Trump DOJ Launches DESPERATE PROBE into Supreme Court...

Original Media · 15m · English · YouTube · Legal AF

TLDR

Michael Popach and Lisa Graves discuss the Supreme Court's oral argument in St. Mary's v. Colorado, where a Catholic preschool seeks taxpayer funding while refusing to admit children of same-sex parents. They argue the Court's conservative majority is poised to conflate religious freedom with a right to discriminate using public dollars, reversing decades of Establishment Clause precedent and echoing biblical justifications once used for racial segregation. They also preview an upcoming discussion on the Dobbs leak investigation, suggesting it may have originated from Justice Alito's camp to lock in votes.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The St. Mary's preschool is not being forced to change its religious teachings — it simply wants public money while excluding children of same-sex parents, and the Court appears ready to allow it.

•

The lawyers for St. Mary's and the Trump Justice Department explicitly argued that LGBTQ discrimination deserves less constitutional protection than racial discrimination, despite Obergefell recognizing sexual orientation as immutable.

•

The Masterpiece Cakeshop baker never actually baked a wedding cake for a same-sex couple, and the 303 Creative website designer was never asked to create a site for a gay wedding — both cases were fabricated to reach the Court.

•

The Wall Street Journal editorial page published an editorial criticizing Chief Justice Roberts before the Dobbs draft leaked, suggesting a separate leak from the conservative side to pressure Roberts.

Key takeaways

•

The Supreme Court heard oral argument in St. Mary's v. Colorado on Election Day, where a Catholic preschool in Littleton, Colorado, demands state preschool funding but refuses to sign a non-discrimination clause covering LGBTQ parents.

•

Colorado is now forced to fund religious schools on equal terms with public schools due to prior Roberts Court decisions eroding church-state separation, whereas the founding generation explicitly barred taxpayer money from funding churches.

•

Republican-appointed justices expressed sympathy for St. Mary's, while Democratic appointees warned a religious exemption for LGBTQ discrimination could logically extend to racial discrimination, citing Bob Jones University and biblical justifications for segregation.

•

The hosts predict the Court will rule that Catholic preschools can discriminate against children of same-sex marriages while receiving taxpayer dollars, creating a second-tier citizenship for LGBTQ families.

•

The Court has manufactured 'astroturf' cases like Masterpiece Cakeshop and 303 Creative — where no actual service was requested — to invent precedents allowing discrimination under the guise of religious freedom.

•

The Roberts Court acts as an arm of the Republican Party, inventing facts, ignoring standing doctrines, and selectively granting emergency relief to Trump policies while denying it to others.

•

The framers' original bargain was clear: freedom of worship is protected, but the Establishment Clause forbids using taxpayer dollars to fund religious indoctrination — a line the current Court has erased.

•

The Department of Justice's new criminal investigation into the Dobbs leak, years later, likely targets someone from Alito's circle who leaked the draft to lock in Barrett and Kavanaugh's votes to overturn Roe.

Notable quotes

“They're going to rule that that Catholic preschools can discriminate and not accept children of same-sex marriages. And that is a that is a indictment of this right-wing Supreme Court that they have mixed together and conflated um religious freedom with the freedom to discriminate freely and masked you know under the under the banner of oh uh you're Catholics should be allowed not to accept children into a preschool because it offends their catechism. I'm like, are you effing kidding me? That and by the way, you are fully allowed to do that. You just can't use taxpayer dollars to do it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:41

“Turn down the dollars and then you can do what you want. You can discriminate if you think that's your gospel to your heart's content, you know. And listen, I'm not of that faith, but what would Jesus do? Not this.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:43

“Freedom of religion means you can go practice your religion freely. Um but the establishment clause says you're not going to use my taxpayer dollars to do it. And that that that was the bargain and that was the trade-off.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:07

“That's the dirty little secret of the Supreme Court is that they they don't wait as a court of last resort and a a court of limited jurisdiction for a case. They just jin up a case.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:22

“This court has invented facts that aren't there.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:40

“You have a court that is acting like an arm of the Republican party uh in many many respects and not acting like a court at all.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:49

Chapters

•

0:00 — St. Mary's case introduction: Michael Popach introduces the St. Mary's v. Colorado case: a Catholic preschool seeks state funding while refusing to admit children of same-sex parents, and the Supreme Court's conservative majority appears sympathetic.

•

0:48 — Oral argument and Colorado law: Lisa Graves details the Election Day oral argument: Colorado requires grantees to sign a non-discrimination clause, but prior Roberts Court rulings now force the state to fund religious schools equally, enabling St. Mary's to claim a religious exemption.

•

2:34 — Historical context and founders' intent: The founders and early state constitutions explicitly barred taxpayer funding of churches; the current Court has overturned that consensus, and a religious exemption for LGBTQ discrimination would logically extend to racial discrimination, as seen in Bob Jones University.

•

4:39 — Prediction: Court will allow discrimination: Popach predicts the Court will rule Catholic preschools can discriminate against children of same-sex marriages using taxpayer dollars, conflating religious freedom with a right to discriminate and creating second-class citizenship for LGBTQ families.

•

6:43 — Establishment Clause and taxpayer dollars: The hosts emphasize the constitutional bargain: free exercise protects worship, but the Establishment Clause forbids public funding of religion — a line the Court has erased, contrary to the framers' clear intent.

•

8:38 — Dark money and Federalist Society influence: A right-wing legal network funded by dark money (Koch, Harlan Crow, Leonard Leo) has weaponized free exercise to attack anti-discrimination laws, from Hobby Lobby to Masterpiece Cakeshop to 303 Creative.

•

10:00 — Astroturf cases and invented facts: Key precedents were built on fabricated disputes — the baker never baked a cake, the designer never designed a site — and the Court invents facts to issue sweeping rulings rather than waiting for real cases.

•

11:11 — Court as Republican arm and Dobbs leak preview: The Court acts as a partisan actor, granting emergency relief to Trump policies while denying it to others, and chooses cases it need not hear. The hosts preview a discussion on the Dobbs leak, theorizing it came from Alito's camp to lock in votes.

Speakers

•

Michael Popach — Host

•

Lisa Graves — Co-host / Legal Expert

⋮