TLDR
Victor Davis Hanson argues that while historical patterns favor Democrats in the midterms, several factors — including the 2022 precedent, systematic polling bias against Republicans, recent international election surprises, weak Democratic candidates in key races, and Alaska ballot irregularities — create enough uncertainty that a Republican hold is plausible. Even if Democrats win Congress, Hanson contends that Clinton and Obama precedents show a president can still govern effectively through executive action and foreign policy, often gaining popularity as a 'lame duck above the fray.'
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A president who loses both chambers in his final two years often becomes more popular and effective, not less, because the opposition overreaches and the president appears statesmanlike by comparison.
The 2022 midterm — with triple the current inflation, higher gas prices, and major foreign-policy failures — produced a near-draw, contradicting the assumption that economic misery guarantees a wave election.
Pollsters knowingly sustain a pro-Democratic bias to stimulate donations and media buzz, then refuse to correct it until the very end, if at all.
Key takeaways
Historical data shows 90% of midterms favor the out party, and when presidential approval is below 40%, losses are especially severe — this is the baseline framework predicting Democratic gains.
The 2022 midterm is a direct counter-precedent: despite 9.1% inflation, $5 gas, the Afghanistan withdrawal disaster, and the Ukraine invasion, Biden lost only nine House seats and gained one Senate seat, suggesting structural resilience for the in-party.
Media coverage has flipped: in 2022 outlets downplayed economic and foreign-policy crises; now they amplify negatives despite robust GDP, low poverty, and high per-capita income, distorting voter perception.
Pollsters have consistently underestimated Republican support by roughly four points across the last three election cycles, partly because many pollsters lean left and use favorable polls to drive donations and media narratives without self-correcting.
Recent elections in Israel, British Columbia, and Brazil all defied polling consensus — Netanyahu survived, BC conservatives won a century-first victory, and Brazil's race was far closer than predicted — indicating a broader pattern of polling failure.
Democratic nominees in Texas (Allred), Michigan (El-Sayed), and other states hold positions sharply at odds with their electorates (e.g., anti-beef, anti-oil, open borders, alleged antisemitism), creating vulnerability that a generic Democrat would not face.
Alaska Democrats allegedly engineered a ballot-confusion scheme by recruiting a fake Republican candidate with the same name as the incumbent to split votes in the ranked-choice system, a tactic that may backfire.
If Republicans lose Congress, the Clinton and Obama models show a president can still govern aggressively: both used executive orders, waged war without congressional authorization (Kosovo, drone strikes, Libya), and entered treaties (Iran deal, Paris Accord) without Senate ratification, while their approval ratings rose after becoming 'lame ducks above the fray.'
Notable quotes
“We don't know really who's going to win the midterms. The Democrats could, but there's enough known unknowns that maybe they won't”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:00“Since 1900 in the last 126 years, only on three occasions did the in party in the White House pick up seats in the House or Senate”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:09“Joe Biden only lost nine seats and he picked up one in the Senate. So, that is a precedent.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:17“The polls don't have necessarily a good record the last three elections. It seems like the Republicans are under rated by about four points.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:54“Obama and Clinton have taught us that even when you come in with huge majorities and you people you're very unpopular below 40% and that continues and then you lose all the Congress by the time of your last 2 years in the last midterms. You're not done at all.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:50“What happens when a president is a lame duck and he loses the Congress, the opposition gets heady and they start talking in megalomaniac terms, narcissistic terms. And the president just acts like he's a lame duck above the fray.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:21Chapters
0:38 — Opening and conventional wisdom: Hanson introduces the midterm outlook: six months ago Republicans were favored for the Senate and the House was a toss-up; now pundits predict certain Democratic victories in both chambers.
1:06 — Historical midterm patterns: Since 1900, the president's party has gained seats in only three midterms (1934, 1998, 2002); 90% go to the out party, especially when presidential approval is below 40%.
2:10 — The 2022 counter-precedent: Despite 9.1% inflation, $5 gas, the Afghanistan collapse, and the Ukraine invasion, Biden lost only nine House seats and gained a Senate seat — a result the media downplayed at the time.
3:54 — Media bias and polling unreliability: Media now exaggerate negatives despite strong economic data; pollsters have underrated Republicans by ~4 points in the last three cycles, driven by ideological bias and fundraising incentives.
4:38 — International election surprises: Netanyahu defied exit polls in Israel, British Columbia elected its first conservative government in a century, and Brazil's race was far closer than predicted — all suggesting systemic polling failure.
5:51 — Weak Democratic candidates in key races: Nominees in Texas (Allred) and Michigan (El-Sayed) hold positions alien to their states — anti-oil, anti-beef, open borders, alleged antisemitism — making winnable seats competitive.
7:16 — Alaska ballot manipulation: Democrats allegedly recruited a fake Republican with the same name as incumbent Senator Sullivan to confuse voters in the ranked-choice system, a calculated ploy that may backfire.
8:17 — Governance after losing Congress: Clinton/Obama model: If Republicans lose, precedents show a president can still govern via executive orders, unilateral military action, and treaty-like agreements without Senate ratification, often rising in popularity as the opposition overreaches.
Speakers
Victor Davis Hanson — Host/Commentator