TLDR
Ezra Klein interviews Ben Wikler, former Wisconsin Democratic Party chair and author of 'This Is the Plan,' about the mechanics, failures, and potential reinvention of the Democratic Party. They discuss why Democrats lost Wisconsin in 2024 despite strong organizing, the party's unpopular brand, the tension between formal party institutions and the 'amorphous blob' of Democratic politics, and how to rebuild trust through year-round local organizing rather than top-down messaging.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Wisconsin Democrats gained 14 state legislative seats and won the Senate race in 2024 while losing the presidential race by <1% — a rare split-ticket outcome driven by superior down-ballot turnout operations.
The 'Scott Walker loophole' — a state law allowing unlimited party-to-candidate transfers — was originally a GOP tool that Wisconsin Democrats adopted to counter billionaire spending (e.g., Elon Musk in the 2025 Supreme Court race).
Ron Johnson wins in Wisconsin partly by holding constant tele-town halls and championing vaccine-skeptic voters who feel mocked by mainstream institutions — a form of 'listening' that builds loyalty despite policy disagreements.
The DNC chair election is decided by ~400 DNC members; Wikler lost despite policy alignment because Ken Martin had spent years building personal relationships with those voters.
James C. Scott's 'Seeing Like a State' — a book about utopian planning disasters — is Wikler's framework for understanding Elon Musk's DOGE cuts: synoptic, top-down, and lacking democratic recourse.
Key takeaways
The Democratic Party's formal institutions (DNC, state parties) are distinct from the 'amorphous blob' of elected officials, pundits, and online discourse that voters actually associate with the party brand.
Wisconsin's Democratic Party succeeded by building deep, year-round neighborhood teams that know voters personally — unlocking apartment doors, knowing farm schedules, and becoming the trusted local 'editorial board' for down-ballot races.
Inflation and economic malaise were the dominant global forces in 2024; every ruling party in advanced democracies lost ground, making Harris's <1% loss in Wisconsin a relative overperformance.
The party's neutral primary system (a Wisconsin tradition since 1948) creates legitimacy for nominees but frustrates those wanting institutional control over candidate selection.
DNC fundraising disadvantages stem from structural changes (Citizens United, McCutcheon) that let national parties spend unlimited coordinated funds — but the DNC has not fully leveraged this.
Voters in the persuasive middle (≈10%) don't think ideologically; they assess candidates on a few 'stars in the sky' that form a constellation of trust, common sense, and shared priorities.
People in blue states can meaningfully impact swing-state elections through voter protection hotlines, giving circles for state legislative races, and supporting democracy-focused legal groups (SLEA, Democracy Defenders, etc.).
Rebuilding the party requires humility: government often fails when it imposes top-down plans without democratic feedback loops (per James C. Scott's 'Seeing Like a State').
Notable quotes
“They're the people who get rid of the piles of coal.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:14“The most that a campaign can hope to do is to add a couple of stars that allow you to draw a different constellation.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:54“If you can effectively become the editorial board for some people in your community... you can have a huge impact on what happens next.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:15“The only famines have been in places that are not democracies. If the people who are starving to death have a voice and a vote, then they can create enough noise that they ultimately get the food that keeps them alive.”
▸ Notable quotes · 54:42“This is a moment where people pouring themselves into the project of winning a contest in a democracy, and ensuring that people who want the rules to give everyone a voice win those elections is absolutely vital.”
▸ Notable quotes · 39:22Chapters
0:00 — What Is the Democratic Party Mechanically?: Klein and Wikler define the Democratic Party as both an 'amorphous blob' of associated figures and a formal institutional structure (DNC, state/county parties) with limited control over candidates due to primary systems.
2:02 — Why Harris Lost Wisconsin and the Global Context: Wikler analyzes the 2024 loss: inflation was the dominant global issue; every ruling party lost ground. Harris overperformed other battlegrounds, and Democrats won down-ballot races despite the presidential loss.
3:58 — The Party's Unpopular Brand and the Trust Deficit: Voters dislike the Democratic brand because they feel neither party delivers tangible results. Trust requires visible, local delivery — not slogans — and a shift from algorithmic outreach to human relationships.
7:24 — Wisconsin's Model: Neutral Primaries and Deep Organizing: Wisconsin's party constitution mandates primary neutrality (a 1948 reform). Success came from neighborhood teams that know voters personally, unlock doors, and become trusted local advisors for down-ballot races.
17:15 — Primary Contests, Party Unity, and the Median Voter: Wikler defends wide-tent primaries; unity exists on affordability. Persuadable voters (≈10%) decide on a few 'constellation' issues — trust, common sense, shared priorities — not ideological checklists.
32:52 — Ron Johnson's Appeal and the Art of Listening: Johnson wins by championing marginalized voters (e.g., vaccine skeptics) via constant tele-town halls. Listening to the unheard is smart politics even when the views are wrong.
39:40 — The DNC Chair Race and Reinventing the National Party: Wikler ran on year-round organizing and economic focus but lost to Ken Martin's institutional relationships. The DNC could leverage new unlimited coordinated spending rules and build a grassroots trust network.
47:50 — How Blue-State Residents Can Matter: Concrete actions: staff voter protection hotlines, join giving circles for swing-state legislative races (States Project, Movement Voter Project), support democracy litigation groups (SLEA, Democracy Defenders).
Speakers
Ezra Klein — Host
Ben Wikler — Guest