Christa Pike: what you haven’t heard — full story of the murder, accomplices, and haunting memories

Original Media · 48m · English · YouTube · Brian Entin

TLDR

This episode of Brian Entin Investigates revisits the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer by Christa Pike, then 18, and her accomplices Tadaryl Shipp and Shadola Peterson, detailing the brutal torture and killing that led to Pike becoming the youngest person on Tennessee's death row. It also covers Pike's subsequent prison violence — a 2001 attempted murder of a fellow inmate and a 2012 foiled escape plot — and the recent botched execution attempt in September 2024. Former Knoxville Police Chief Phil Keith, who led the original investigation, describes the crime scene as one of the most grotesque he ever saw and reflects on the lasting trauma for investigators and the victim's mother, May Martinez.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The victim's skull was withheld from her mother for 14 years due to post-conviction proceedings, only returned in January 2009.

•

Pike returned to the crime scene the day after the murder, giddy and laughing, asking officers if they had any suspects.

•

During police interrogation, Shipp fell asleep while being questioned about the murder.

•

The medical examiner stopped counting Slemmer's stab wounds because there were so many — she had to restart the alphabet multiple times labeling them.

•

After the botched execution, Pike was taken to Vanderbilt University Medical Center, one of the world's top hospitals, to save the life the state had just tried to end.

•

The prison guard involved in the 2012 escape plot avoided prison by cooperating with prosecutors against Pike's pen pal.

Key takeaways

•

Christa Pike, then 18, lured Colleen Slemmer to a remote area of the University of Tennessee campus under false pretenses, where Pike and her boyfriend Tadaryl Shipp tortured and killed Slemmer over 30 to 60 minutes using a box cutter, meat cleaver, and chunks of asphalt, while Shadola Peterson acted as lookout and held Slemmer down.

•

Shipp carved a pentagram into Slemmer's chest and later told police she was 'a sacrifice to the devil'; Pike took a piece of Slemmer's skull and showed it to Job Corps classmates the next morning, bragging about the killing.

•

Pike was convicted of capital murder in March 1996 and sentenced to death, becoming the youngest person on Tennessee's death row; Shipp, 17 at the time, was ineligible for the death penalty and received life with parole eligibility (denied in 2023, next review 2031); Peterson pleaded guilty to being an accessory in exchange for testimony and received probation.

•

While on death row, Pike was convicted of attempted murder in 2001 for using a shoelace to strangle a fellow inmate, admitting in a recorded call to her mother that the attack was premeditated and saying, 'If I'd have had 30 more seconds, we'd have a little chalk line out there.'

•

In 2012, a New Jersey pen pal was arrested for conspiring to bribe a guard to help Pike escape; the guard cooperated with prosecutors and avoided prison, the pen pal got seven years, and Pike was not charged in the plot.

•

On September 30, 2024, Tennessee's first execution attempt of a woman in over 200 years failed when two doses of pentobarbital did not kill Pike; IV lines could not be established and veins may have ruptured. She was hospitalized for 11 days at Vanderbilt, then returned to prison, now able to walk and speak.

•

Governor Bill Lee has suspended all executions pending an independent review of lethal injection protocols after this and a prior failed execution in May 2024; Pike's attorneys are seeking to block a second attempt, and litigation could take years.

•

Former Police Chief Phil Keith, who saw the crime scene firsthand, describes the murder as 'pure evil' and says the trauma remains vivid decades later; he believes the rule of law requires carrying out the death sentence, but acknowledges the case has haunted investigators and the victim's mother, May Martinez, who waited 14 years to receive her daughter's skull for burial.

