Haberman on Nvidia scandal: 'The BIGGER story' is whether AI chips are being SMUGGLED into China

Original Media · 10m · English · YouTube · MS NOW

TLDR

New York Times reporting reveals U.S. intelligence believes Alice Wong, partner of NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang, was a Chinese intelligence asset, prompting a DOJ investigation into whether advanced Blackwell chips are being smuggled to China. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent is openly criticizing Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and calling for changes at NVIDIA, while President Trump — briefed on the intelligence at least twice — invited Huang on a presidential trip after being reminded of the concerns, and is unlikely to raise the issue with Xi Jinping.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Despite being reminded by Marco Rubio that Alice Wong was believed to be a Chinese intelligence asset, President Trump invited Jensen Huang to join a presidential trip to Alaska during a refueling stop.

•

The intelligence community withheld a defensive briefing from Jensen Huang not because they doubted the threat, but because they did not want to alert Alice Wong that she was under surveillance.

•

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent's public attacks on Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and NVIDIA reveal open policy warfare within the Trump administration over how aggressively to restrict chip exports to China.

Key takeaways

•

U.S. intelligence agencies assess that Alice Wong, who had a relationship with NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang, was a Chinese intelligence asset, and this assessment was briefed to President Trump at least twice, including via a secret memo from Marco Rubio.

•

A DOJ investigation is examining whether NVIDIA's most advanced Blackwell chips — critical to the AI race and restricted from export to China — are being smuggled into China, with online analysts suspecting they may already power sophisticated Chinese AI models.

•

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has been publicly criticizing Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and demanding changes at NVIDIA, signaling significant internal administration tension over China chip policy; Bessent would not do so without Trump's tolerance.

•

Marco Rubio personally briefed Trump on the intelligence about Alice Wong just before Trump invited Jensen Huang to join a presidential trip to Alaska, overriding the intentional exclusion of Huang from that trip.

•

Jensen Huang's departure from NVIDIA's board stemmed from multiple corporate culture issues, including an affair with a direct report that he initially denied to The New York Times before later admitting it.

•

The intelligence community did not give Huang a defensive briefing about Alice Wong because they did not want to tip off their surveillance target (Wong), and officials did not believe Huang necessarily knew what was happening.

•

President Trump is not expected to raise the intelligence concerns about Alice Wong or chip smuggling with Xi Jinping during their upcoming meeting, preferring to avoid the topic entirely.

•

There is deep skepticism in Silicon Valley about the 'spy' allegations against Alice Wong, with many executives questioning why they weren't informed if a foreign intelligence operative was close to the most important CEO in American technology.

Notable quotes

“There is no credible debate that she is believed to be a Chinese intelligence asset by U.S. intelligence this has been something that they have been tracking for some time”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:05

“President Trump likes Jensen Wong is, as you said before, very aware that NVIDIA is propping up a significant aspect of the economy, which is what. And this this frontier of A.I. is what President Trump has really staked the economic maintenance of the U.S. on right now.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:03

“This pushback is coming from allies of Jensen Wong. It has not come from anywhere else.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:48

“He invited him to join in Alaska during a refueling stop. And when Marco Rubio learned this, he went and briefed the president and reminded him, reminded, not briefed for the first time, of this intelligence.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:47

“There is no credible debate about what Xi was doing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:03

“And that is a risk that there will be that again.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:47

Chapters

•

0:00 — NVIDIA intelligence allegations surface: Maggie Haberman outlines New York Times reporting that U.S. intelligence believes Alice Wong, Jensen Huang's partner, was a Chinese intelligence asset, and that a DOJ investigation is probing whether advanced Blackwell chips are being illegally smuggled to China.

•

1:51 — Silicon Valley skepticism and defensive briefing question: Joe Scarborough relays Silicon Valley doubts about the 'spy' allegations and asks why Huang wasn't given a defensive briefing if the intelligence community knew a foreign operative was close to him for a year.

•

3:26 — Why no defensive briefing was given: Haberman explains defensive briefings are withheld to avoid tipping off surveillance targets; officials didn't believe Huang knew about Wong's activities, and Trump values NVIDIA's role in the U.S. AI economy.

•

4:44 — Internal administration conflict over chip policy: Scott Bessent's public criticism of Howard Lutnick and NVIDIA reveals Trump-tolerated infighting; Bessent wouldn't speak out without presidential acquiescence, and the pressure comes from Huang's allies.

•

5:53 — Chip tiers, export controls, and Blackwell concerns: Haberman details legal vs. illegal chip sales to Southeast Asia and China, the debate over Blackwell chips, and fears they may already power advanced Chinese AI models, raising national security alarms.

•

7:22 — Huang's board departure and corporate issues: Huang left the board amid broader corporate culture problems, including an affair with a direct report he initially denied to the Times, not solely due to the intelligence allegations.

•

7:50 — Trump-Xi meeting implications: Trump is unlikely to raise the intelligence or chip smuggling issues with Xi; the meeting is expected to be a photo op with strongmen leaders, and Xi may be the one to bring it up.

•

8:32 — Helsinki parallel and Rubio's intervention: Rubio briefed Trump on the intelligence just before Trump invited Huang on the Alaska trip, overriding staff's intentional exclusion; Barnacle compares Trump's likely deference to Xi to his 2018 Helsinki stance with Putin.

Speakers

•

Joe — Host

•

Maggie Haberman — Guest

•

Mike Barnacle — Guest

•

Rachel — Host

⋮