TLDR
The Mississippi Senate race has shifted to lean Democratic as challenger Scott Colom holds a 3,800-vote lead over incumbent Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith after Hinds County counted its affidavit ballots, with Colom netting over 700 of roughly 800. Though fewer than 15,000 ballots remain statewide, Hyde-Smith would need to win over 60% of them to overtake Colom — a path complicated by Colom's consistent overperformance in affidavit ballots across both Democratic and Republican counties. Hyde-Smith has not publicly addressed the count or presented a path to victory, which panelists find telling. If Colom prevails, he would become Mississippi's first African-American senator since Reconstruction. The AP and MSNBC have not yet called the race, rating it "lean Democratic" while awaiting more complete data from the state's decentralized county-run system. Panelists emphasize the historical magnitude: Trump won Mississippi by 22 points, yet Colom dramatically overperformed in Black-majority counties and even made gains in Republican areas. Stuart Stevens, a Mississippi native and Republican strategist, calls the race effectively over and describes Hyde-Smith as an "accidental senator" with no passionate base.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A Democrat is leading a Senate race in Mississippi — a state Trump won by 22 points — eight days after Election Day.
Cindy Hyde-Smith, the incumbent senator, has not made a single public appearance or statement to contest the count or rally supporters.
Scott Colom is winning affidavit ballots in Republican-leaning counties, not just Democratic strongholds.
Hyde-Smith blocked Colom's judicial nomination years ago; that decision may have inadvertently created the candidate who could defeat her.
Stuart Stevens, a veteran Republican operative, declares the race over and praises the Democratic candidate as a future "tremendous senator."
Colom's father was a Reagan-era Republican state treasurer, and his family's political lineage spans both parties and civil rights history.
Key takeaways
Scott Colom leads Cindy Hyde-Smith by approximately 3,800 votes after Hinds County — the state's second-largest — finished counting affidavit ballots, with Colom winning roughly 703 of 808 affidavit ballots compared to Hyde-Smith's 96.
Hyde-Smith would need to win over 60% of the estimated fewer than 15,000 remaining ballots statewide to overcome Colom's lead, but Colom has been outperforming his Election Day share by about 20 points in affidavit ballots across multiple counties, including Republican-leaning ones.
Cindy Hyde-Smith has not held press conferences, released a vote-count analysis, or publicly articulated a path to victory — a silence panelists interpret as a campaign that does not believe it can win.
If Colom wins, he will be the first African-American U.S. Senator from Mississippi since Reconstruction; his grandmother was a civil rights worker in Ripley, his father served as Republican state treasurer in the 1980s and co-founded the Innocence Project, and his mother was the state's first African-American chancery judge.
Trump carried Mississippi by over 22 points in 2024, yet Colom matched Vice President Harris's vote total in Hinds County (~62,000) while Hyde-Smith fell well short of Trump's total there, indicating both higher Black turnout and some Trump voters either staying home or crossing over.
Stuart Stevens, a longtime Mississippi Republican strategist, argues the race is effectively decided and that Hyde-Smith — an appointed incumbent with no organic base — lacks the institutional or grassroots support to mount a comeback.
The Associated Press and MSNBC have declined to call the race despite the "lean Democratic" rating, citing the state's decentralized county-run election system and the need for greater certainty about the composition and distribution of remaining affidavit ballots.
Panelists frame Colom's performance as a potential template for Democrats in deep-red states: a candidate deeply rooted in the community, campaigning on local issues, and engaging directly with Trump voters without abandoning Democratic identity.
Notable quotes
“This thing is done. It should be called. It's really a disservice to the state not to call it, because he needs to be up in Washington doing all the briefings and all the orientation that the senators do.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:06“If she was to win 90% of the ballots outstanding, she still would lose.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:26“His grandmother was a civil rights worker in Ripley, Mississippi, and now her grandson is going to be the first African-American since Reconstruction.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:42“She's sort of been a ghost. She's an accidental senator. She was first appointed. There's no passion there for her.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:29“President Trump won the state of Mississippi by over that is over 22 points. Now what we're talking about... Scott Colom in a lot of these places where he needed he did it in kind of a spectacular way.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:09“Hyde-Smith's plan, our path is getting narrower each day... She'd need to win over 60% of the estimated votes left to count to catch up with Colom.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:30Chapters
0:02 — Race overview and Hinds County results: The Mississippi Senate race now leans Democratic with Scott Colom leading incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith by 3,800 votes. Hinds County finished counting affidavit ballots; Colom netted ~703 of ~808, Hyde-Smith ~96. Counties have until Friday the 13th to certify.
2:16 — Outstanding ballots and path to victory: Fewer than 15,000 affidavit ballots remain statewide, but the decentralized county system makes exact numbers uncertain. Hyde-Smith would need >60% of remaining votes to overtake Colom, yet Colom has outperformed his Election Day share by ~20 points in affidavit ballots across counties.
4:06 — Hyde-Smith's silence and campaign dynamics: Hyde-Smith has not publicly addressed the count or presented a path to victory — unusual for an incumbent. Panelists interpret this as a campaign that does not believe it can win. Colom, by contrast, has been transparent and engaged.
6:06 — Historical significance and Colom's background: Stuart Stevens emphasizes the race's magnitude: Colom would be Mississippi's first Black senator since Reconstruction. His family history — civil rights grandmother, Republican father who co-founded the Innocence Project, pioneering mother — underscores the moment. Stevens calls Hyde-Smith an "accidental senator" with no passionate base.
9:07 — Vote patterns and Democratic overperformance: Despite Trump's 22-point statewide win, Colom matched Harris's Hinds County total while Hyde-Smith fell far short of Trump's. Higher Black turnout and some Trump voter crossover or abstention fueled Colom's gains, including in Republican counties.
10:15 — Implications for 2028 and Democratic strategy: Panelists discuss whether Colom's approach — local roots, issue-focused campaigning, engaging Trump voters — offers a model for Democrats in deep-red states. The election guru's memo confirms Hyde-Smith's path is narrowing; Colom's margin may expand as remaining ballots are counted.
Speakers
Katie — Host
Namdiega Wanwu — Reporter
Shawna Thomas — Political Director
Eugene Daniels — Senior Washington Reporter
Stuart Stevens — Senior Advisor, Lincoln Project