SANCTIONS DEMANDED over Trump PATHETIC Alaska SCHEME...

Original Media · 11m · English · YouTube · Legal AF

TLDR

The ACLU has filed a blistering legal brief urging the Ninth Circuit to summarily affirm the dismissal of the Trump DOJ's appeal in an Alaska election case and sanction the government attorneys involved. The Trump DOJ sued to block certification of Mary Peltola's likely victory, claiming ballot confusion over two candidates named Dan Sullivan, and sought a government investigation into voters' true intentions — a remedy the district court found both impossible and a violation of the secret ballot. Despite the lower court's dismissal, the DOJ continues its appeal, which the ACLU calls "embarrassing and indefensible" and driven by President Trump's personal directive. The brief argues the appeal is frivolous, violates professional ethics, and warrants sanctions including fees and double costs. The host emphasizes this story has faded from headlines but the appeal remains active.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Trump DOJ's requested remedy included a government "inquisition" into individual voters' true intentions, which would require federal agents to question citizens about how they voted — a direct assault on the secret ballot.

•

Stanley Woodward, who represented Trump's criminal co-defendant in the classified documents case, is one of the DOJ attorneys signing the appeal brief.

•

The ACLU's brief explicitly invites advocacy groups to file bar complaints against the DOJ attorneys, framing the appeal as a violation of professional conduct rules that previously led to disbarments after the 2020 election.

Key takeaways

•

The Trump DOJ sued to block certification of Alaska's election results and sought a government investigation into how individual voters cast their ballots, which the district court dismissed as both practically impossible and a violation of the constitutional right to a secret ballot.

•

Despite the lower court's dismissal, the Trump DOJ has not withdrawn its appeal to the Ninth Circuit, continuing to pursue relief that cannot legally or practically be granted.

•

The ACLU's new brief calls the DOJ's legal theory "embarrassing and indefensible" and an "abomination of a lawsuit" filed at President Trump's personal behest — Trump publicly stated, "I'm the one that said, 'Do it.'"

•

The ACLU argues the DOJ attorneys, including high-ranking official Stanley Woodward (who represented Trump's co-defendant in the classified documents case), have violated professional ethics rules against frivolous litigation and should face sanctions including fees, double costs, and potential bar discipline.

•

The brief frames the continued appeal as an attempt to hold an entire state's democracy hostage for political purposes, noting that no legitimate legal theory can justify the requested relief of interrogating voters about their true intentions.

•

The case has largely disappeared from media coverage since the pre-midterm period, but the appeal remains pending and the Ninth Circuit now has the opportunity to impose consequences for what the ACLU characterizes as sanctionable conduct.

Notable quotes

“The legal theory advanced by the United States here is embarrassing and indefensible. The court should summarily affirm and then order the attorneys for the United States to explain why they or their client should not be sanctioned for pursuing a frivolous appeal.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:19

“And even if the United States were within shouting distance of a valid legal theory, summary would still be proper. The relief sought indefinitely blocking the certification of an ongoing US end election and running an inquisition into individual voters true intentions was and remains completely illegal.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:05

“The Department of Justice's apparent desire to enter the election season political fray is no substitute for a legitimate legal theory, and it cannot justify a shameful attempt to hold Alaskans vote hostage.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:35

“Why did the United States file this abomination of a lawsuit? Let us not mince words. This lawsuit was filed at the behest of President Trump.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:33

“No principle of law or free government allows holding an entire state's democracy hostage while roving federal agents questions citizens about who they really wanted to vote for.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:39

“The continued pursuit of this litigation by attorneys for the Department of Justice is an embarrassing and sanctionable violation of professional norms.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:09

Chapters

•

0:00 — ACLU brief targets Trump DOJ Alaska appeal: The host introduces the ACLU's new legal brief calling the Trump DOJ's ongoing Ninth Circuit appeal in an Alaska election case "embarrassing and indefensible" and seeking sanctions against government attorneys.

•

0:19 — Background: DOJ lawsuit over two Dan Sullivans: The Trump DOJ sued before the midterms to block Mary Peltola's victory, claiming ballot confusion from two candidates named Dan Sullivan; Alaska courts rejected this, clarifying both had a right to run and voters were not confused.

•

2:21 — ACLU argues appeal is frivolous and sanctionable: The ACLU brief demands summary affirmance and sanctions, arguing the DOJ's legal theory has no merit and the requested relief — investigating voters' true intentions — is impossible and violates the secret ballot.

•

6:36 — Trump personally directed the lawsuit: The brief quotes Trump stating "I'm the one that said, 'Do it,'" and argues political directives from powerful officials cannot transform a frivolous argument into a colorable one.

•

7:43 — Call for sanctions and bar discipline: The ACLU urges the Ninth Circuit to impose fees, double costs, and other penalties, and signals that the DOJ attorneys' conduct violates professional ethics rules warranting bar complaints and potential disbarment.

Speakers

•

Host — Legal commentator

•

Co-host — Legal AF contributor

⋮