TLDR
Smosh hosts Shayne, Angela, and Chanse read and react to four Reddit stories from 'Am I the Asshole' and 'Am I the Devil' subreddits. Stories include: a single woman upset her friend copied her hypothetical wedding plan; a husband refusing to stay with his in-laws and baby while his wife attends a wedding in China; a man who texted his girlfriend's 'affair partner' only to discover it was her elderly aunt; and a 21-year-old treating relationships like collectible cards while deciding whether to 'switch' girlfriends. A bonus cooking story involves someone serving mashed potatoes left out for 10 hours. The hosts unanimously judge the OPs as the assholes in each case, emphasizing communication, empathy, and basic food safety. The episode is sponsored by DoorDash, Zocdoc, and Wayfair. The hosts are Shayne Topp (Smosh cast member), Angela Giarratana (Smosh cast member), and Chanse McCrary (Smosh cast member).
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Reddit deemed the single woman the asshole for being upset her friend 'stole' her hypothetical wedding plan — the consensus was that sharing an idea publicly for years forfeits any claim to it.
The 'affair partner' texting 'love you princess, hugs and kisses' was the girlfriend's elderly aunt who makes chocolate cake — the OP's girlfriend had mumbled about the cake in her sleep, not a lover.
The 21-year-old OP actually accepted Reddit's verdict in a comment, admitting 'switching' was a terrible word choice and saying he'd go to therapy, apologize, and take time alone — rare accountability for this format.
The mashed potato OP served the spoiled potatoes anyway, and guests ate them — 'no emergencies were made' but the hosts were horrified that 'tasting fine' was the safety standard used.
Key takeaways
Pranks that cause genuine distress aren't funny — the hosts condemn a 'prank' where friends pretended to abandon a friend with childhood trauma, noting pranks are only funny if the target also laughs.
Communication prevents catastrophic misunderstandings — the man who texted his girlfriend's 'affair partner' and blocked the number destroyed his relationship because he never talked to her first; it was her aunt.
You cannot 'own' a life idea — the single woman upset her friend 'stole' her hypothetical wedding plan (elopement + surprise reception) was told by Reddit and the hosts that ideas aren't copyrightable, especially when shared publicly years in advance.
Parenting requires sacrifice and turn-taking — the husband in China who refused to stay with his son for one night so his wife could attend a wedding was called out for expecting his wife to always handle childcare and for not learning basic language tools like Google Translate.
Relationships aren't transactional comparisons — the 21-year-old listing two women's 'stats' (violin skills, religion, bra size joke) like baseball cards to decide which to 'switch' to revealed he views partners as objects, not people; commenters urged therapy and letting both women go.
Food safety is non-negotiable when feeding others — the person who served mashed potatoes left unrefrigerated for 10 hours (tasting 'tart' like lemon) was slammed for risking guests' health instead of buying replacements or skipping the dish.
Insecurity often masquerades as righteous anger — multiple OPs framed their hurt as moral outrage, but the hosts identified underlying insecurity: fear of being copied, fear of isolation, fear of betrayal, fear of making the 'wrong' life choice.
Notable quotes
“A candle loses nothing from lighting another candle. There's just more light now, come on.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:32“Pranks are only funny if they are funny to the one being pranked. Otherwise, you're just being an ass.”
▸ Notable quotes · 45:17“If a man is ever having a hard time choosing between you and another woman, let him pick the other woman because he doesn't actually love either of you.”
▸ Notable quotes · 62:30“You're thanking us for your fuck up or for telling you that you fucked up.”
▸ Notable quotes · 34:26“I'm a simple man and an atheist, which might be important. Wanting a house of his own, a great family, being able to do some work every day for the company and some for the local community.”
▸ Notable quotes · 53:00“Will my entire party get sick from eating my mashed potatoes?”
▸ Notable quotes · 66:29Chapters
0:00 — Intro & Devil Criteria: Hosts Shayne, Angela, and Chanse introduce the 'Am I the Devil' theme and discuss what makes someone a 'devil' in everyday life: fighting service workers, projecting insecurities, expecting things from others, and conscious lying.
2:31 — Story 1: Stolen Wedding Idea: A single woman is upset her friend Brittany copied her years-long plan to elope in a national park with a surprise reception, using the same photographer and announcement wording. Reddit and hosts deem OP the asshole — ideas aren't owned, especially when shared publicly.
14:01 — Story 2: Husband Left in China: A husband traveling in China with his wife and baby refuses to stay with his non-English-speaking in-laws while his wife attends a friend's wedding. Hosts call him out for expecting his wife to always handle childcare, not learning translation tools, and making it about his discomfort.
25:58 — Story 3: Texted the 'Affair Partner': A man sees 'Love you princess' on his girlfriend's phone, reads her history, texts the contact calling him scum, deletes messages, and blocks the number. Update reveals it was her elderly aunt who makes chocolate cake. Girlfriend dumps him.
37:34 — Story 4: Prank Gone Wrong: OP and friend pretend to abandon their friend Jack at his girlfriend's house after a movie argument. Jack cries, revealing childhood abandonment trauma. OP's defensive comment doubles down. Hosts condemn the cruelty and lack of accountability.
52:04 — Story 5: Should I Switch Girlfriends?: A 21-year-old lists two women's traits like specs — current girlfriend (witch, nurse, changed for him) and 'other girl' (violinist, Catholic, poetic) — asking which to 'switch' to. Hosts and Reddit say he's not ready for relationships; OP later accepts feedback.
66:03 — Story 6: Spoiled Mashed Potatoes: OP serves mashed potatoes left out 10 hours, tasting 'tart' like lemon. Guests eat them; no one gets sick. Hosts are horrified by the food safety risk and OP's casual attitude.
72:40 — Outro & Sponsors: Hosts wrap up, thank guests Angela and Chanse, joke about autoplay switching hosts, and read final sponsor spots for DoorDash, Zocdoc, and Wayfair.
Speakers
Shayne — Host
Angela — Co-host
Chanse — Co-host