TLDR
This 48 Hours compilation examines four murder cases where justice took unconventional paths: Sheila Trot was convicted of killing her friend Kelly Brennan after a dream led police to the body, despite no physical evidence linking her; Allison Davis was acquitted of murdering her husband Kevin when experts disagreed on whether his skull fractures came from a fall or a beating; Jerry Westerm was convicted of the 1993 murder of Jeanie Childs after genetic genealogy matched his DNA and a single bloody footprint to the cold case; and Steven Burns, who killed his girlfriend Kina Solano in 1979, was denied parole for the 13th time in 2025 after 45 years in prison, with her family attending every hearing to keep him incarcerated.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Sheila Trot claimed she set up her husband Dan with Kelly Brennan to speed her own divorce, yet prosecutors argued this was a fabrication to mask jealousy.
Allison Davis laughed with paramedics while her husband lay brain dead, which investigators cited as evidence of guilt, but the jury acquitted her anyway.
Jerry Westerm's defense expert Alicia McCarthy agreed with the prosecution on the single most damning footprint (E2) but was then fired by the defense team before trial.
Steven Burns stole the murder weapon from his girlfriend's father's store weeks before the killing, yet received only a 17-years-to-life sentence for second-degree murder, not first-degree.
The Solano family's advocacy changed California law: victims can now give impact statements at sentencing, parents can attend trials even as witnesses, and child witnesses must have support persons.
Key takeaways
A dream or vision can become the cornerstone of a murder prosecution even without physical evidence, as Sheila Trot's nightmare about Kelly Brennan at Mark's Landing led directly to the body and her conviction.
When forensic experts radically disagree — as in the Allison Davis case where one pathologist saw multiple blows and another saw a single fatal impact with brain ricochet — reasonable doubt can prevail even with a dead body and suspicious circumstances.
Genetic genealogy can solve decades-old cold cases but may not resolve all questions: Jerry Westerm's DNA and one footprint placed him at the scene, yet other male DNA and alternate suspects with violent histories remained unexplained.
A family's relentless presence at parole hearings over 45 years (the Solanos attended all 13 for Kina's killer) can influence outcomes, but the system increasingly weighs rehabilitation, age at offense, and statistical recidivism rates against victim impact.
The absence of a murder weapon does not preclude conviction: Sheila Trot and Jerry Westerm were both convicted without a weapon recovered, while Allison Davis was acquitted partly because no weapon was found.
Domestic violence escalation patterns — threats, stalking, gun theft — were evident in both the Kina Solano and Kelly Brennan cases, yet the legal system initially treated them as relationship disputes rather than lethal dangers.
Jurors can reach verdicts quickly (under 3 hours for Sheila Trot, 8 days for Jerry Westerm) when a defendant's own words (911 calls, letters, footprint evidence) create a compelling narrative, even amid forensic gaps.
The definition of justice diverges: for some families it's a conviction (Sheila Trot, Jerry Westerm), for others it's an acquittal (Allison Davis), and for the Solanos it's the ongoing act of showing up to ensure a killer never walks free.
Notable quotes
“I said, "I'm worried about Kelly. I think Kelly's hurt."”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:31“You don't believe that she has some supernatural ability that all these facts came to her in a dream? No, I don't think she's clairvoyant. I think she's a killer.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:02“The smoking gun in this case are the defendant's own words, telling the police where the dead body is.”
▸ Notable quotes · 36:14“He was a big guy. You know, the jurors may have a hard time believing that she was even capable of causing this injury to him.”
▸ Notable quotes · 73:30“There's no timestamp on DNA.”
▸ Notable quotes · 112:00“The shooting of the gun murdered my sister, but the behaviors and the need for his power and control and the obsessiveness is what makes him dangerous.”
▸ Notable quotes · 155:37Chapters
0:00 — Sheila Trot: Dream Leads to Body: Sheila Trot reports a dream about her friend Kelly Brennan at Mark's Landing; police find Kelly's body exactly there. Sheila becomes prime suspect. Her husband Dan was having an affair with Kelly. Sheila's sons testify she led them to the body and a bag with Kelly's ID. She claims she witnessed a stranger kill Kelly. Convicted of first-degree murder, life in prison.
42:16 — Allison Davis: Fall or Beating?: Kevin Davis found at bottom of stairs with massive head trauma. Autopsy shows multiple skull fractures inconsistent with a fall. No murder weapon found. Allison's behavior (calm 911 call, laughing with paramedics) raises suspicion. Experts disagree: prosecution says beating, defense says single impact with brain ricochet. Jury acquits Allison after 4-day trial.
84:20 — Jerry Westerm: Cold Case DNA Hit: 1993 murder of Jeanie Childs goes cold. 2015 genetic genealogy matches crime scene DNA to Jerry Westerm. Bloody bare footprints at scene; one footprint (E2) definitively matched to Westerm. Other male DNA and alternate suspects (Arthur Gray, James Carlton, John Eswine) excluded by judge. Westerm convicted of first-degree murder, life in prison.
125:54 — Steven Burns: 45-Year Parole Battle: 1979: Steven Burns shoots girlfriend Kina Solano in back of head on college campus. Stole gun from her father's store. Convicted of second-degree murder, 17-to-life. Family attends 13 parole hearings over 45 years. Burns admits killing but denies premeditation. 2025 hearing: commissioners deny parole for 5 years, citing minimal change in obsessive behaviors. Family's advocacy transformed victim rights laws.
Speakers
Peter Van Sant — Narrator/Reporter
Major Todd Goodyear — Lead Investigator (Sheila Trot case)
Todd Deritany — Defense Attorney (Sheila Trot case)
Detective James Krueger — Lead Investigator (Allison Davis case)
Agent Chris Boers — FBI Agent (Jerry Westerm case)
Harriet Solano — Victim's Mother (Kina Solano case)
Nina Solano — Victim's Sister / Prosecutor (Kina Solano case)
Dr. Bill Smock — Forensic Pathologist (Allison Davis case)
Dr. LJ Dragovich — Forensic Neuropathologist (Allison Davis case)
Alicia McCarthy — Forensic Scientist (Jerry Westerm case)