TLDR
Two hosts react to The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014) in real-time, praising Andrew Garfield's performance and the Gwen Stacy death scene as franchise highs, while criticizing the overstuffed plot, underdeveloped villains, and unnecessary parent storyline. They rank it a strong 7-7.5/10 and express regret over the canceled Amazing Spider-Man 3.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The hosts reveal Andrew Garfield advocated for a gay/bisexual Peter Parker with Michael B. Jordan as MJ
Sony had already flown Garfield out to announce Amazing Spider-Man 3 before canceling it with him present
The film's Times Square sequence was shot on location, not green screen, contributing to its visual quality
The closet is a deliberate metaphor for Peter's secrets and repressed identity ("people keep secrets in the closet")
The hosts prefer this film's 'nines and twos' approach over Homecoming's consistent 'sevens and eights'
Key takeaways
Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man is considered the most comic-accurate and three-dimensional portrayal, blending Peter Parker and Spider-Man seamlessly
The Gwen Stacy death sequence is regarded as one of the best 10 minutes in any live-action Spider-Man film
The film suffers from 'Spider-Man 3 syndrome' — too many villains (Electro, Green Goblin, Rhino) and plotlines (parents, Oscorp, romance) crammed into one movie
Electro's characterization loses depth after his Times Square scene, becoming a generic mustache-twirling villain
The parent subplot adds nothing and should have been cut to streamline the film
Dane DeHaan's Harry Osborn is praised as superior casting to James Franco's version
The visual effects, suit design, and action sequences hold up better than most MCU films
The hosts pitch a Safdie brothers-directed Spider-Man 3 with Robert Pattinson as Harry Osborn adapting Kraven's Last Hunt
Notable quotes
“He's Spider-Man. He is Spider-Man. Like he is the When I'm reading a comic, I'm like, this is Andrew Garfield doing all like the best”
▸ Notable quotes · 68:57“This movie simultaneously has the highest highs and lowest lows.”
▸ Notable quotes · 59:19“Every scene of them is a scene of scenes. works, yeah. And the movie that was the attempt at the choice I was saying that I wish the movie was leaning more into of him being like nothing's working.”
▸ Notable quotes · 47:39“I would put him on the Rushmore of casting. Like he's one of the best comic book castings period.”
▸ Notable quotes · 72:49“The highs out here completely outweigh Homecoming.”
▸ Notable quotes · 70:41“Safdie brothers Spider-Man would be crazy. Stress, pressure, stress, and I'd watch that Spider-Man.”
▸ Notable quotes · 86:40Chapters
0:00 — Opening Reactions & Movie Setup: Hosts discuss their history with the film, previous viewings, and initial impressions of the opening plane sequence and parent spy storyline.
5:00 — Spider-Man Action & Peter/Gwen Dynamics: Reaction to the Times Square rescue sequence, Spider-Man suit praise, and the chemistry between Garfield and Stone during their breakup/ground rules scene.
15:00 — Electro's Origin & Harry Osborn's Return: Max Dillon's transformation into Electro, Harry Osborn's introduction (Dane DeHaan), and the Osborn family curse storyline.
40:00 — Ravencroft & Villain Problems: Critique of the Ravencroft scenes as 'Batman & Robin' tone, Electro's loss of depth, and Harry's desperate turn to villainy.
43:20 — Parent Subplot & Aunt May Scenes: Peter discovers his father's secret lab, the 'Roosevelt Station' revelation, and emotional Aunt May moments that work despite the parent plot.
56:40 — Climax: Electro, Goblin & Gwen's Death: Power plant battle with Electro, Green Goblin's brief appearance, the clock tower sequence, and the iconic Gwen Stacy death faithful to the comics.
65:00 — Aftermath & Ending: Peter's grief, the 5-month time jump, Gwen's graduation speech bookend, and the Rhino tease for the canceled sequel.
68:20 — Ranking, Viewer Questions & Dream Pitches: Hosts debate ranking vs other Spider-Man films (7-7.5/10), answer audience questions, and pitch a Safdie brothers Spider-Man 3 with Robert Pattinson as Harry.
Speakers
Greg — Co-host
Coy — Co-host