TLDR
Irving Finkel, curator at the British Museum and world expert on cuneiform, discusses the origins of writing in Mesopotamia around 3500 BC, the crucial invention of using signs to represent sounds, and his controversial theory that writing existed millennia earlier at Gobekli Tepe. He explains the decipherment of cuneiform, the structure and longevity of the script, the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Babylonian flood narrative that predates the biblical Noah, the Royal Game of Ur, and reflects on what ancient peoples understood about language, games, and human nature that modern society has lost.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Finkel believes a seal stone from Gobekli Tepe (c. 9000 BC) proves writing existed 5,000 years before the accepted Mesopotamian origin, a view he calls 'highly controversial' and that makes many Assyriologists 'leave the room.'
Henry Rawlinson, traditionally credited as the 'Father of Assyriology' for deciphering cuneiform via the Behistun inscription, wrote a book that was 'almost entirely wrong'; the true breakthrough came from Edward Hincks, an Irish clergyman with five daughters.
Cuneiform scribes could write down languages they did not understand — e.g., recording foreign tongues phonetically by ear — because the script was a universal sound-recording system long before the alphabet.
The Babylonian ark was a giant round coracle, not a rectangular box; its dimensions and materials were specified in the tablet with such precision that a modern replica built to one-third scale successfully floated.
The flood story's 'noise' motive is a euphemism: before the flood the gods had not created death, so overpopulation was the real problem; after the flood they instituted barren women and celibate priestesses as population control.
Finkel considers monotheistic religion 'the big mistake for mankind' because it introduced the logic of 'I'm right and you're wrong,' leading to inquisitions, religious prejudice, and violence absent in polytheistic systems.
Key takeaways
Writing began in Mesopotamia around 3500 BC with pictographic signs, but the revolutionary breakthrough was the rebus principle — using a picture of a foot to represent the sound of the word 'foot' — which allowed recording of grammar, literature, and any spoken language.
Cuneiform was a syllabic system with multivalent signs (same sign, multiple sound values) and no word spacing; it lasted over 3,000 years because early scribes created standardized lexical lists that froze the system into a retrievable, teachable canon.
Sumerian is a language isolate with no known relatives; its recording in cuneiform preserved a unique linguistic lineage whose sister languages vanished without trace.
The Babylonian flood story (Atra-Hasis, 1700 BC) predates the biblical Noah by over a millennium and describes a round coracle-shaped ark built to precise mathematical specifications; Finkel built a one-third replica that floated.
The biblical flood narrative was likely adopted by Judean exiles in Babylon during the 6th century BC, who transformed the gods' annoyance at human noise into divine punishment for sin.
The Royal Game of Ur, a 20-square race game mixing dice chance with strategy, spread across the ancient Middle East for nearly 3,000 years without written rules, transmitted by merchants and players across language barriers.
Finkel argues ancient humans were cognitively identical to us — 'if you put them on a bus, all wearing the same clothes, you wouldn't know' — but lived without the 'electronic universe' that he believes degrades language, thought, and natural human behavior.
The British Museum's mission is to preserve the 'raindrops' (artifacts) from which future generations can reconstruct the 'waterfall' of human history, serving both the whole world without cultural favoritism and the unborn.
Notable quotes
“it is theoretically possible to infer the Niagara Falls from a raindrop”
▸ Notable quotes · 18:42“the limits of our language is the limits of our world”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:00“Once the rockets are up, who cares where they come down? That's not my department, says Wernher von Braun.”
▸ Notable quotes · 122:49“I think the big mistake for mankind was the creation of monotheistic religions, because they brought evil into the world.”
▸ Notable quotes · 64:12“If you put them on a bus, all wearing the same clothes, you wouldn't know.”
▸ Notable quotes · 113:46“The British Museum is a kind of lighthouse in a universe where we are surrounded by darkness, ignorance, stupidity, uninterest, disinterest, skepticism, ignorance, and so forth.”
▸ Notable quotes · 108:47Chapters
0:56 — Origin of writing and cuneiform: Finkel describes the emergence of writing in Mesopotamia around 3500 BC, the shift from pictographs to sound-based signs via the rebus principle, and the creation of a flexible syllabic system that could record any language.
14:32 — Gobekli Tepe and earlier writing: Finkel presents his controversial theory that a seal stone from Gobekli Tepe (c. 9000 BC) proves writing existed millennia before Sumer, used for inter-group communication via pictographic symbols that transcended language barriers.
25:29 — Decipherment of cuneiform: The trilingual Behistun inscription (Old Persian, Elamite, Babylonian) provided the key; Edward Hincks, not Henry Rawlinson, was the true genius who cracked the multivalent, syllabic nature of the script.
39:51 — Learning cuneiform and its complexity: Finkel recounts his own training under the formidable Professor Lambert; cuneiform requires mastering hundreds of signs with multiple sound values, reading without word spacing, and navigating Sumerian (agglutinative isolate) and Babylonian (Semitic).
42:02 — Why cuneiform lasted 3000 years: Early lexical standardization, scribal monopoly on power, and institutional inertia preserved the system; scribal schools produced specialists for administration, literature, astronomy, medicine, and architecture.
71:23 — Flood narratives and the Ark Tablet: The 1700 BC Ark Tablet details a round coracle ark built to precise specifications; the flood story predates the Bible by 1000+ years and was likely borrowed by Judean exiles in Babylon, who changed the motive from divine annoyance at noise to punishment for sin.
92:53 — Royal Game of Ur: A 20-square race game mixing dice chance with strategy spread across the ancient Middle East for nearly 3000 years; Finkel reconstructed its rules from a late Babylonian tablet and the game is now played worldwide.
105:49 — British Museum philosophy and ancient wisdom: Finkel defends the Museum as a 'lighthouse' preserving humanity's narrative for the unborn; he argues ancients were cognitively identical to us but lived more naturally, while modern electronic communication degrades language and thought.
Speakers
Lex Fridman — Host
Irving Finkel — Guest