TLDR
In Part 2 of the Ashley Flynn case, hosts Stephanie Harlow and Derek Levasseur analyze thousands of text messages between Caleb Flynn, his wife Ashley, and his mistress Alieha Botner. The messages reveal a toxic dynamic where Alieha pressured Caleb to leave Ashley with escalating deadlines, while Caleb lied to both women. Alieha repeatedly said she wanted Ashley 'gone' or 'dead,' then added disclaimers. In January 2026, Alieha took a solo Florida trip where both her phone and laptop were conveniently destroyed. Caleb sent Alieha an AI-generated love song while still acting as a devoted husband to Ashley. The hosts debate whether Alieha's ambiguous language constituted criminal encouragement or emotional venting, and whether law enforcement adequately investigated her role.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Alieha expressed jealousy not just of Ashley but of Caleb's own daughters, texting that family celebrations made her 'physically sick' and she wanted to 'run in front of a bus.'
Caleb told Alieha he was 'literally trying to find a way to kill her and not go to jail' and Alieha's first written response was 'It would change everything, Caleb' before adding she wasn't asking him to kill Ashley.
Alieha praised Caleb's ability to lie to Ashley, calling it 'sexy' and saying 'you're such a high-value man' when he devised a scheme to secretly check Ashley's phone.
Caleb sent Alieha an AI-generated song (created with Eleven Labs) professing undying love while simultaneously planning Valentine's Day dinner and hot tub time with Ashley.
Alieha waited 5 days after returning from Florida to file a lost-laptop report with Frontier Airlines, despite claiming she realized it was missing immediately upon landing.
Key takeaways
Alieha Botner exerted relentless pressure on Caleb Flynn to leave his wife Ashley, issuing multiple deadlines (October, November, Christmas) and demanding 'believable proof' he hated Ashley, while Caleb apologized profusely but delayed taking action.
Caleb maintained two completely different narratives: to Alieha he claimed he hated Ashley and wanted her gone; to Ashley he acted affectionate, went on dates, discussed Valentine's Day plans, and told her he loved her.
Alieha was far more sophisticated about covering digital tracks than Caleb, using ChatGPT to research message deletion, WhatsApp security, and iCloud backups, while Caleb was careless and his devices were eventually accessed.
Both Alieha's phone and laptop were destroyed during a suspicious 3-day solo Florida trip in January 2026 — the phone dropped in the ocean while kayaking, the laptop left on a plane — occurring between her claimed breakup with Caleb and Ashley's murder weeks later.
Alieha's language was strategically ambiguous: she repeatedly said 'I want her dead' and 'remove her from your life,' then occasionally added 'obviously I don't mean kill her,' which the hosts debate as either poor wording or calculated plausible deniability.
Caleb used religious language manipulatively, claiming God told him to go on the anniversary cruise with Ashley, and both he and Alieha invoked fasting and prayer while conducting an affair and discussing murder.
Ashley Flynn was actively trying to understand and repair her marriage — confronting Caleb, asking 'Is it her?', screenshotting relationship advice — while Caleb gaslit her and told Alieha that Ashley was avoiding him.
The defense team portrayed Alieha as the mastermind who hired a hitman, citing her device destruction, burner phone, and lies to the FBI; the hosts find the hitman theory unlikely but agree Alieha's behavior warrants serious scrutiny.
Notable quotes
“If you can find a way to remove her from your life, if you can really show me how sorry you are, if you can give me more and actually believable proof that you hate her. I don't know. It's all for you to figure out if you want me to really be back in your life.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:32“I have never been more hurt by any single thing in my entire life, and nothing will ever top what I've been through. You have truly no idea what this has put me through. I truly have never felt such excruciatingly awful suffering in my life.”
▸ Notable quotes · 21:24“I was up till 4:00 a.m. last night crying and literally thinking of ways to kill her and not go to jail, even though you have said if she was gone, you wouldn't want me.”
▸ Notable quotes · 39:18“It would change everything, Caleb. I'm not asking that you take her life, obviously, because that's not what you should do and I know you actually wouldn't, but to make the divorce happen, it would change everything.”
▸ Notable quotes · 40:04“I need her gone and I need urgency.”
▸ Notable quotes · 86:16“As long as she stays, it'll always be hard between us.”
▸ Notable quotes · 71:52Chapters
0:03 — Recap and Alieha's Testimony: Hosts recap Part 1: Caleb and Alieha exchanged thousands of messages hiding their affair and discussing wanting Ashley dead. Alieha testified she doubted Caleb hated Ashley because she saw his location at restaurants with Ashley and saw Ashley's loving texts to him.
21:06 — Cruise Aftermath and Message Discovery: Caleb and Ashley went on a 15th anniversary cruise August 2025. Alieha was furious. Ashley discovered more texts, reached out to Alieha for a sit-down, but Alieha canceled. Caleb sent Alieha instructions on deleting messages and a fabricated cover story about a recording session.
64:42 — Escalating Pressure and Deadlines: Alieha gave Caleb deadlines to leave Ashley (October, November, Christmas). Caleb apologized, cried, claimed God told him to go on the cruise, and listed what he'd sacrifice (daughters, job, home, church). Alieha demanded urgency and said 'I need her gone.'
109:25 — Florida Trip and Device Destruction: After a claimed final breakup January 11, Alieha took a solo 3-day Florida trip Jan 22-24. Her phone fell in the ocean while kayaking; she left her work laptop on the plane. Both devices were destroyed during the critical window before Ashley's murder.
123:00 — AI Song and Valentine's Day Lead-Up: Caleb sent Alieha an AI-generated love song (Eleven Labs) while still sleeping in bed with Ashley, going on Valentine's dates, and telling Ashley he loved her. Ashley was confronting him; Caleb was crafting a cough alibi.
Speakers
Stephanie Harlow — Host
Derek Levasseur — Host