Disturbing Stories from Small Towns

Original Media · 55m · English · YouTube · Lets Read!

TLDR

This episode features three true-story submissions read by the Let's Read narrator. The first recounts a 1970s vigilante justice tale where a beloved town hobo is revealed as a child predator and beaten by teenagers who destroy photographic evidence. The second describes a sinkhole in a sleepy town that may have been used to conceal a murder. The third tells of a teenage mugger in a tiny community who targets people he knows will forgive him, driven by depression and an abusive mother.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The town hobo Cornelius B. Cheesy was a serial child abuser who kept Polaroid trophies of his victims — and the police chief likely knew and covered it up.

•

The father and his friends tied Cornelius to a cross in a deliberate Christ-parallel punishment, then kept him alive for days to 'contemplate his sins.'

•

The sinkhole repair company (Company X) was corrupt and likely used the concrete fill to bury Bob, with the foreman leveraging blackmail over town officials.

•

The mugger in story three was a 17-year-old boy who apologized via WhatsApp mid-arrest and had never taken phones because 'that would be really inconvenient.'

•

The mugger's own father initially considered prosecuting his son, then abruptly dropped charges and abandoned the family.

•

The cafe owner (mugger's mother) stopped all malicious gossip after her son's arrest — the one 'positive' outcome of the crime spree.

Key takeaways

•

Small towns enable secrets to fester behind a facade of familiarity and trust.

•

Vigilante justice creates moral ambiguity: the father in story one still questions whether destroying the Polaroids was right.

•

Institutional complicity can silence victims: the police chief in story one and the construction company in story two both appear to cover up crimes.

•

A predator's 'harmless' public persona (Cornelius's dancing, the mugger's shyness) masks calculated abuse.

•

Teenage perpetrators in stories one and three act from a mix of moral conviction and personal trauma, blurring victim/offender lines.

•

Gossip in small communities distorts reality, amplifying minor crimes while ignoring systemic abuse.

•

The mugger in story three chose victims he believed would forgive him, revealing a warped desire for connection over malice.

Notable quotes

“I was the one who hoisted him up onto that cross, son. And I was responsible for one of his black eyes.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:42

“He was a devil with a voice of an angel, and so very cleverly Cornelius would get a donation of paper money rather than nickel and dime pocket change.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:08

“The Lord provides and beyond that he wouldn't say anything else.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:05

“He picked his victims based on people he thought would forgive him, I think.”

▸ Notable quotes · 49:01

“We're all pretty certain that somewhere at the bottom of a large lake near our old hometown, Bob's car is rusting away. And we believe that buried in a soundless tomb under tons of concrete, blacktop, and grass lies mean, scowling Bob.”

▸ Notable quotes · 30:54

“What the mugger did was definitely wrong but I can see all too easily how it happened to a teenager growing up in such a sleepy, gossipy town when his own mother was the town's biggest gossip.”

▸ Notable quotes · 53:05

Chapters

•

0:23 — The Cornelius B. Cheesy Story: Vigilante Justice in the 1970s: The narrator's father recounts how he and two friends beat and crucified a beloved town hobo after discovering he was a child predator who kept Polaroid trophies. They destroyed the evidence and the police chief covered up the investigation, likely because his own daughter was a victim.

•

18:35 — The Sinkhole and the Disappearance of Bob and Pete: A sinkhole opens on Main Street. Pete falls in and dies; his friend Bob waits an hour to get help. Bob owes Pete money and disappears the same night a corrupt construction company fills the sinkhole with concrete. The town suspects Bob was murdered and buried in the fill.

•

32:21 — The Teenage Mugger Who Targeted Friends: In a tiny town, a 17-year-old boy commits four muggings with a box cutter during school holidays. He targets people he knows — his former babysitter, a friend, his father, a stoner acquaintance — hoping they'll forgive him. He's caught when police deduce the pattern; victims drop charges, but his father abandons him.

Speakers

•

Narrator (Joel) — Host/Reader

•

Story 1 Submitter — First-person narrator

•

Story 2 Submitter — First-person narrator

•

Story 3 Submitter — First-person narrator

⋮