TLDR
JVL and Sarah Longwell discuss the 2024 election aftermath, highlighting Scott Colom's historic Senate win in Mississippi as a Black Democrat, systematic polling errors that underestimated Democratic performance, Florida's anti-DEI law forcing Delray Beach to cancel its St. Patrick's Day parade, and Donald Trump's erratic post-election behavior including sidelining JD Vance from Iran negotiations.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Florida's anti-DEI law forced a city to cancel its St. Patrick's Day parade because Irish heritage celebrations technically fall under the law's restrictions on ethnicity-based programming.
The polling miss favored Democrats this cycle, contrary to the recent pattern of polls underestimating Republican support.
Scott Colom won Jefferson Davis County and Nathan Bedford Forrest County in Mississippi — counties named after Confederate leaders.
Some Democratic candidates in red states ran on personally pro-life positions and emphasized trans people's humanity while opposing trans athletes in women's sports — a combination that defies national party orthodoxies.
Key takeaways
Scott Colom's victory in Mississippi represents a historic breakthrough — a Black Democrat winning a Senate seat in a deep-red state, carrying counties named after Jefferson Davis and Nathan Bedford Forrest.
The 2024 polls systematically underestimated Democratic performance because polling models rely on outdated turnout assumptions that cannot capture rapid political realignments and late-breaking voter shifts.
Democratic candidates won in red states by running campaigns tailored to their specific states — including personally pro-life candidates and those emphasizing trans people's humanity while opposing trans sports participation — defying simple moderate/progressive categorization.
The low-profile nature of some Democratic campaigns like Colom's may have been advantageous, preventing Republican panic spending and nationalization of the races until it was too late.
Florida's anti-DEI law has produced absurd collateral damage, with Delray Beach canceling its St. Patrick's Day parade because the law's restrictions on ethnicity-based programming technically encompass Irish heritage celebrations.
Donald Trump appears mentally rattled by the election results, showing erratic behavior and scattered communication, while his inner circle has shifted from relative professionals like Susie Wiles to ideologues like Stephen Miller who may treat him "like a toddler."
Trump has placed JD Vance in a "penalty box" by removing him from Iran negotiations, possibly due to Vance's disloyalty or Trump's growing paranoia about potential successors, though this may paradoxically boost Vance with the America First base.
Notable quotes
“Just a black guy becoming a senator from the state of Mississippi.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:55“the polls really did miss in the Democrats direction”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:04“the bigger a swing there is from one election to the next, the bigger the error is going to have to be”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:06“he is increasingly just an old man doing old man erratic stuff”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:18“I think that the election has genuinely rattled him”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:32“the mayor of Delray know that the the DEI law is only supposed to apply to black people and gays. It's not supposed to apply to Irish.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:06Chapters
0:00 — Scott Colom's Historic Mississippi Win: JVL and Sarah discuss Scott Colom becoming the first Black senator from Mississippi, winning counties named after Confederate leaders Jefferson Davis and Nathan Bedford Forrest.
2:30 — Polling Errors and Forecasting Failures: The hosts analyze why polls systematically missed in Democrats' favor, discussing how forecasting models rely on outdated turnout assumptions and cannot capture rapid political realignments or late-breaking shifts.
6:15 — Why Mississippi Was Winnable: Sarah explains her bullishness on Mississippi: mixed polling, enormous candidate quality gap, a national Democratic wave especially among Black voters, and polls lagging by about a week.
8:16 — Red-State Democratic Campaign Strategies: JVL details how Democrats expanded the map with candidates who fit their states — personally pro-life, affirming trans humanity while opposing trans sports participation — defying simple moderate/progressive labels.
10:00 — The Advantage of Being Underestimated: JVL and Sarah discuss how low-profile campaigns like Colom's avoided Republican panic spending and nationalization, with Cook Political Report ratings and polling keeping national money away until too late.
11:12 — Florida Anti-DEI Law Cancels St. Patrick's Day Parade: Delray Beach canceled its St. Patrick's Day parade because Florida's anti-DEI law restricts municipal funding for activities referencing ethnicity, and St. Patrick's Day is not a federally exempt holiday.
14:08 — Trump Pulls JD Vance from Iran Talks: Trump removed Vance from Iran negotiations, which Sarah reads as a "penalty box" move amid a fraying relationship, while JVL suggests it might help Vance prove his America First credentials.
15:19 — Trump's Mental State and Inner Circle Shift: Sarah argues Trump is genuinely rattled by the election loss, showing erratic behavior, while his team has shifted from professionals like Susie Wiles to ideologues like Stephen Miller who may effectively run the administration.
Speakers
JVL — Host
Sarah Longwell — Co-host, Publisher of The Bulwark