned consultants to soften his message; after a Rebecca Traister piece exposed this, he leaned back into Medicare for All and his authentic persona, and the race tightened.

•

Victoria Brderick, a tech support worker who couldn't take Election Day off, flipped a Trump+24 Tennessee district while being outspent 12.5-to-1 in the primary — with zero DC help.

Key takeaways

•

Democratic establishment figures (Pelosi, Schumer, Haley Stevens) actively undermined progressive nominees like Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan and Angie Nixon in Florida before the general election.

•

Progressive candidates overperformed relative to investment: Angie Nixon came within 3 points of flipping Florida with almost no national support; Victoria Brderick won a Trump+24 district in Tennessee with <$100k.

•

The 'electability' narrative is selectively applied: moderate candidates like Sherrod Brown ($150M spent, won by 5 pts) and Josh Turk ($67M, won by 4 pts) underperformed relative to massive spending, but face no scrutiny.

•

Black voters turned out enthusiastically for progressive candidates (Nixon, Scott Cole, Annie Andrews), contradicting the establishment's use of older Black voters as a cudgel against the left.

•

Populist economic messaging (billionaire taxes, Medicare for All, universal childcare) is now standard even for 'moderate' Democrats like Tester and Roy Cooper, showing the Overton window has shifted since 2016.

•

National Democrats would rather preserve the AIPAC/Third Way factional playbook — using Islamophobia and 'electability' to divide the base — than invest in transformative candidates who threaten consultant revenue streams.

Notable quotes

“They had already preset and were attempting to manufacture the narrative via this point shaving that Haley Stevens engaged in that Pelosi engaged in... They were already focused on making sure that he did not overperform so they could set a narrative that his kind of politics wouldn't work.”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:10

“All of them agreed, left or right, that Democrats would have won in Florida had the national powers that be put in more money and effort. And the sources weren't phrasing it generally as may have won or likely would have won. They boldly claim Dems would have won period.”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:36

“You think that Schumer was motivated to invest in her race to have a black DSA member firebrand like herself... who would have been another vote that would have said, 'I don't really think Schumer is a good pick for leader'? You think that he would have been motivated to get her elected?”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:41

“It turns out like having populist uh candidates that are somewhat against the status quo means that you're not working with the status quo, which surprise makes it a little bit more difficult.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:16

“The labeling is incredibly motivated. This is an attempt to reclaim the moderate label when we're not looking at the actual substance of the rhetoric, which indicates the exact opposite that politics have indelibly changed since Bernie Sanders ran in 2016.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:15

“Angie Nixon swung Latino voters by 20 points... and that includes Cuban Americans who we were told that a candidate like her could never have success in that election.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:48

Chapters

•

0:00 — Ezra Klein's Post-Midterm Narrative Critiqued: Hosts open by criticizing Ezra Klein's claim that progressives underperformed in the midterms, noting his past praise for Charlie Kirk and his attack on Ta-Nehisi Coates. They argue Klein is parroting a pre-set establishment narrative designed to protect the 'electability' myth.

•

2:02 — Michigan: Establishment Sabotage of Abdul El-Sayed: Details how Pelosi, Haley Stevens, and Slotkin undermined El-Sayed in the primary's final days — Stevens even endorsing the Republican — to engineer an underperformance that would discredit Medicare for All and anti-AIPAC positions.

•

4:36 — Florida: Angie Nixon's Overperformance Despite Neglect: Analyzes the Florida Senate race where Angie Nixon, a Black DSA member, came within 3 points of winning with virtually no national investment. Private strategists confirm Dems would have won with funding, but Schumer chose to preserve the AIPAC factional playbook instead.

•

26:00 — Maine & Tennessee: Populist Authenticity vs. Consultant Class: Contrasts Troy Jackson (pressured by DC consultants, then rebounded by leaning into his working-class identity) with Victoria Brderick (a tech worker who flipped a Trump+24 district with $100k and no institutional support), showing populist authenticity wins where consultant-driven campaigns fail.

•

14:35 — The Shifting Overton Window and Bad-Faith 'Moderate' Labeling: Argues that even 'moderate' Democrats now run on Bernie-style populism (billionaire taxes, universal childcare), but pundits like Klein retroactively label them moderate to deny the left credit. The 'moderate' label is a motivated fiction.

Speakers

•

Host 1 — Political commentator / podcast co-host

•

Host 2 — Political commentator / podcast co-host

⋮