TLDR
The Oak Island team examines a unique brooch possibly dating to 1500-1700 and linked to the 1746 Duc d'Anville French expedition. Blacksmith Carmen Legge identifies a decorative strap as a French "bowtie" chest fitting and a heavy iron piece as a probable mining chisel, both from Lot 5 where five ancient coins (three Roman, 500 AD–300 BC) were previously found. Researcher Zena Halpern shares 12th–14th century maps marking a hatch, valve, and anchors on Oak Island; the hatch location aligns with a depression Dave Blankenship discovered, which the team investigates at episode's end. The findings deepen the French/Templar connection and suggest pre-Money Pit activity on the island.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Roman coins from 500 AD–300 BC were found on a North American island whose recorded history begins in the late 18th century.
A French decorative chest strap (bowtie style) possibly predating the 1600s was recovered on Oak Island, suggesting French presence centuries before the 1746 Duc d'Anville expedition.
A 1347 map labels the Money Pit area as "the oak, enter here" and marks a hatch, valve, and anchors — features the team had never heard of but that align with later discoveries.
Family oral tradition recorded a hatch "you only have to sink a spade to find" with a warning not to get lost below, matching the map's hatch location.
The lead cross previously found on Oak Island was tested and its lead traced to southern France, independently corroborating the French connection indicated by the maps and artifacts.
Key takeaways
A brooch recovered on Oak Island may date from 1500–1700 and could be a French military badge, tying it to the 1746 Duc d'Anville fleet that sailed to Nova Scotia.
Three of five ancient coins found on Lot 5 in the past year are Roman (500 AD–300 BC), pushing the island's documented artifact record far earlier than the 1795 Money Pit discovery.
Blacksmith Carmen Legge identified a decorative metal strap as a French "bowtie" chest ornament, a style used on wooden chests and boxes, and dated it as possibly pre-17th century.
A heavy, hand-forged iron piece from Lot 5 was identified as the broken end of a mining or tunneling chisel approximately one foot long, with metallurgy showing no modern elements.
Zena Halpern's hand-drawn maps (dated 1179 and 1347) label Oak Island features in French — basin, marsh, dam, oak (enter here), anchors, valve, and hatch — several of which match known island geography.
The "hatch" on Halpern's map corresponds to a ground depression Dave Blankenship found near his property; the team located and examined this anomaly at the close of the episode.
Rick Lagina believes the original depositional work on Oak Island began "incredibly early" and that the French artifacts, lead cross (with lead sourced to southern France), and Halpern's maps point to a multilayered, pre-Money Pit history.
Carmen Legge stated the artifacts emerging from Oak Island are unique compared to anything he has seen elsewhere, underscoring the site's anomalous archaeological profile.
Notable quotes
“I think that's a brooch. You see the two raised areas the pin would've gone across?”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:19“I believe this is really, really old. What is really, really old? I think that's hundreds of years old. I wouldn't be surprised if this is anywhere between 1500 and 1700.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:54“It looks like a bowtie strap. You can see the bowtie? Yeah. You can see-- What's a bowtie strap? It was a decorative piece that had decorations to be narrow-wide, narrow-wide, all the way around to decorate a chest. Oh, so, specifically chest decorations? Yeah, wooden boxes and chests. That's exceedingly interesting. Is there a cultural influence? Yes. French. Really? Yeah. Wow!”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:18“From what I see there on the head, it looks like it was the broken end off something. It looks to me like it could be some sort of a chisel. Yes, this could be a tool that could be used for mining or tunneling.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:27“We have long puzzled about the possibility that these French items, the lead cross and Zena's Map were associated with some depositional work. I have always believed that this work on Oak Island, the original depositional work was started incredibly early.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:14“The artifacts you've shown me over the years is very unique. There's artifacts coming out of Oak Island that I haven't seen anywhere else.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:41Chapters
0:01 — Brooch Discovery and Duc d'Anville Link: The team examines an ornate brooch possibly dating 1500–1700; Doug Crowell and Charles Barkhouse connect it to the 1746 Duc d'Anville French fleet and a previously found French cap badge.
3:33 — Lot 5 Ancient Coins and New Metal Detecting: Recap of five ancient coins (three Roman, 500 AD–300 BC) found on Lot 5; Gary Drayton and Rick Lagina detect a decorative strap and a heavy iron piece near a circular depression.
8:29 — Carmen Legge Artifact Analysis: Blacksmith Carmen Legge identifies the strap as a French bowtie chest decoration (possibly pre-17th century) and the iron piece as a mining chisel with no modern metallurgical elements.
13:24 — Zena Halpern's Maps and the Hatch: Zena Halpern shares 1179 and 1347 maps of Oak Island with French annotations (hatch, valve, anchors); the hatch aligns with a depression Dave Blankenship found, and the team goes to investigate.
18:00 — Hatch Location Investigation: Jack Begley overlays the French map on satellite imagery; the hatch location matches Blankenship's anomaly. The team walks to the site and discovers a strange depression/hole.
Speakers
Doug Crowell — Researcher/Historian
Charles Barkhouse — Team Member/Interpreter
Gary Drayton — Metal Detection Specialist
Rick Lagina — Co-Lead Treasure Hunter
Marty Lagina — Co-Lead Treasure Hunter
Craig Tester — Partner/Engineer
Carmen Legge — Blacksmithing Expert
Zena Halpern — Knights Templar Researcher
Jack Begley — Team Member/Mapping
Dave Blankenship — Property Owner/Team Member
Narrator — Narrator