TLDR
48 Hours correspondent Aaron Morardi details the Todd Mullis case: an Iowa farmer convicted of murdering his wife Amy with a corn rake in 2018. Their son Tristan, who found her, now says his father could only have been out of sight for seconds — not enough time to commit murder. New defense experts, a forensic pathologist and biomechanical engineer, conclude Amy's death was an accident: she fell backward onto the rake in a dark, crowded shed, and struggling caused additional injuries. Crucially, Amy's coat had only four holes while her body had six puncture wounds, which the experts say is impossible if the rake was swung repeatedly. The original defense attorney never examined the clothing. A 2025 postconviction hearing denied Mullis a new trial, but his attorneys plan to appeal.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A woman who fell on a corn rake at age 13 in Iowa initially had rumors spread that her family intentionally hurt her — she survived and cleared them, showing such accidents can be mistaken for homicide.
Falling onto a corn rake generates more force and energy than swinging it, contrary to the assumption that a swung weapon delivers more impact.
Amy's coat had fewer holes (four) than her body had puncture wounds (six), which the biomechanical engineer says is illogical if the rake was swung multiple times through the clothing.
The original defense attorney never examined the victim's clothing — a central piece of physical evidence — because he 'grew up on a farm' and didn't think an accident was possible.
The detailed animation illustrating the accident theory was never shown at the postconviction hearing; 48 Hours viewers saw more scientific demonstration than the judge did.
Key takeaways
Tristan Mullis, who was 13 when he found his mother with a corn rake in her back, now says he only lost sight of his father for seconds when getting water — not the hour-and-a-half window prosecutors claimed allowed the murder.
Biomechanical engineer Dr. Valentina Nye determined that falling onto the corn rake generates more force than swinging it, and that swinging a four-tine rake multiple times would have produced more holes in Amy's outer coat than the four found — yet her body had six puncture wounds.
The original defense attorney, Gerald Firehelm, admitted under oath that he never looked at Amy's clothing from the autopsy and dismissed the accident theory based solely on his personal farm experience with corn rakes.
The animation created by the new experts — showing Amy falling backward onto the rake and struggling, which caused additional injuries — was never presented at the postconviction hearing because it wasn't ready and funding wasn't in place.
The judge denied Mullis's petition after a 15-month wait, ruling he received a fair trial with competent counsel and that the jury reasonably credited the original medical examiner's homicide determination, despite the new scientific evidence.
Multiple people from rural Iowa contacted the reporters saying they would drive a critically injured person to the hospital themselves rather than wait for volunteer-based EMS, contextualizing Todd's decision to call 911 while driving.
The red shed where Amy was found was much farther from the barn than expected — a round trip of roughly four football fields — and the family home was closer to the shed than the barn, meaning the two youngest children were nearby during the alleged murder window.
Tristan Mullis, now 21, says he completely believes his mother's death was an accident and that investigators got it wrong; he insists he would not defend his father if he believed he had harmed his mother.
Notable quotes
“If my dad had ever done something to harm my mom, I would not be sitting here telling you the story.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:54“Her body has six holes. The clothes have less holes than six. He was convicted on swinging this rake multiple times into her body. How do you swing a four tine implement multiple times and have less holes in the outer clothes and more holes in the body? That is illogical.”
▸ Notable quotes · 18:04“I did not consider the accident theory to be a realistic possibility because I grew up on a farm with personal experience using a corn rake.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:03“Did you ever look at Amy Melissa's clothing from November 10th, specifically the coat, the sweatshirt, and the long sleeve shirt that she was wearing when she was injured? No.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:34“The animation shows a figure like Amy falling backwards onto the rake and then struggling to free herself from it. And they say that as she struggled to break free, she inadvertently caused additional injuries.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:25“According to Dr. Nye, falling onto the rake actually generates more force and energy than swinging the rake.”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:57Chapters
0:01 — Case background and initial investigation: Todd Mullis was convicted of murdering his wife Amy with a corn rake on their 400-acre hog farm in 2018. Their son Tristan, 13, found her with the rake in her back. Todd claimed accident; prosecutors argued homicide citing Amy's affair as motive and the medical examiner's finding of six puncture wounds from a four-tine rake.
6:18 — Tristan's testimony and timeline issues: At trial, Tristan testified he was with his father all morning but later admitted losing sight of him briefly twice. Prosecutors argued this window allowed the murder. Tristan now says the gaps were only seconds — insufficient for his father to travel to the shed, kill Amy, and return unseen.
10:36 — Farm visit reveals distance and layout: Morardi and Tristan toured the farm. The barn and shed were far apart — a round trip of about four football fields. Only two barn exits existed; either would have been visible to Tristan. The family home was closer to the shed than the barn, placing the two youngest children nearby.
14:09 — New experts and scientific reanalysis: Forensic pathologist Dr. Jennifer Hammers and biomechanical engineer Dr. Valentina Nye concluded Amy's death was an accident. Falling backward onto the rake in the dark, crowded shed and struggling caused the injuries. Falling generates more force than swinging. The coat had four holes; the body had six — impossible if the rake was swung repeatedly through clothing.
20:09 — Original defense failures uncovered: Original attorney Gerald Firehelm admitted he never examined Amy's clothing and dismissed the accident theory based on his farm experience. Co-counsel Bob Sabers later said Todd did not receive effective representation. The jury never saw the coat photo from the autopsy.
18:58 — Postconviction hearing and ruling: A six-day PCR hearing in February 2025 presented the new scientific evidence. The state offered no counter-experts but argued Mullis hadn't met the burden for a new trial. After 15 months, the judge denied the petition, upholding the conviction and finding the original trial fair.
25:24 — Aftermath and ongoing fight: Mullis's attorneys plan to appeal. Tristan, now 21, remains convinced of his father's innocence and continues advocating. Audience response largely favors a new trial, citing the coat-hole discrepancy and the implausible travel time between barn and shed.
Speakers
Ann Marie Green — Host
Aaron Morardi — 48 Hours correspondent
Tristan Mullis — Son of Todd and Amy Mullis
Dr. Valentina Nye — Biomechanical engineer
Gerald Firehelm — Original defense attorney