Notable quotes

“It wasn't a surprise, although, you know, Vanderbilt is such a tremendous hospital. Um their capabilities are just incredible. Not just with cancer, but with other issues, and I'm sure that, um they had their best team on trying to uh resuscitate her and bring her back, and yeah, it was it was a bit agonizing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:55

“I think you know, following that law is is what we need to do. I'm not necessarily for or against death penalty, but I think in this case it's such an egregious act I mean and so much has been forgotten you know about the torment the torture that Colleen went through the battering stabbing um and and I know Pike is likely suffered some some issues some perhaps pain although it seems like the medications have had had reduced the the option of pain and that wasn't in the equation but I'd like to see it brought to an end. I mean it's um she she's pure evil and um I I don't have I don't have any sympathy for Pike she just um the what she did to to Colleen will forever be remembered by those of us that were at the crime scene and were involved in the investigation and obviously the trial but none more so than than than Colleen's mother.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:55

“Yeah, when I walked up to the to the crime scene, that was the obviously the first thing I I noticed was the battered skull. Um my PO had had advised me on the way down that they had identified the victim as a female. Um which you know, when I first walked up it it was really kind of hard to to tell whether it was a male or female. The outside of her skull was bashed in beyond recognition.”

▸ Notable quotes · 19:37

“And you know, all under the idea that like she said the day before the the murder uh to one of the Job Corps uh classmate, she just wanted to be mean and she's going to kill Colleen. And unfortunately, that classmate didn't sound the alarm or or try to to help Colleen.”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:41

“She did the very next day, the 13th. ... Yeah, the the crime scene was typically, you know, protected by tape, but you have to have, you know, security there. And so, we had officers, and UTPD was helping us out, and there was a UT officer that was actually standing right at the edge of the crime scene when when Pike walked up, and there were a couple of girls with her. Um and she was asking questions of the officer, you know, like, "Do you have any suspects? Do you know who it is?" Uh and that sort of thing. ... but yeah, she was back. She was giddy, uh laughing, um it it's pretty sick.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:58

“You know, you I was in law enforcement active law enforcement for 34 years. And at the time of that murder took place, I'd probably reviewed 200 250 homicide cases. Um and and you know, traffic fatalities. So, I'd I'd seen some of the what I'd consider to be the worst the worst cuz we had some really you know, gruesome murders prior to Pikes, but the the magnitude once you realize that the torture part because you could see at the crime scene the photographs were they dragged Colleen back. Um Colleen had um blood stains on her on her knees where they were mistreating her and you know, literally torturing her for this 30 minutes to an hour. ... I wouldn't even want to guess the number of stab wounds, but there had to be 70, 80 90 of them. I mean, they were just everything from deep gashes to puncture wounds to ... Uh and as a medical examiner said, she just quit counting cuz there were so many.”

▸ Notable quotes · 36:21

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction and botched execution recap: Host Brian Entin introduces the episode, summarizing the September 2024 botched execution of Christa Pike, the state's first attempt to execute a woman in over 200 years, and the subsequent hospitalization and legal fallout.

•

5:00 — The 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer: Entin details the brutal killing: Pike, Shipp, and Peterson lured Slemmer to a remote campus area, where Pike and Shipp tortured her for up to an hour with blades and asphalt, Shipp carved a pentagram, and Pike crushed Slemmer's skull with a chunk of asphalt.

•

8:15 — Aftermath, confessions, and sentences: Slemmer's body was found the next day; Pike confessed, kept a piece of skull as a trophy, and showed it to classmates. Pike got death; Shipp, 17, got life with parole; Peterson got probation for testifying. The victim's skull was withheld from her mother for 14 years.

•

11:20 — Pike's prison violence and escape plot: In 2001, Pike attempted to murder a fellow inmate with a shoelace, admitting premeditation in a recorded call. In 2012, a pen pal tried to bribe a guard to help her escape; the guard cooperated, the pen pal got seven years, Pike was not charged.

•

13:50 — Interview with former Chief Phil Keith: Entin interviews former Knoxville Police Chief Phil Keith, who describes the crime scene as the most brutal he ever saw, recounts Pike's giddy return to the scene, Shipp falling asleep during interrogation, and the lasting trauma for investigators and the victim's mother.

•

31:00 — Chief Keith on the torture and legal process: Keith details the extent of Slemmer's injuries — dozens of stab wounds, skull fragments driven into brain — and explains why the DA made a deal with Peterson despite overwhelming evidence. He reflects on the death penalty, the botched execution, and the case's enduring psychological impact.

•

47:30 — Closing reflections: Entin thanks Chief Keith and concludes the episode, emphasizing the importance of remembering the original crime and victim amid the focus on the botched execution.

Speakers

•

Brian Entin — Host

•

Phil Keith — Guest

⋮