TLDR
Republican Senator John Kennedy bluntly tells his party that the 2022 midterm losses were far worse than a normal historical swing — a 13% vote shift versus the typical 7% — and calls any Republican who claims otherwise "stupid." In a separate Fox News appearance, Kennedy uses a bizarre urination analogy to argue Republicans should stop creating self-inflicted problems and then congratulate themselves for partial fixes. Host David Pakman agrees with Kennedy's election analysis but notes the senator still advocates for conservative policies, just ones voters find useful rather than blindly following Trump. The episode highlights growing open conflict within the GOP over whether leadership understands why voters rejected them. The segment ends with a sponsor read for Incognito, a data-removal service.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A staunchly conservative Republican senator used the word "stupid" on the record to describe colleagues who downplay the midterm loss, violating the party's usual code of public unity.
Kennedy's chosen metaphor for Republican self-sabotage involved detailed urination mechanics — "a wise man doesn't urinate on his hands" — delivered seriously on a major cable news program.
Key takeaways
Senator John Kennedy (R-LA) publicly broke with Republican talking points by declaring the 2022 midterm results were not a normal historical fluctuation but an unusually large 13% swing toward Democrats, nearly double the typical 7% midterm shift.
Kennedy explicitly called fellow Republicans "stupid" for pretending the loss was ordinary, arguing the scale and specific locations of defeats — such as competitive races in Texas and Mississippi — signaled a clear voter rejection that the party refuses to acknowledge.
The Republican Party has organized itself entirely around Donald Trump's instincts, grievances, and personal survival, leaving it unable to admit failure or adjust course even when voters deliver a clear rebuke at the ballot box.
Kennedy's Fox News appearance featured a strange analogy about urination and hand-washing to illustrate his point: Republicans should stop creating messes (arson) and then demand credit for inadequate cleanup (a cup of water on a massive fire).
Despite his blunt assessment, Kennedy is not urging the GOP to abandon conservatism; he argues the party should pursue conservative policies that voters actually find useful rather than assuming whatever Trump wants will be popular.
Open disagreement is emerging within the GOP about whether party leadership understands the magnitude of the defeat and whether the current direction is sustainable, marking a shift from the unified denial seen in previous election cycles.
Notable quotes
“Republicans lost. Democrats won. The American people have decided. This was not a normal midterm election. If you have concluded otherwise. Congratulations. You're stupid.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:53“Normally there's about a seven vote swing. In this case you would normal circumstances. It would be a seven vote swing in favor of the Democrats in this election. There was a 13 vote, 13% swing.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:21“What a smart man washes his hands after he urinates. A wise man doesn't urinate on his hands.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:38“If you're the arsonist who set the fire, you don't get a medal from the fire department for them throwing a cup of water on the massive fire that you started.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:27“The Republican Party has organized itself around the instincts of one guy, the grievances of one guy, the personal survival of one guy, and now there's consequences to that which our voters rejected him.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:59Chapters
0:00 — Kennedy's blunt midterm assessment: Senator John Kennedy declares the 2022 midterms were not a normal historical swing, citing a 13% vote shift versus the typical 7%, and calls Republicans who claim otherwise "stupid."
2:54 — Pakman analyzes the scale and geography of losses: Host David Pakman expands on Kennedy's point, emphasizing that the magnitude of defeat and specific losses in Republican strongholds like Texas and Mississippi confirm this was not a routine midterm correction.
3:43 — Trump's role in preventing honest reckoning: Pakman argues Trump has created an environment where admitting failure is forbidden, forcing Republicans to deny reality or blame fraud rather than confront voter rejection.
4:22 — Kennedy's bizarre Fox News urination analogy: Kennedy appears on Fox News and uses an extended metaphor about urination and hand-washing to argue Republicans should stop creating self-inflicted problems and then seek credit for inadequate solutions.
5:32 — The arsonist analogy and policy implications: Pakman reframes Kennedy's point with an arsonist metaphor, noting Kennedy still supports conservative policies but wants them to be voter-responsive rather than dictated by Trump's personal preferences.
6:17 — GOP identity crisis and sponsor segment: The episode concludes with Pakman observing open Republican infighting over whether leadership understands the defeat, followed by a sponsor read for Incognito data-removal service.
Speakers
David Pakman — Host
John Kennedy — U.S. Senator (R-LA)
Sean Hannity — Fox News host