TLDR
2020 The After Show examines the disappearances of Josette Wright (12) and Robin Murphy (17) from Carmel, New York in 1994-95. Two men, Anthony DePippo and Andrew Krivick, were convicted for Josette's elaborately staged murder but acquitted at retrial after two decades in prison. The defense pointed to Howard Gombert — who sexually assaulted a 7-year-old girl, Sarah, with striking similarities to Josette's binding — as an alternate suspect. Gombert, nearing release after 30 years, has never been charged in Josette's case. Investigative journalist Paul Solitaroff calls for a special prosecutor appointed by NY Attorney General Tish James and Governor Kathy Hochul to reopen both cases.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A teenage girl's uncorroborated eyewitness testimony was enough to convict two teenagers of a sadistic murder despite a total absence of forensic evidence at the crime scene.
The defense strategy of introducing an alternate suspect (Gombert) relied on a survivor (Sarah) voluntarily testifying about her own childhood sexual assault to help free two men she didn't know.
Howard Gombert picked out a leopard-print two-piece bathing suit for his 7-year-old victim before assaulting her in a pre-scouted woodland clearing — behavior suggesting premeditation and prior experience.
Key takeaways
Josette Wright's remains were found elaborately staged: hands bound behind her back connected to a noose around her throat and one leg, so she could barely walk but would strangle herself if she resisted; her underwear was stuffed down her windpipe and her bra tied as a blindfold — indicating a practiced sadist.
Anthony DePippo and Andrew Krivick, teenagers with minor drug histories but no violent records, were convicted largely on a teenage girl's eyewitness testimony placing them in a van with Josette, despite zero forensic evidence (DNA, blood, semen, hairs) linking them to the crime scene.
Both men spent roughly 20 years in New York's harshest prisons (Attica, Dannemora) where child murderers face extreme violence; DePippo, a ninth-grade dropout, taught himself law in the prison library and drove the appeals that led to their acquittals at retrial.
Sarah, assaulted at age 7 by Howard Gombert, testified at DePippo's third trial because Gombert bound her hands in front of her and shoved a tank top in her mouth — mirroring Josette's binding and gagging. She chose to testify despite trauma, saying: 'If me speaking out could help these two men get out of prison... why wouldn't I?'
Howard Gombert is serving the final months of a 30-year sentence for assaulting Sarah and has never been charged in Josette's murder, though the Putnam County DA calls him 'reprehensible' but cites insufficient evidence. A new task force has been formed to re-examine both girls' cases.
Paul Solitaroff, after speaking with Gombert in prison, argues there is 'absolutely no hope of justice in Putnam County organically' and urges public pressure on NY Attorney General Tish James and Governor Kathy Hochul to appoint a special prosecutor with authority to reinvestigate from the beginning.
Notable quotes
“Elaborately bound, gagged and blindfolded, it was clearly the work of a practiced sadist.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:16“A part of me got silenced. Because he tried to silence you.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:55“If me speaking out and saying my story could help these two men get out of prison, you know, they were young guys at the time, why wouldn't I?”
▸ Notable quotes · 17:13“I am also a woman who needs him to know that it's not over. There's no way you're going to just walk free and that's the end of the story.”
▸ Notable quotes · 18:26“I was and remain so enraged, so, so haunted, not so much by what he did but by the suffering that lives on in history.”
▸ Notable quotes · 21:06“There is absolutely no hope of justice in Putnam County organically. It must come from without.”
▸ Notable quotes · 22:37Chapters
0:11 — Case Overview: Two Missing Girls: Deborah Roberts introduces the 1994-95 disappearances of Josette Wright (12) and Robin Murphy (17) from Carmel, NY, and welcomes investigative journalist Paul Solitaroff.
5:11 — Josette's Staged Murder & Wrongful Convictions: Paul details the elaborate staging of Josette's remains, the lack of forensic evidence against DePippo and Krivick, their 20-year imprisonment, and eventual acquittal at retrial.
9:18 — Survivor Sarah's Testimony: Sarah recounts her assault at age 7 by Howard Gombert, the parallels to Josette's binding, her decision to testify at DePippo's trial, and her ongoing fight as Gombert nears release.
19:52 — Paul's Prison Call with Gombert & Call to Action: Paul describes his heated phone conversation with Gombert in prison and urges viewers to pressure NY AG Tish James and Governor Hochul to appoint a special prosecutor.
Speakers
Deborah Roberts — Host
Paul Solitaroff — Investigative Journalist
Sarah — Survivor / Witness
John Quiñones — Correspondent