TLDR
Mythical Kitchen host Josh Scherer teams up with drag queen and Easy Bake oven expert Trixie Mattel to attempt three notoriously difficult desserts — a Cherry Garcia crepe cake, a Dominique Ansel peanut butter crunch cake, and a Cosme restaurant corn husk meringue — using only vintage Easy Bake ovens. Trixie shares deep knowledge of the ovens' history, including the 2011 recall after children suffered severe burns from front-loading heating elements. The crepe cake fails texturally (dense, gummy layers), the peanut butter cake succeeds because it requires minimal baking, and the corn meringue emerges as the standout. Throughout, they trade stories about dropping out of school for career breaks, millennial culture, exotic pet ethics, and the gap between earnest amateur attempts and professional kitchen results.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Easy Bake ovens reached 380°F using just a single incandescent light bulb, since bulbs emit 96% of their energy as heat.
The Food Network internally categorized Josh's demographic as "edible complex" — young latchkey males watching female hosts with confused maternal/romantic feelings.
Trixie knows the exact number of children injured (three) that prompted the 2011 Easy Bake oven recall and the specific injuries (third-degree burns, partial finger loss).
Dominique Ansel (cronut inventor) is French and had a military background before becoming a pastry chef.
Trixie made thousands of crepes in French class as a homework-for-crepes barter system with smarter classmates.
Trixie refuses to own pet birds despite loving them because she's "too well educated on them" to provide adequate care while touring.
The crepe cake's beautiful presentation masked a disappointing texture — "dense and scabby" like a fruit roll-up — while the weirdest-sounding dessert (popcorn meringue) was the best.
Key takeaways
Easy Bake ovens switched from light bulbs to heating elements in 2011 after three children suffered severe burns including a finger amputation, making them bake better but leading to recalls of front-loading models.
Trixie Mattel has extensive Easy Bake oven expertise from testing vintage models on her YouTube channel, knowing the history, mechanics, and quirks of each generation.
Making a proper crepe cake requires 12-14 perfectly thin, even crepes layered with pastry cream — a tedious process that the Easy Bake oven's small cavity and uneven heating makes extremely difficult, resulting in dense, gummy crepes.
The peanut butter crunch cake (Dominique Ansel's recipe) worked surprisingly well in the Easy Bake oven because it required minimal baking — just toasting rice cereal with corn syrup — and the mousse/ganache components were made conventionally.
The corn husk meringue from Cosme restaurant was the most successful dessert, using dehydrated corn husk powder in a simple four-ingredient meringue that whipped up beautifully and tasted delicious.
Both hosts share a background of dropping out of higher education for career opportunities — Trixie left beauty school for Drag Race, Josh left UCLA for a book deal.
The episode highlights the gap between "doing dumb shit earnestly" for content versus professional kitchen results, with Josh's team doing significant off-camera work to salvage the desserts.
Trixie's deep knowledge of exotic pets (especially birds) contrasts with her drag persona, revealing a thoughtful approach to animal welfare — she refuses to get birds because her schedule can't meet their flock-animal needs.
Notable quotes
“Three different kids had third degree burns and one of them lost a piece of their finger.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:35“You and I are both kind of like the queens of doing dumb shit very earnestly and that's what we're about to do today.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:12“Frankly, that flat chested little bitch, she don't have what it takes, all right? I got tits bigger than her on my back.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:18“They had a name for my demographic exactly, which was young, latchkey male watching female hosts, both wishing they were their mother, but also that they could be romantically intimate with them.”
▸ Notable quotes · 24:01“They're flock animals. They need a lot of attention, why are you laughing?”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:39“It's kind of like what's wrong with fondant. It's just like not, it's a non-event.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:05Chapters
0:00 — Introduction & Easy Bake History: Josh welcomes Trixie, they discuss their friendship history, Trixie explains Easy Bake ovens switched to heating elements in 2011 after a recall for severe burns.
2:04 — Making Cherry Garcia Crepe Cake: They attempt 12-14 crepes in Easy Bake ovens for a milk crepe cake inspired by Lady M Bakery, struggling with the tiny cavity and crepe technique.
15:13 — Reveal & Layering Crepes: Josh admits the crepes were made off-camera by his team yesterday; they layer crepes with cherry pastry cream and chocolate, discussing Trixie's beauty school dropout story.
20:17 — Making Dominique Ansel Peanut Butter Crunch Cake: They toast rice cereal with corn syrup in Easy Bake ovens for Ansel's peanut butter crunch cake, discussing his military background and cronut invention.
27:04 — Making Cosme Corn Husk Meringue: They whip a four-ingredient corn husk meringue with corn pastry cream, Trixie demonstrates a helicopter whisking technique, they discuss ax throwing and millennial music.
33:06 — Tasting & Reviewing All Three Desserts: They taste the crepe cake (dense, gummy), peanut butter cake (restaurant-ready), and corn meringue (prettiest and best), with tangents on guinea pigs, Provincetown, and Anthony Bourdain.
38:46 — Wrap Up & Goodbyes: Trixie credits Josh's team for the results, they joke about catching birds, Trixie's shoe breaks, and she plugs her channels.
Speakers
Josh — Host
Trixie — Guest