Young Thug’s Attorney Arrested! Buster Murdaugh Sues Netflix. Alec Baldwin Rust Trial Update TES 286

Original Media · 41m · English · YouTube · Emily D. Baker

TLDR

Emily D. Baker covers three major legal developments: New Mexico prosecutors seek use immunity to compel Hannah Gutierrez-Reed's testimony at Alec Baldwin's 'Rust' trial after she invoked the Fifth Amendment; in Georgia's Young Thug RICO case, the judge held defense attorney Brian Steel in contempt for refusing to reveal how he learned of an ex parte meeting between the judge, prosecutors, and a witness; and Buster Murdaugh filed a defamation lawsuit against Netflix, HBO Max, and others over documentaries implying he killed Stephen Smith. The Young Thug case has drawn Georgia Supreme Court intervention, while Murdaugh's suit was filed days before the statute of limitations expired on the first documentary. All three cases involve televised proceedings and high-profile defendants. Baker questions whether Murdaugh wants to invite discovery into the Smith death investigation.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Prosecutors sought use immunity for Gutierrez-Reed only after she asserted the Fifth Amendment in a May 2024 interview — despite her attorney Jason Bowles initially telling the prosecutor that use immunity would 'take care of any issues' and he would confirm the next day, but then never following up.

•

The judge in the Young Thug case personally presided over the contempt hearing for defense attorney Brian Steel after Steel refused to reveal his source about the ex parte meeting — even though the judge was a witness to the alleged contempt, which basic procedure says should be heard by a different judge.

•

The Georgia Supreme Court intervened via writ of certiorari (not a standard appeal) and granted a supersedeas bond within days, signaling unusual urgency in a case where the trial judge held the lead defense attorney in contempt during an ongoing capital RICO trial.

•

Buster Murdaugh's defamation suit names only one individual — Michael DeWitt Jr., editor of the Hampton County Guardian — among all the people who appeared in the documentaries, specifically for his on-camera statement that the paper 'did everything but put the Murdaugh name in the story.'

•

The statute of limitations on the first documentary ('Murdaugh Murders: Deadly Dynasty,' June 2022) expired three days after the suit was filed, meaning the complaint was timed to the very last moment to preserve claims against that production.

Key takeaways

•

Prosecutors in New Mexico filed a motion on June 14 seeking use immunity for Hannah Gutierrez-Reed so she can testify at Alec Baldwin's July trial without her statements being used against her in a potential retrial; Gutierrez-Reed previously waived her Fifth Amendment rights in 2021 interviews with law enforcement and OSHA but asserted the privilege during a May 2024 pre-trial interview when asked about Baldwin's behavior, firearms training, and whether she offered him a fake gun on the day of the shooting.

•

The state argues Gutierrez-Reed's prior statements already inculpate Baldwin — including that he was inattentive during training, used his phone during sessions, rushed her, and 'kind of does whatever he wants' as a producer — and that those statements were played at her trial and viewed by millions, so no new prejudice exists; the hearing on the immunity motion is set for June 21.

•

In the Young Thug RICO trial in Fulton County, Georgia, Judge Ural Glanville held an ex parte meeting on June 10 with prosecutors and witness Kenneth Copeland — who had been jailed for contempt after invoking the Fifth Amendment — after Copeland received use immunity; defense attorney Brian Steel learned of the meeting and moved for a mistrial, but the judge demanded Steel reveal his source, then held Steel in contempt (20 days on weekends) when he refused citing attorney work-product privilege.

•

The Georgia Supreme Court granted Steel a supersedeas bond, halting his incarceration while it reviews the contempt order via writ of certiorari; Steel and co-counsel filed a motion to disqualify the judge and for mistrial on June 17, arguing the ex parte communication violated due process and that the judge's reaction — 'you seem to know exactly what was happening in my Chambers' — confirms the meeting occurred as described.

