Baby Koah Survives Being Buried Alive, Obsessed Stepdad’s Shrine of Underwear & Incest Dad Walks

Original Media · 1h 08m · English · YouTube · Annie Elise

TLDR

Annie Elise and Amy Collette cover six disturbing true crime cases from the week: Steven Chavez released after serving only five months for sexually assaulting his daughter Michaela Settles, who later died by suicide; Katie Suarez stabbed to death while jogging in Brooklyn by a former NYPD officer with a history of mental health issues and threats; Melissa Pilklor murdered by her ex-husband Norman Junior, who had built a shrine to their daughter Allison and violated protection orders; Andrea Cantorini shot by her boyfriend during a 14-minute phone call with her father; 11-month-old Koa Sharp found buried alive in a dog crate in South Carolina, allegedly by his father; and 10-year-old Malaysia Alford murdered by her foster mother Caprice Williams, who had previous abuse allegations expunged from her record.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Incest between adults is not a felony in some U.S. states, and even in California where it is a felony, the maximum sentence is only three years.

•

A former NYPD officer with documented mental health issues and family threats was allowed to work at an elementary school without intervention.

•

A foster parent with a substantiated case of causing a child's traumatic brain injury and malnutrition had her record expunged after appeal, enabling her to foster and kill another child.

•

An 11-month-old survived being buried alive in a dog crate for roughly 24 hours, likely due to an air pocket created by a towel wrapped around the crate and cool weather.

Key takeaways

•

Steven Chavez pleaded guilty only to felony incest and misdemeanor furnishing alcohol to a minor, receiving a one-year sentence despite brutally assaulting his 18-year-old daughter Michaela for four hours, causing injuries so severe she had to be carried into the ER; he served just five months before release.

•

Katie Suarez's killer, Syed Mohasib, was a former NYPD rookie who resigned in 2022 and was discharged from the military for mental health concerns; he had threatened to 'chop up' his mother and sister in 2024, yet was working as a paraprofessional at a Brooklyn elementary school at the time of the murder.

•

Melissa Pilklor's ex-husband Norman Junior built a shrine in a storage closet using their daughter Allison's underwear and sanitary products, violated protection orders repeatedly, and killed Melissa the day before a court hearing on those violations; he then killed himself during a police chase.

•

Andrea Cantorini's father, a retired NYPD officer, spent 14 minutes on the phone begging her boyfriend Juan Cornelio Diaz not to kill her while Diaz held a gun to her head; earlier that morning, Diaz had locked Andrea in a room waving a gun while their daughter screamed outside.

•

11-month-old Koa Sharp was found alive in a wired dog crate buried under a foot of dirt near his grandfather's house after being missing for 24 hours; his father Michael Sharp had a recent probation for aggravated breach of peace and prior domestic violence arrests.

•

Malaysia Alford's foster mother Caprice Williams faked text messages from the 10-year-old's phone after killing her to make it appear she had run away; Williams had previously been accused of causing a traumatic brain injury and severe malnutrition to another foster child in 2021, but successfully appealed and had her record expunged, allowing her to foster again.

Notable quotes

“You can rape your own daughter, that you can intoxicate a minor, that you can be, you know, commit sexual assault, but also incest, and basically get a slap on the motherfucking wrist.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:30

“How on earth could you say something's consensual when someone cannot even walk themselves into a hospital and they have to be carried in?”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:49

“He was screaming at the top of his lungs, which is a good thing in the baby world, I would guess.”

▸ Notable quotes · 51:06

“I keep expecting her to walk through the front door like she's just been out running errands, ready to do something spontaneous like she always did.”

▸ Notable quotes · 36:42

“Mommy, I know you are waiting for me to come home, but my family, they don't want me to be adopted, and I just wish we can all be together.”

▸ Notable quotes · 60:56

“Those 14 minutes just keep repeating over and over again in my head. I have to live with this the rest of my life.”

▸ Notable quotes · 43:29

Chapters

•

6:37 — Steven Chavez Released: Steven Chavez, who sexually assaulted his 18-year-old daughter Michaela Settles causing her to die by suicide, was released after serving only five months of a one-year sentence for incest and furnishing alcohol to a minor. Michaela's mother launched a Change.org petition demanding sentencing reform.

•

18:01 — Katie Suarez Murder: 28-year-old Katie Suarez was stabbed in the neck while jogging in Brooklyn. Suspect Syed Mohasib, a former NYPD rookie with mental health discharge and history of threatening family, was arrested after surveillance showed him in the area. He worked at an elementary school after the attack.

•

30:54 — Melissa Pilklor Case: Melissa Pilklor was murdered by ex-husband Norman Junior, who had built a shrine to their daughter Allison using her underwear and sanitary products. Allison had reported sexual assault and stalking for years with protection orders repeatedly violated. Norman killed himself before trial.

•

39:17 — Andrea Cantorini Shooting: Nurse Andrea Cantorini was shot by boyfriend Juan Cornelio Diaz in the Bronx while on a 14-minute phone call with her retired NYPD father. Earlier that morning, Diaz had locked Andrea in a room at gunpoint while their daughter screamed outside.

•

47:30 — Koa Sharp Buried Alive: 11-month-old Koa Sharp was found alive in a buried dog crate near his grandfather's house in South Carolina after 24 hours missing. Father Michael Sharp, with domestic violence history, was found hiding in a shed and arrested for burglary; charges for the burial pending.

•

57:06 — Malaysia Alford Foster Murder: 10-year-old Malaysia Alford was murdered by foster mother Caprice Williams, who faked texts from the girl's phone to stage a runaway. Williams had previous substantiated abuse of another foster child causing traumatic brain injury, but record was expunged after appeal.

Speakers

•

Annie Elise — Host

•

Amy Collette — Guest

⋮