TLDR
The Cowboys defense collapsed against the 49ers, surrendering 584 yards and six touchdowns on six different defensive calls, exposing a systemic failure that has persisted through three coordinators in three years. Meanwhile, Joe Burrow is putting up historic numbers for the Bengals with five straight four-touchdown games, fueled by improved pass protection and elite receiver play, though Pittsburgh's passive coverage made it easier than it should have been. The panel argues Dallas's defensive issues are organizational, not just schematic, while Cincinnati's offense looks unstoppable if opponents don't disrupt its rhythm. The Cowboys have been outscored by 84 more points than any NFL defense over the last three seasons despite multiple coordinator changes.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The Cowboys' defensive collapse isn't new — they've been the worst defense by point differential for three straight years despite three different coordinators.
Von Miller, a future Hall of Famer, was singled up on Christian McCaffrey in coverage and predictably beaten for a touchdown.
The Bengals' offensive line, long a liability, is now a strength — Amarius Mims at right tackle and Chase Brown in pass protection are key reasons Burrow isn't getting hit.
Pittsburgh never once put hands on Chase or Higgins at the line of scrimmage, a strategic choice that contradicts how New England used to defend Peyton Manning's Colts.
Key takeaways
The Cowboys defense allowed six touchdowns on six completely different defensive looks — man coverage, weak-side blitz, Cover 4, Cover 3, Cover 0 — proving they have no base concept they execute well.
Dallas has fired three defensive coordinators in three years (Zimmer, Eberflus, Parker) and the defense has gotten worse each time, suggesting the problem is organizational philosophy and player development, not play-calling alone.
The Cowboys have been outscored by 84 more points than any other NFL defense over the last three seasons, with 19 more touchdowns allowed and 750 more yards given up than the next-worst team.
Joe Burrow has thrown four-plus touchdowns in five straight games, tying Peyton Manning's 2004 MVP season for the longest such streak in NFL history, and is averaging more TD passes per game than any quarterback ever through this point.
Burrow's leap coincides with finally having pass protection — right tackle Amarius Mims and running back Chase Brown's blitz pickup have kept him clean, allowing the offense to operate on rhythm.
The Steelers played soft coverage against Cincinnati, giving Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins 270 of their 297 receiving yards with five-plus yards of cushion, never disrupting the timing that makes the Bengals' offense lethal.
The Bengals now have the easiest remaining schedule in the league, positioning them to stack wins and make a playoff push if the offense maintains this level.
A former defensive coach on the panel argued the Cowboys should have dedicated a safety to shadow Christian McCaffrey all game rather than switching schemes, but the staff lacked the conviction to stick to one plan.
Notable quotes
“They allowed 584 yards, most in a home game in their history. Third time in franchise history they've scored 40 plus points in a loss. Two of them have come in the Brian Schottenheimer era.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:14“This was about as bad a game as any defense has ever played. That's not hyperbole.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:10“So, we can fire Christian Parker all we want, but when you don't have one thing that you're good at, that's what you get.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:33“In the last three years, the Cowboys defense has been outscored 84 more points than anybody else in the NFL. They've given up 19 more touchdowns and 750 yards. We fired Mike Zimmer, Matt Eberflus, and now Christian Parker.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:11“If you don't play Cincinnati like New England used to play Peyton Manning and the Colts, you can't stop them. You have to disrupt the timing and the rhythm of their offense.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:33“Last night, Higgins and Chase had 297 receiving yards. 270 of them came with more than five yards of cushion by the secondary.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:54Chapters
0:00 — Cowboys defensive meltdown vs 49ers: The 49ers scored six touchdowns on six different defensive calls against Dallas, exposing a defense with no identity. The Cowboys allowed 584 yards, most in a home game in franchise history, and became the third team ever to score 40+ points and lose — twice under Brian Schottenheimer.
4:00 — Systemic failure in Dallas: Panel argues firing Christian Parker won't fix the Cowboys; the defense has worsened under three coordinators in three years, is outscored by 84 more points than any NFL defense in that span, and lacks a single concept it executes well. The issue is organizational — hiring retreads and inexperienced coaches — not schematic.
8:47 — Joe Burrow's historic streak: Burrow threw four touchdowns in a fifth straight game, tying Peyton Manning's 2004 MVP record. He's averaging more TD passes per game than any QB in history through this point. The difference: he finally has pass protection (Amarius Mims, Chase Brown) and isn't getting hit.
11:50 — Steelers' passive coverage enables Bengals: Pittsburgh never pressed Ja'Marr Chase or Tee Higgins, giving them 270 of 297 receiving yards with five-plus yards of cushion. The panel emphasizes that disrupting timing — as New England did to Manning — is the only way to slow this offense, but Pittsburgh refused to try.
Speakers
Speaker 1 — Host/Play-by-play
Speaker 2 — Analyst (former defensive coach)
Speaker 3 — Analyst (Dan)
Speaker 4 — Analyst (Nick)
Speaker 5 — Analyst (Don)
Zack Taylor — Bengals Head Coach