Arch Manning benched, Todd McShay reveals to Ryan Clark Sarkisian to blame & his No 1 pick at QB

Original Media · 10m · English · YouTube · The Pivot Podcast

TLDR

Todd McShay and Ryan discuss Arch Manning's concerning regression at Texas under Steve Sarkisian, Ohio State's quarterback crisis after Julian Sayin's injury, and why Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss — a former Division II non-starter — is the best quarterback in college football and a potential top-five NFL draft pick despite size concerns. McShay argues Manning is not improving in eye discipline or mental processing, Sarkisian's public protection of Manning has collapsed, and Ohio State must rely on defense and coaching to survive a brutal schedule. Chambliss's poise, decisiveness, and elite tape against Georgia make him a unique prospect who will defy NFL skeptics. The conversation covers three major college football storylines with direct scouting insights.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

A Division II quarterback who wasn't even a starter a year ago is now considered the best quarterback in college football and a potential top-five NFL pick.

•

Steve Sarkisian, widely regarded as an elite offensive mind, may not be suited to develop a young quarterback like Arch Manning.

•

Ohio State's offensive line and run game have been significant but overlooked weaknesses all season, not just recent issues.

Key takeaways

•

Arch Manning is regressing at Texas: he lacks comfort with eye discipline and mental clock management, and has lost the aggressive running ability that was his greatest strength, making him unable to operate the offense as needed.

•

Steve Sarkisian's public defense of Manning — calling criticism a 'cover-up' — ended abruptly this weekend, with Sarkisian admitting 'it's all on the tape' and hinting at a quarterback change, suggesting the program's patience has expired.

•

Sarkisian's reputation as an offensive mind may not translate to developing a young quarterback; his best QB work (Mark Sanchez, Jake Locker) involved more experienced players, raising questions about his fit for Manning's development.

•

Ohio State's playoff path now depends almost entirely on defense and coaching creativity: with Julian Sayin injured and the backup undeveloped, the offensive line struggling, and the run game unreliable, they cannot afford two more losses in a brutal three-week stretch.

•

Trinidad Chambliss, a former Division II Ferris State non-starter, is the best quarterback in college football due to rare poise, processing speed, decisiveness, and confidence — traits McShay values over measurables.

•

Chambliss's performance against Georgia was the best single-game quarterback tape of the 2025 season, and McShay would draft him in the top five despite his size, believing his mental makeup will overcome NFL skepticism just as it has at every previous level.

Notable quotes

“I'm watching a quarterback that's not getting better. I'm watching a quarterback in Arch that does not look comfortable with where his eyes need to be.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:28

“The mental clock, locking on the primary targets, not not having that same aggressiveness even in the second half of last season taking off and running and creating which is probably the greatest strength of his game is size, arm strength, the physical nature of of his game, and then that acceleration taking off and running.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:40

“As the head coach with a player like Arch Manning and with the scrutiny and the the the microscope that he's under, I understand why, and I called it a cover-up and it's probably too strong. But coaches are always protecting what's really going on.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:28

“He's the best quarterback in college football. I mean, he just is.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:27

“I got no problem taking him in the top five picks. I think he's just Some guys are built differently mentally, confidence-wise, processing, um aggressiveness, decisiveness. He's got all of it, man.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:37

“I can't wait to hear all those negative things about him and then watch him on an NFL field and what he shows that he's capable of overcoming yet again.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:59

Chapters

•

0:00 — Arch Manning's Regression at Texas: McShay details Arch Manning's lack of improvement in eye discipline, mental clock, and aggressiveness, questioning whether Sarkisian's system, development, or Manning's own processing is the root cause. Sarkisian's public protection of Manning has collapsed.

•

3:42 — Ohio State's Quarterback Crisis: With Julian Sayin injured and the backup undeveloped, Ohio State faces a brutal schedule (Oregon, etc.) relying on defense, Jeremiah Smith, and coaching creativity. The offensive line and run game have been season-long weaknesses.

•

6:15 — Trinidad Chambliss: Best QB in College Football: McShay makes the case for Ole Miss QB Trinidad Chambliss as the top quarterback in college football and a top-five NFL prospect, citing his poise, processing, decisiveness, and elite tape against Georgia despite his Division II background and undersized frame.

Speakers

•

Todd McShay — Analyst

•

Ryan — Host

⋮