Friends for Life | Full Episode

Original Media · 41m · English · YouTube · 48 Hours

TLDR

This 48 Hours episode investigates the 2009 murder of Brian Davis in Lake Charles, Louisiana, and the controversial conviction of his wife Robin Davis and her best friend Carol "Sissy" Saltzman. Despite no physical evidence, DNA, fingerprints, or murder weapon linking the women to the crime, they were convicted of second-degree murder based largely on cell phone tower data placing them near the remote crime scene. The case highlights serious investigative flaws including a lost surveillance video, failure to interview a jealous husband with motive, and Louisiana's non-unanimous jury law that allowed a 10-2 conviction over one holdout juror's reasonable doubt. Both women maintain their innocence and remain close friends while serving life sentences without parole.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Louisiana allowed non-unanimous jury verdicts in murder cases until 2019 — this case was decided 10-2, meaning in 48 other states it would have been a mistrial.

•

Police never initially interviewed Shane Dietz, the husband of Brian's mistress, despite him having a clear motive and his wife confessing the affair to him just two months before the murder.

•

The defense's own cell tower testing showed signals could bounce between towers in rural areas, but these results were ruled inadmissible at trial.

•

The holdout juror, Shandrika Washington, still feels pain over the verdict years later, believing the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

•

Robin and Sissy were interrogated without lawyers initially, and police told neighbors they were murderers before charges were filed.

•

Both defense attorneys took the case pro bono because they were convinced of the women's innocence.

Key takeaways

•

Robin Davis and Carol "Sissy" Saltzman were convicted of second-degree murder based entirely on circumstantial evidence — primarily cell phone tower data — with no physical evidence, DNA, fingerprints, or murder weapon linking them to the crime.

•

The crime scene was staged to look like a flat tire, but the tire held air, suggesting someone lured Brian to the remote location.

•

Brian Davis had a history of infidelity and was having an affair with Fanny Deats, whose husband Shane Dietz was never initially interviewed by police despite having a strong motive.

•

A surveillance video from Fred's Lounge that could have shown who drove the Honda to the crime scene was lost by police.

•

Louisiana's non-unanimous jury law (since changed) allowed conviction with a 10-2 vote; one juror held out for acquittal citing reasonable doubt.

•

The prosecution's motive was $600,000 in life insurance, but Robin and Brian gambled together and shared finances.

•

The women were seen shopping in white capri pants and flip-flops an hour before the murder — attire the defense argued was inconsistent with planning a killing.

•

Both women maintain their innocence, their friendship endures, and they continue to serve life sentences without parole.

Notable quotes

“There's no fingerprints. There's no eyewitnesses. There's no DNA. There's no nada.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:57

“You tell me what a cold-blooded killer looks like. A murderer comes in all shapes and sizes.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:34

“Not a shred. Absolutely zero.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:06

“I would cringe if that piece of evidence sent someone to the penitentiary.”

▸ Notable quotes · 32:52

“They didn't have enough evidence. It wasn't enough for me to convince me that they murdered Brian.”

▸ Notable quotes · 33:39

“My worst nightmare has come true. From day one I said the two things that scare me the most is that my life is hanging on a pinnacle of a cell phone tower and there's 12 people that's going to judge me that don't know me.”

▸ Notable quotes · 38:57

Chapters

•

0:00 — Brian Davis's Disappearance and Murder: Brian Davis goes boat shopping with wife Robin, drops her off, continues alone, and never returns. His body is found two days later on Wagon Wheel Road, shot four times in the back beside his jacked-up car with belt undone and shoes off.

•

10:00 — Investigation Focuses on Robin and Sissy: Police become suspicious of Robin's reaction to the news and her joking about Sissy's boyfriend. Cell phone records show Sissy's phone pinging off a tower 11 miles from her home near the crime scene, contradicting her alibi. Police theorize the women staged a flat tire to lure Brian.

•

19:00 — Alternative Suspects and Motives: Brian's infidelity and affair with Fanny Deats are revealed. Fanny's husband Shane Dietz had motive but was cleared based on employer records. Defense argues Brian may have been meeting someone at the remote location. Prosecution cites $600,000 insurance motive for Robin.

•

30:00 — Trial and Conviction: Three years later, trial begins with only circumstantial evidence. Cell tower experts place both women near the scene. Defense cell tower tests excluded. Jury deliberates under three hours; 10-2 verdict convicts both of second-degree murder. Holdout juror cites lack of physical evidence.

•

37:00 — Aftermath and Life in Prison: Women sentenced to mandatory life without parole. They serve time in same facility, see each other briefly in church. Their friendship remains strong. Brian's family believes justice served; holdout juror and defense attorneys maintain reasonable doubt.

Speakers

•

Erin Moriarty — Correspondent

•

Robin Davis — Defendant / Victim's Wife

•

Carol "Sissy" Saltzman — Defendant / Best Friend

•

Tony Mancuso — Sheriff

•

Rick Bryant — Prosecutor

•

Glenn Van Voorhis — Defense Attorney

•

Shane Hinch — Defense Attorney

•

Fanny Deats — Mistress

•

Shane Dietz — Mistress's Husband

•

Scott Davis — Victim's Brother

•

Kelsey — Robin's Daughter

•

Shandrika Washington — Holdout Juror

•

Marcy Wilson — Friend

⋮