TLDR
This episode features three true-story submissions read by the Let's Read narrator. The first recounts a 1970s vigilante justice tale where a beloved town hobo is revealed as a child predator and beaten by teenagers who destroy photographic evidence. The second describes a sinkhole in a sleepy town that may have been used to conceal a murder. The third tells of a teenage mugger in a tiny community who targets people he knows will forgive him, driven by depression and an abusive mother.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The town hobo Cornelius B. Cheesy was a serial child abuser who kept Polaroid trophies of his victims — and the police chief likely knew and covered it up.
The father and his friends tied Cornelius to a cross in a deliberate Christ-parallel punishment, then kept him alive for days to 'contemplate his sins.'
The sinkhole repair company (Company X) was corrupt and likely used the concrete fill to bury Bob, with the foreman leveraging blackmail over town officials.
The mugger in story three was a 17-year-old boy who apologized via WhatsApp mid-arrest and had never taken phones because 'that would be really inconvenient.'
The mugger's own father initially considered prosecuting his son, then abruptly dropped charges and abandoned the family.
The cafe owner (mugger's mother) stopped all malicious gossip after her son's arrest — the one 'positive' outcome of the crime spree.
Key takeaways
Small towns enable secrets to fester behind a facade of familiarity and trust.
Vigilante justice creates moral ambiguity: the father in story one still questions whether destroying the Polaroids was right.
Institutional complicity can silence victims: the police chief in story one and the construction company in story two both appear to cover up crimes.
A predator's 'harmless' public persona (Cornelius's dancing, the mugger's shyness) masks calculated abuse.
Teenage perpetrators in stories one and three act from a mix of moral conviction and personal trauma, blurring victim/offender lines.
Gossip in small communities distorts reality, amplifying minor crimes while ignoring systemic abuse.
The mugger in story three chose victims he believed would forgive him, revealing a warped desire for connection over malice.
Notable quotes
“I was the one who hoisted him up onto that cross, son. And I was responsible for one of his black eyes.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:42“He was a devil with a voice of an angel, and so very cleverly Cornelius would get a donation of paper money rather than nickel and dime pocket change.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:08“The Lord provides and beyond that he wouldn't say anything else.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:05“He picked his victims based on people he thought would forgive him, I think.”
▸ Notable quotes · 49:01“We're all pretty certain that somewhere at the bottom of a large lake near our old hometown, Bob's car is rusting away. And we believe that buried in a soundless tomb under tons of concrete, blacktop, and grass lies mean, scowling Bob.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:54“What the mugger did was definitely wrong but I can see all too easily how it happened to a teenager growing up in such a sleepy, gossipy town when his own mother was the town's biggest gossip.”
▸ Notable quotes · 53:05Chapters
0:23 — The Cornelius B. Cheesy Story: Vigilante Justice in the 1970s: The narrator's father recounts how he and two friends beat and crucified a beloved town hobo after discovering he was a child predator who kept Polaroid trophies. They destroyed the evidence and the police chief covered up the investigation, likely because his own daughter was a victim.
18:35 — The Sinkhole and the Disappearance of Bob and Pete: A sinkhole opens on Main Street. Pete falls in and dies; his friend Bob waits an hour to get help. Bob owes Pete money and disappears the same night a corrupt construction company fills the sinkhole with concrete. The town suspects Bob was murdered and buried in the fill.
32:21 — The Teenage Mugger Who Targeted Friends: In a tiny town, a 17-year-old boy commits four muggings with a box cutter during school holidays. He targets people he knows — his former babysitter, a friend, his father, a stoner acquaintance — hoping they'll forgive him. He's caught when police deduce the pattern; victims drop charges, but his father abandons him.
Speakers
Narrator (Joel) — Host/Reader
Story 1 Submitter — First-person narrator
Story 2 Submitter — First-person narrator
Story 3 Submitter — First-person narrator