TLDR
Ian Pfeiffer and Jen Psaki analyze four political ads in key Senate and governor races days before the election. They discuss Abdul El-Sayed's Michigan ad featuring conservative validators like Tucker Carlson, Keisha Lance Bottoms' Georgia ad targeting Fox viewers, the Senate Leadership Fund's attack on Troy Jackson's temperament in Maine, and a Democratic Super PAC ad highlighting Roger Marshall's history of suing patients and Epstein ties in Kansas. The conversation reveals Democratic strategies for winning over Republican-leaning voters through trusted messengers and contrast ads, while acknowledging the difficulty of flipping deep-red seats.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A Democratic Senate candidate in Michigan is running an ad featuring Tucker Carlson and Jesse Watters saying positive things about him to reach conservative voters.
Kansas hasn't elected a Democratic senator since 1932 — before Donald Trump was born — yet Adam Hamilton is competitive.
Roger Marshall charged patients predatory interest rates not required by law, then had police arrest a woman who owed him $50.
The Maine Senate Leadership Fund ad attacking Troy Jackson's temperament deliberately excludes the 'shut up' debate moment because it 'wasn't as bad as the story of it is.'
Key takeaways
Democrats are using conservative media figures as trusted messengers to reach Republican-leaning voters, as seen in El-Sayed's ad featuring Tucker Carlson and Jesse Watters praising him to defang Islamophobic attacks.
Keisha Lance Bottoms' Georgia ad explicitly addresses racial and gender bias by arguing Georgia voters are less prejudiced than national pundits assume, while attacking her opponent's corruption.
In Maine, Republicans are targeting older independent women — Susan Collins' core constituency — by painting Troy Jackson as temperamentally unfit, creating a 'permission structure' for Collins voters to stick with her despite Trump opposition.
The Kansas race represents a rare Democratic opportunity in a state that hasn't elected a Democratic senator since 1932, built on a stark character contrast: Adam Hamilton's pastoral decency versus Roger Marshall's history of suing patients for small debts and protecting Epstein.
Both parties are running 'contrast ads' in the final days that focus on character and temperament rather than policy, suggesting voters' decisions may hinge on personal qualities over issues.
Polling anxiety is pervasive among Democrats, who apply a 'PTSD model' of subtracting points from favorable polls based on 2016 and 2020 polling errors that underestimated Republican turnout.
Notable quotes
“It like kind of makes you perk up. If you haven't been paying close attention, you're like, "Jesse Watters likes him?"”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:36“It like showed what a complete he is. It lit a match.”
▸ Notable quotes · 19:22“Democrats are using a very advanced model called PTSD, where we're taking five points away from every poll.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:54“You got a bunch bunch people who have never voted for Democrat or Senate in their entire lives. And they could be in their 90s when that happens.”
▸ Notable quotes · 21:31“Adam Hamilton radiates decency. Like you just can't be around him and think like this is a truly decent human being.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:37“He had a woman arrested who owed him $50. $50.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:51Chapters
0:09 — Opening and election anxiety: Ian Pfeiffer welcomes Jen Psaki on the Friday before the election. Both express nervousness about polls being 'too good' and discuss the Democratic 'PTSD model' of subtracting points from favorable polls.
1:25 — Abdul El-Sayed and Keisha Lance Bottoms ads: Analysis of two ads targeting Fox News viewers: El-Sayed's Michigan ad using conservative validators to counter Islamophobic attacks, and Bottoms' Georgia ad addressing racial bias while attacking her opponent's corruption.
12:06 — Troy Jackson attack ad in Maine: Discussion of the Senate Leadership Fund ad painting Troy Jackson as temperamentally unfit, targeted at older independent women who form Susan Collins' base, creating a permission structure to vote for Collins despite Trump opposition.
18:07 — Roger Marshall attack ad in Kansas: Analysis of the Democratic Super PAC ad highlighting Marshall's history of suing patients, predatory lending, and Epstein ties, contrasting with Adam Hamilton's pastoral decency in a state that hasn't elected a Democratic senator since 1932.
Speakers
Ian Pfeiffer — Host
Jen Psaki — Guest