TLDR
Mythical Kitchen's Josh Scherer and returning co-host Lily Guarnaschelli compete in a 1v1 Mystery Challenge cooking from viewer Hannah's freezer contents. Both independently create katsu curry variations — Josh makes a pav bhaji-inspired version using Indian spice blends and Trader Joe's Spicy Spuds, while Lily prepares a classic Japanese katsu curry with curry roux. Judge Vi prefers Josh's curry flavor but Lily's pork cutlet and bread choice.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The Dave's Killer Bread brand story about the founder killing a man is false — he had drug and violent offenses but no murder conviction, which Josh had been repeating for years.
Lily's cat Pippin violently attacks only when she takes her pants off, drawing blood, despite her rarely doing so in front of him.
The frozen ginger in Hannah's freezer was stored uncovered in chunks, which both hosts found bizarre — Josh said 'I would never freeze ginger like that.'
Josh's cookbook recipe for pav bhaji calls for six tablespoons of pav bhaji masala, which he initially thought was excessive but used anyway.
Key takeaways
Lily returned after a vaginal delivery with a 3.5-hour labor and epidural, describing the sensation as feeling like she was 'pooping the entire time' and that the baby 'was coming outta my ass.'
Both hosts unknowingly chose to make katsu curry from the same five freezer ingredients: Dave's Killer Bread buns, frozen ginger, thin-cut pork chops, frozen peas and carrots, and Trader Joe's Spicy Spuds.
Josh's pav bhaji approach uses a specific spice blend (pav bhaji masala) and cooks down onions, ginger, and spices into a paste before adding the pre-seasoned frozen potatoes, cauliflower, and peas.
Lily's classic katsu curry uses Japanese curry roux blocks, sautéed onions with garlic and ginger, and adds the frozen vegetables directly to the curry sauce.
Josh hand-tears Dave's Killer Bread into panko for his breading, while Lily uses a standard flour-egg-panko dredge; Vi preferred Lily's crispier crust.
Vi judged Josh's curry flavor superior — 'I like the flavor of your mush better' — but preferred Lily's pork cutlet and her use of the hamburger bun over Josh's bread.
The episode reveals Dave's Killer Bread founder Dave Dahl did not actually kill anyone despite the brand's marketing lore; he had drug and violence offenses but no murder conviction.
Lily fell down the root cellar stairs during filming (which had Crisco on them per a prank), shattering a plate, but continued cooking and later received her film degree certificate from the crew.
Notable quotes
“It felt like my baby was coming outta my ass.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:56“There's three holes.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:32“I've been telling everyone that Dave killed somebody. Personal life.”
▸ Notable quotes · 25:29“Dave didn't kill anyone? And some violent stuff. But he didn't kill anyone.”
▸ Notable quotes · 25:13“I like the crispiness on Lily's better. But I like the flavor of your mush better.”
▸ Notable quotes · 34:10“I only believe in Eastern medicine.”
▸ Notable quotes · 31:24Chapters
0:00 — Intro & Lily's Birth Story: Josh welcomes Lily back from maternity leave; she shares details of her 3.5-hour vaginal delivery with epidural, the sensation of feeling like she was pooping the baby out, and her husband Alex's reaction to watching.
2:30 — Revealing Hannah's Freezer: The hosts reveal the five ingredients from viewer Hannah's freezer: Dave's Killer Bread buns, uncovered frozen ginger chunks, thin-cut pork chops in multiple bags, frozen peas and carrots, and Trader Joe's Spicy Spuds.
6:00 — Both Choose Katsu Curry: Both hosts independently decide to make katsu curry — Josh a pav bhaji-inspired version, Lily a classic Japanese version — leading to comedic realization they're making the same dish.
9:55 — Josh Cooks Pav Bhaji Base: Josh builds a pav bhaji masala spice paste with onions and ginger, adds frozen Spicy Spuds, cauliflower, and peas, explaining the dish's Goan-Portuguese origins and his friend Dip's mom's recipe.
13:43 — Lily Cooks Classic Katsu Curry: Lily sautés onions with garlic and ginger, adds Japanese curry roux blocks and frozen vegetables, and marinates raw onions in lemon and cayenne for topping per Dip's mom's method.
25:30 — Breading & Frying Pork Chops: Josh hand-tears Dave's Killer Bread into panko for his breading; Lily uses standard flour-egg-panko dredge. Both fry thin-cut bone-in pork chops at different temperatures.
30:40 — Plating & Judging: Vi judges both dishes: prefers Josh's curry flavor ('mush') but Lily's pork cutlet crispiness and bun choice. Both dishes receive praise; Dip's mom credited as inspiration.
34:45 — Outro & Lily's Film Degree: Crew surprises Lily with her film degree certificate; she demonstrates knowledge of set terminology. Josh promotes newsletter as episode ends.
Speakers
Josh Scherer — Host
Lily Guarnaschelli — Co-host
Vi — Judge / Crew Member
Tony — Crew Member
Annaliese — Crew Member
KG — Crew Member / Safety