TLDR
Political consultant Sarah Longwell explains why Trump's approval has collapsed from over 50% to 37.5% since taking office in 2025, based on hundreds of focus groups. The core drivers are Trump's unilateral tariffs and the war in Iran — both seen as his personal choices — which have raised prices and broken his core promise to lower costs. Corruption is breaking through as a top issue because voters are economically hurting and see Trump enriching himself. A split is emerging between the MAGA establishment and 'America First' populists who oppose the Iran war. Democrats have an opening in the midterms if they can articulate solutions to affordability, health care, and AI-driven disruption rather than just opposing Trump.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Trump voters' primary lens is not left-right but 'interested vs. uninterested' — most voters absorb politics as algorithmic 'vibes' from cultural content, not news.
Younger Trump voters (under 35) increasingly believe Israel controls Trump, a frame that blends anti-establishment populism with antisemitic tropes and may outlast Trump.
The masked faces of ICE agents is a specific, visceral trigger for voters — it signals government knows its actions are illegitimate and creates a 'zone of action' without accountability.
Rural voters are organizing against data centers at the local level, voting them down, and watching them get built anyway — deepening the sense that 'our word doesn't matter.'
Medicare for All is polling higher than ever, and the left has dropped the 'abolish private insurance' position, making universal health care newly viable across party lines.
Trump's strongest remaining issue with his base is cultural (gender, sports) — not economic or foreign policy — suggesting his coalition is held together by identity, not delivery.
Key takeaways
Trump's approval collapse stems from two specific choices he owns completely: unilateral tariffs and the Iran war, both of which raised prices after he promised to lower them.
Voters don't connect policy rhetoric to outcomes; they experience price increases directly (groceries, gas) and blame the president.
Corruption only became salient when economic pain made voters resent Trump's self-enrichment; they'd tolerate it if they thought he was delivering for them.
Jon Ossoff's corruption messaging works because he tells a step-by-step story rather than listing scandals that become white noise.
The Epstein files non-release broke trust with swingier Trump voters who believed Trump would expose elite corruption as their 'guy on the inside.'
A fracture exists between the MAGA establishment (Rubio, Johnson) and 'America Firsters' (Carlson, MTG) who oppose the Iran war and feel betrayed.
Immigration enforcement is alienating Trump voters who want criminals deported but object to masked agents, inhumane tactics, and targeting long-term residents.
Data centers are an emerging cross-partisan issue in rural areas: voters oppose them raising energy costs, threatening jobs via AI, and being imposed without local consent.
Medicaid cuts delayed until after the midterms will hit millions of Trump voters, potentially making health care the defining 2028 issue.
Democrats need candidates who can walk voters through complex new problems (AI, pricing, health care) with honesty rather than pretending to have all answers.
Notable quotes
“The first thing we do is we ask people, 'How do you think things are going in the country?' Every focus group, every single time, doesn't matter whether left, right, or center. And right now people say bad, and then they immediately start talking about the prices of something.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:26“Americans don't necessarily connect policy rhetoric to the outcome. They live through something, see the outcome, and then they decide how they feel about it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:57“I really thought it was going to be about us here at home.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:47“The reason that corruption is breaking through right now is for two reasons. The first is people are suffering economically and so all of Trump's focus on his ballroom, on the reflecting pool, it strikes voters at they are frustrated that he is not focused on them. He's focused on himself.”
▸ Notable quotes · 17:11“Trump can never fail. He can only be failed. And so, you have to have a scapegoat for why Trump is failing.”
▸ Notable quotes · 32:31“They're creating a zone of action that is wider. Because they're creating an anonymity. They're shifting the relationship between the agents and the public.”
▸ Notable quotes · 52:57“Our word doesn't matter.”
▸ Notable quotes · 60:17“Americans will let you say I don't know, but I'm working to figure it out and I'm going to figure it out in a way that doesn't leave you behind.”
▸ Notable quotes · 64:04“The number one thing that people say to indicate that they're still appreciative of what Donald Trump is doing is that he has made it clear that there are two genders, that he is keeping biological men out of women's sports.”
▸ Notable quotes · 68:17Chapters
0:00 — Trump's Approval Collapse: Tariffs and Iran War: Trump's net approval has fallen over 30 points since taking office in 2025. Longwell identifies two self-inflicted wounds: unilateral tariffs and the Iran war, both owned entirely by Trump, which raised prices after he promised to lower them.
3:28 — Voters Experience Prices, Not Policy: Focus groups reveal voters judge the economy through direct experience — grocery bills, gas prices — not macroeconomic indicators. They feel betrayed because Trump promised to prioritize 'America First' (meaning them) but is focused on himself.
16:10 — Corruption Salience Driven by Economic Pain: Corruption only became a top issue when voters' economic suffering made them resent Trump's visible self-enrichment. Jon Ossoff's storytelling approach — walking voters through specific corrupt deals — is effective because it avoids white noise.
22:40 — Epstein Files and the 'Guy on the Inside' Betrayal: Trump voters believed he would expose elite corruption (JFK, aliens, Epstein) as their insider. His failure to release the Epstein files broke trust with swingier voters who saw it as proof he's now the establishment.
25:10 — MAGA Split: Establishment vs. America Firsters: A fracture has opened between the MAGA establishment (Rubio, Johnson) who follow Trump unconditionally, and 'America Firsters' (Carlson, MTG) who oppose the Iran war and feel Trump was manipulated by Netanyahu.
28:20 — Iran War: From Quick Win to Quagmire: Voters expected a Venezuela-style quick operation. Instead, they see Trump repeatedly declare victory while the war drags on, raising gas prices and violating his 'no stupid wars' promise.
45:00 — Immigration: Voters Want Order, Not Cruelty: Trump voters support deporting criminals but object to masked agents, inhumane tactics, and targeting long-term residents. They distinguish 'deserving' vs. 'undeserving' immigrants and value fairness ('come the right way').
56:10 — Data Centers: Rural Revolt Against AI Infrastructure: Data centers have become a dominant local issue in rural areas — raising energy costs, threatening jobs via AI, and being imposed without community consent. Voters feel powerless when local opposition is ignored.
65:00 — Health Care and the 2028 Landscape: Delayed Medicaid cuts will hit millions of Trump voters post-midterms. Medicare for All is polling at historic highs. Democrats need communicators who can honestly walk voters through complex problems (AI, pricing, health care) rather than just opposing Trump.
Speakers
Host — Interviewer
Sarah Longwell — Guest