•

Buster Murdaugh filed a defamation lawsuit on June 14, 2024 — three days before the two-year statute of limitations expired on the first documentary — against Netflix, Warner Bros. Discovery, HBO Max, production companies, and a local newspaper editor; the suit alleges three docuseries ('Murdaugh Murders: Deadly Dynasty,' 'Low Country: The Murdaugh Dynasty,' 'Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal') falsely imply Buster killed Stephen Smith with a baseball bat, motivated by a romantic relationship and Smith's sexual identity.

•

The complaint highlights that the Netflix series depicts a red-haired man with a baseball bat (Buster has red hair) and includes statements like 'everyone keeps coming up to me and saying it was the Murdaugh boys'; the Hampton County Guardian editor, Michael DeWitt Jr., is quoted in the Netflix series saying 'we did everything but put the Murdaugh name in the story,' which the suit argues makes the implication readily ascertainable.

•

Baker notes the Young Thug case has already lasted over a year with 60+ witnesses called, and a mistrial would be extraordinary; she also questions whether Buster Murdaugh wants to subject himself to discovery in a case where the Smith death is reportedly under review by a statewide grand jury, and where he has not been notified of any allegations by law enforcement.

Notable quotes

“the shit's kind of out of the horse on that one too”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:54

“shit's well out of the horse”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:08

“that's not how any of this works”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:51

“you seem to know exactly what was happening in my Chambers”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:47

“when someone's accusing you of eavesdropping doesn't it lend Credence to the argument that you knew exactly what was happening”

▸ Notable quotes · 24:45

“we did everything but put the murdon name in the story”

▸ Notable quotes · 36:42

Chapters

•

0:00 — Karen Reed trial update and New Mexico immunity motion: Baker opens with the Karen Reed trial entering week eight, then turns to New Mexico where prosecutor Carrie Morrissey filed a June 14 motion seeking use immunity for Hannah Gutierrez-Reed to testify at Alec Baldwin's July trial; Gutierrez-Reed previously waived Fifth Amendment rights in 2021 interviews but asserted the privilege in a May 2024 pre-trial interview on questions about Baldwin's conduct.

•

2:40 — Hannah Gutierrez-Reed's prior statements and immunity arguments: The state details Gutierrez-Reed's 2021 statements to law enforcement and OSHA inculpating Baldwin — including that he was inattentive during firearms training, used his phone, rushed her, and 'kind of does whatever he wants' as a producer — and argues those statements are already public from her trial; the defense never notified the state Gutierrez-Reed would invoke the Fifth, and her attorney initially agreed use immunity would resolve the issue but never followed up.

•

13:17 — Young Thug RICO case: ex parte meeting and contempt: In the massive Georgia RICO trial (28 indicted, 7 on trial since November 2023), Judge Glanville held an ex parte meeting on June 10 with prosecutors and witness Kenneth Copeland after Copeland received use immunity; defense attorney Brian Steel learned of the meeting, moved for mistrial, and was held in contempt (20 weekend days) for refusing to reveal his source, citing work-product privilege.

•

19:00 — Georgia Supreme Court intervention and defense motions: The Georgia Supreme Court granted Steel a supersedeas bond and took up the contempt via writ of certiorari; Steel filed a motion to disqualify the judge and for mistrial on June 17, arguing the ex parte communication violated due process and the judge's own reaction — 'you seem to know exactly what was happening in my Chambers' — confirms the meeting occurred; the judge should have recused from the contempt proceeding.

•

30:52 — Buster Murdaugh defamation lawsuit against Netflix and others: Buster Murdaugh sued Netflix, HBO Max/Warner Bros. Discovery, production companies, and a local newspaper editor on June 14 — three days before the statute of limitations expired on the first documentary — alleging three docuseries falsely imply he killed Stephen Smith with a baseball bat due to a romantic relationship; the suit highlights the Netflix depiction of a red-haired man with a bat and the editor's statement 'we did everything but put the Murdaugh name in the story.'

Speakers

•

Emily D. Baker — Host

⋮