THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN 2 REACTION – This Is BETTER Than Homecoming! I SAID IT – ROAD TO DOOMSDAY

Original Media · 1h 38m · English · YouTube · Reel Rejects

TLDR

Two hosts react to The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014) in real-time, praising Andrew Garfield's performance and the Gwen Stacy death scene as franchise highs, while criticizing the overstuffed plot, underdeveloped villains, and unnecessary parent storyline. They rank it a strong 7-7.5/10 and express regret over the canceled Amazing Spider-Man 3.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The hosts reveal Andrew Garfield advocated for a gay/bisexual Peter Parker with Michael B. Jordan as MJ

•

Sony had already flown Garfield out to announce Amazing Spider-Man 3 before canceling it with him present

•

The film's Times Square sequence was shot on location, not green screen, contributing to its visual quality

•

The closet is a deliberate metaphor for Peter's secrets and repressed identity ("people keep secrets in the closet")

•

The hosts prefer this film's 'nines and twos' approach over Homecoming's consistent 'sevens and eights'

Key takeaways

•

Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man is considered the most comic-accurate and three-dimensional portrayal, blending Peter Parker and Spider-Man seamlessly

•

The Gwen Stacy death sequence is regarded as one of the best 10 minutes in any live-action Spider-Man film

•

The film suffers from 'Spider-Man 3 syndrome' — too many villains (Electro, Green Goblin, Rhino) and plotlines (parents, Oscorp, romance) crammed into one movie

•

Electro's characterization loses depth after his Times Square scene, becoming a generic mustache-twirling villain

•

The parent subplot adds nothing and should have been cut to streamline the film

•

Dane DeHaan's Harry Osborn is praised as superior casting to James Franco's version

•

The visual effects, suit design, and action sequences hold up better than most MCU films

•

The hosts pitch a Safdie brothers-directed Spider-Man 3 with Robert Pattinson as Harry Osborn adapting Kraven's Last Hunt

Notable quotes

“He's Spider-Man. He is Spider-Man. Like he is the When I'm reading a comic, I'm like, this is Andrew Garfield doing all like the best”

▸ Notable quotes · 68:57

“This movie simultaneously has the highest highs and lowest lows.”

▸ Notable quotes · 59:19

“Every scene of them is a scene of scenes. works, yeah. And the movie that was the attempt at the choice I was saying that I wish the movie was leaning more into of him being like nothing's working.”

▸ Notable quotes · 47:39

“I would put him on the Rushmore of casting. Like he's one of the best comic book castings period.”

▸ Notable quotes · 72:49

“The highs out here completely outweigh Homecoming.”

▸ Notable quotes · 70:41

“Safdie brothers Spider-Man would be crazy. Stress, pressure, stress, and I'd watch that Spider-Man.”

▸ Notable quotes · 86:40

Chapters

•

0:00 — Opening Reactions & Movie Setup: Hosts discuss their history with the film, previous viewings, and initial impressions of the opening plane sequence and parent spy storyline.

•

5:00 — Spider-Man Action & Peter/Gwen Dynamics: Reaction to the Times Square rescue sequence, Spider-Man suit praise, and the chemistry between Garfield and Stone during their breakup/ground rules scene.

•

15:00 — Electro's Origin & Harry Osborn's Return: Max Dillon's transformation into Electro, Harry Osborn's introduction (Dane DeHaan), and the Osborn family curse storyline.

•

40:00 — Ravencroft & Villain Problems: Critique of the Ravencroft scenes as 'Batman & Robin' tone, Electro's loss of depth, and Harry's desperate turn to villainy.

•

43:20 — Parent Subplot & Aunt May Scenes: Peter discovers his father's secret lab, the 'Roosevelt Station' revelation, and emotional Aunt May moments that work despite the parent plot.

•

56:40 — Climax: Electro, Goblin & Gwen's Death: Power plant battle with Electro, Green Goblin's brief appearance, the clock tower sequence, and the iconic Gwen Stacy death faithful to the comics.

•

65:00 — Aftermath & Ending: Peter's grief, the 5-month time jump, Gwen's graduation speech bookend, and the Rhino tease for the canceled sequel.

•

68:20 — Ranking, Viewer Questions & Dream Pitches: Hosts debate ranking vs other Spider-Man films (7-7.5/10), answer audience questions, and pitch a Safdie brothers Spider-Man 3 with Robert Pattinson as Harry.

Speakers

•

Greg — Co-host

•

Coy — Co-host

⋮