Republicans Lost So Badly They’re Now Fighting Over Who to Blame | Next Level

Original Media · 1h 03m · English · YouTube · The Bulwark

TLDR

The Bulwark's 'Next Level' podcast hosts JVL, Sarah Longwell, and Tim Miller celebrate Democratic victories in the 2026 midterms, analyzing key races in Mississippi, Texas, and Iowa while dissecting Republican responses including Jim Jordan's leadership win, Stephen Miller's White House appointment, and Trump's election denialism. They critique media narratives downplaying democratic threats and discuss the GOP's doubling down on culture war tactics that failed with voters.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Black turnout reached near-presidential levels in a midterm, a historic anomaly that powered Southern upsets.

•

Joe Manchin went 0-for-7 on endorsements in a cycle where Democrats had their best midterm since 1974.

•

Colin Allred won Texas by 12 points — a massive shift in a state Republicans assumed was safely red.

•

A neo-Nazi streamer accidentally broadcast himself masturbating on a World of Warcraft stream while discussing midterm results, then worried about losing a $100 donor.

•

Sarah Longwell's focus groups reveal Trump-to-Democrat voters explicitly citing 'a check on Trump' and faith alignment as motivations.

Key takeaways

•

Democrats achieved historic midterm gains driven by surging Black and Hispanic turnout plus depressed rural white turnout, not a broad 'common sense' rejection of extremism as some media claim.

•

Jim Jordan's elevation to House Minority Leader despite the Ohio State wrestling abuse scandal signals Republicans choosing performative grievance over governance.

•

Stephen Miller's appointment as Chief of Staff confirms Trump's hardline immigration stance despite momentary mixed signals.

•

Republican culture war attacks (on Colin Allred's sexuality, Rob Sand's gay staffer) backfired with focus group voters who found them weird and off-putting.

•

Winning Democratic candidates in red states ran culturally aligned, locally tailored campaigns — addressing faith, rejecting national party litmus tests, and avoiding primary scrutiny.

•

Josh Hawley's performative one-hour 'fast' exemplifies the GOP's Christian nationalist posturing over substantive response to electoral defeat.

•

Media outlets (WSJ, Axios) dismissing democratic threats ignore the massive organizing and legal work that prevented election subversion — a Y2K-style fallacy.

•

The GOP's 2028 bench appears weak as potential candidates like Dan Crenshaw double down on unpopular positions rather than differentiate.

Notable quotes

“It's like a Haley Stevens, Joe Manchin double duty. 0 for 7. Imagine being a Democratic senator, former Democratic senator doing seven endorsements in a year where the Democrats win more elections than they've won since 1974 and you get zero.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:12

“Jim Jordan is the person that you pick to lead the conference when you want to have a temper tantrum. You know, like he is he's not the person that you pick to lead the conference if you're trying to rehabilitate or rebuild the Republican brand.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:50

“The weirdest thing about the J.D. Vance trying to throw Trump under the bus last week was that Vance's argument was the Iran war lost us seats in the Senate and the House, and that's why it's bad. Right? Like as if there aren't any other reasons why it could be bad.”

▸ Notable quotes · 23:31

“It is like the Y2K thing... if the entire world doesn't blow up, then everything was fine and it was always going to be fine. And you people over there are the ones with your hair on fire. Oh, you're alarmists. I hate that so much.”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:54

“They just did. They just did. They just voted for a check on Trump. They did see it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 42:57

“This isn't actual Christianity. And it drives me crazy and it's really toxic and poisonous. And here Mr. Runaway is doing it again. Why? What did what is he Who is this performance for?”

▸ Notable quotes · 48:51

Chapters

•

0:00 — Post-Election Celebration & Mississippi Senate Race: Hosts celebrate Democratic midterm wins, discuss Scott Colom's narrowing gap in Mississippi against Cindy Hyde-Smith, and mock Joe Manchin's 0-for-7 endorsement record.

•

5:00 — Freshman Democrats & Republican Meltdowns: Sarah highlights joyful new Democratic freshmen orientation; Tim describes Republican influencer meltdowns (Tim Pool, Laura Loomer, Katie Miller) and schadenfreude over their coping mechanisms.

•

10:20 — Jim Jordan Leadership & Ohio State Scandal: Analysis of Jim Jordan's House Minority Leader win over Steve Scalise, detailing the Ohio State wrestling abuse scandal (177 accusers) and what Jordan's elevation signals about GOP priorities.

•

15:00 — Stephen Miller, Dan Crenshaw & Trump's Direction: Debate over Stephen Miller as Chief of Staff, Dan Crenshaw's tweet urging doubling down on unpopular policies, and whether Trump is moderating or entrenching.

•

28:00 — Election Denialism & Media Gaslighting: Trump's half-hearted election fraud claims in Alaska; critique of Wall Street Journal and Axios editorials dismissing democratic threats as 'hand-wringing' despite organizing that prevented subversion.

•

47:00 — Josh Hawley's Performative Fast & Iowa Culture War: Mockery of Hawley's one-hour 'fast and prayer' event; analysis of Rob Sand (Iowa) attacked for gay staffer, and why GOP culture war tactics are failing with voters.

•

54:00 — Texas, Mississippi & Winning Campaign Strategies: Focus group insights on Colin Allred's 12-point Texas win, Scott Colom's culturally aligned Mississippi campaign, and how Democrats won by running local races free from national party interference.

•

60:00 — Neo-Nazi Streamer Incident & Paywall Tease: Discussion of Will Sommer's piece on a neo-Nazi streamer caught masturbating on stream during election night; hosts transition to member-only content.

Speakers

•

JVL — Host

•

Sarah Longwell — Co-host

•

Tim Miller — Co-host

⋮