If your only ticket to heaven was to forgive your enemies– would you? Trump says no

Original Media · 11m · English · YouTube · MS NOW

TLDR

A panel discusses Donald Trump's interview with Ross Douthat in which Trump explicitly stated he hates his enemies and cannot forgive them, rejecting a core Christian tenet. The conversation explores why this moment has unsettled even loyal white evangelical supporters, tracing a pattern of Trump denying fundamental evangelical theology while being cast as an 'unrighteous defender' of Christianity. White evangelical approval has dropped 20 points in Trump's second term, yet structural support remains.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Evangelical leaders have explicitly developed a theology that accepts an 'unrighteous' savior figure rather than requiring personal piety from their political champion.

•

A 20-point drop in white evangelical approval has not yet translated into meaningful political pullback from Trump.

•

Trump's most theologically literate interviewer (Douthat) elicited his most theologically candid rejection, suggesting the problem is not ignorance but deliberate refusal.

Key takeaways

•

Trump told Ross Douthat he cannot forgive enemies like James Comey and Nancy Pelosi, saying 'I do hate some of my enemies' and acknowledging he knows the Christian answer but refuses to give it.

•

This continues a pattern: in 2015 Trump said he never asked God for forgiveness, and in 2016 claimed he could shoot someone on Fifth Avenue without losing voters — both at evangelical venues with little blowback.

•

White evangelical leaders have rationalized support by recasting Trump not as a righteous Christian but as an 'unrighteous man who will save Christianity,' a defender who will restore their cultural and political power.

•

White evangelical approval of Trump has fallen from 78% to 58% early in his second term, reflecting broader unhappiness with the administration beyond this theological rupture.

•

Ross Douthat's interview was distinctive because he questioned Trump as a theologian, not a politician, prompting an unusually reflective 80-year-old Trump to consciously reject the faith's central demand to change one's heart.

•

Evangelical supporters and pastors still want Trump to become a 'baby Christian' on a path to salvation; Franklin Graham's tweet quoting Scripture was effectively another plea for Trump to repent.

•

Trump's honesty about his hatred — knowing the right answer and refusing it — disturbs religious supporters more than his previous theological ignorance or political hyperbole.

Notable quotes

“No, I think there were very bad people, and I dislike, I can use the word hate. I do hate some of my enemies.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:24

“He said no to that question.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:44

“It's a bit stunning, you know, from an evangelical point of view.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:17

“He's the unrighteous man who's ultimately going to save Christianity.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:56

“Trump really considered the question, clearly knew what he was supposed to say, knew what the Christian answer was, and then gave the opposite.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:44

“There was something about that exchange. And it's much longer than we played up top. That just felt different to me. And it felt even more revelatory.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:37

Chapters

•

0:00 — Trump's forgiveness answer: Trump tells Ross Douthat he cannot forgive political enemies like Comey and Pelosi, explicitly stating he hates them and rejecting the Christian requirement of forgiveness before entering heaven.

•

0:40 — Historical pattern of theological rejection: Robert Jones traces Trump's 2015 refusal to say he'd asked God for forgiveness and his 2016 Fifth Avenue shooting comment, noting both occurred at evangelical venues with minimal blowback.

•

2:23 — Evangelical nervousness and polling decline: Ruth Graham explains current unease stems from Trump knowingly denying the correct answer, amid a 20-point drop in white evangelical approval (78% to 58%) and Democratic candidates embodying a more authentic Christian worldview.

•

4:10 — Douthat's theological interview: McKay Coppins highlights how Ross Douthat, as a serious Catholic intellectual, asked a theological question about heart transformation, prompting Trump to consciously reject Christianity's core demand.

•

7:03 — Trump as unrighteous defender: Robert Jones argues evangelical leaders have recast Trump as an 'unrighteous man who will save Christianity' — a violent defender who will restore white evangelical cultural dominance.

•

8:31 — Evangelical hope for Trump's salvation: Ruth Graham notes supporters still want Trump to become a 'baby Christian'; Franklin Graham's tweet was a plea for repentance, and the Douthat exchange felt uniquely revelatory about Trump's heart.

Speakers

•

Host — MSNBC host and moderator

•

Robert Jones — Panelist

•

Ruth Graham — Panelist

•

McKay Coppins — Panelist

⋮