The Animals On My Farm Kill Their Newborns | Creep Cast

Original Media · 1h 33m · English · YouTube · CreepCast

TLDR

Creep Cast hosts read and discuss two horror stories from their Tales from the Creeps subreddit: "Breathless" by The Republic, a poetic narrative from a hunted animal's perspective (likely a bison) fleeing human hunters in a historical setting, and "The Deer Pit" by Veridian Voidling, where a man discovers a massive bone pit containing a reanimated entity that has absorbed a missing exchange student named Heinrich. The hosts praise both stories' literary quality, ambiguity, and body horror, contrasting their subreddit's creative freedom with r/nosleep's restrictive rules.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The hosts reveal that r/nosleep banned a strong story because "not enough happened," showing the subreddit prioritizes plot mechanics over literary merit.

•

The Deer Pit's entity is implied to be a massive subterranean creature tunneling beneath the Appalachians, suggested by the ending where highway sounds resemble its movement — expanding the horror from a single pit to a regional threat.

•

Heinrich's uncle worked in roadkill removal for the Department of Transportation, creating a dark thematic parallel: the family that cleans dead animals from roads ultimately feeds their own kin to a pit that preserves the dead indefinitely.

Key takeaways

•

"Breathless" uses flowery, mid-century poetic language to depict an animal's terror as it's relentlessly hunted by humans with bows and arrows, emphasizing the creature's exhaustion and the unnatural persistence of its pursuers who never stop tracking it.

•

The hosts prefer Tales from the Creeps over r/nosleep because its lack of a mandatory first-person "this happened to me" framing allows writers to use third-person, historical, or non-human perspectives, resulting in more literary and creative horror.

•

"The Deer Pit" reveals a supernatural pit filled with bones that functions as a collective entity — the missing exchange student Heinrich has become part of it, his decayed body still animate and connected to a massive tunneling creature implied to span miles underground.

•

The Deer Pit story uses escalating body horror effectively: Heinrich emerges from the bone pile with maggot-infested flesh, phantom eyelids revealing his original emerald eyes, and his detached body parts continue attacking independently.

•

Both stories employ animal motifs — the first from the prey's POV, the second with deer leading the protagonist to the pit and the entity resembling an amalgamation of animal remains — creating a thematic link about humans as both hunters and hunted.

•

The hosts value horror that implies a deliberate design or "blueprint" without full explanation: the pit's purpose, the "her" at its core, whether it's a curse or natural phenomenon, and why it targets those who fear loss are left for audience speculation.

•

A previously featured author had a story banned from r/nosleep for "not enough happened," illustrating that subreddit's rigid enforcement of pacing rules versus Tales from the Creeps' focus on writing quality and atmosphere.

Notable quotes

“What What is with our viewers being mid-century poets?”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:39

“OXES CAN'T USE COMPUTERS. A GAZELLE FROM THE 1800s could never type like this.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:41

“This is pretty good. It's just like an animal running, being hunted by people.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:23

“It's over, Wanda. He's gone.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:44

“Juanita, there's something I haven't told you.”

▸ Notable quotes · 33:52

“To me that's like where the best horror is where you can tell there's a blueprint, but we don't get a look right at it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 90:28

Chapters

•

0:00 — Intro & Merch Promotion: Hosts promote limited-time merch including frog, dental photo, and Smile Dog shirts, thank audio listeners and patrons, and introduce the episode's two stories from Tales from the Creeps.

•

4:44 — Reading "Breathless": Host reads The Republic's story about an animal (likely a bison) fleeing human hunters across rivers, mountains, and deserts, describing the herd's ambush at a watering hole and the narrator's solitary, exhausting escape.

•

17:27 — Discussing "Breathless": Hosts analyze the story's poetic language, debate whether the narrator is animal or human, praise the subreddit's creative freedom over r/nosleep, and joke about the implausibility of a bison typing the story.

•

23:10 — Intro to "The Deer Pit": Hosts introduce Veridian Voidling's creature feature story, note the author's previous strong work, and express excitement for the animal-themed narrative.

•

24:14 — Reading "The Deer Pit": Host reads the story of a man revisiting a warm forest clearing from childhood, discovering a covered pit filled with bones, encountering the reanimated Heinrich, and escaping as a massive entity reveals itself.

•

80:40 — Discussing "The Deer Pit": Hosts dissect the story's body horror, ambiguity, and thematic depth: Heinrich's roadkill-removal uncle, the entity's tunneling scale, the "her" at its core, and the ending's implication that the creature follows the protagonist.

•

92:23 — Outro: Hosts praise both stories as home runs, encourage writers to join Tales from the Creeps for feedback, thank patrons and listeners, and sign off.

Speakers

•

Host 1 — Co-host

•

Host 2 — Co-host

⋮