TLDR
This two-part Serialously episode revisits the 2018 Watts family murders, where Chris Watts killed his pregnant wife Shannan and daughters Bella and Cece. Host Annie Elise details the marriage's deterioration, Chris's affair with coworker Nicole Kessinger, the murders and cover-up, and the disturbing evidence suggesting Kessinger knew more than she claimed — including phone pings near the Watts home the morning of the murders, deleted searches for Shannan dating back to 2017, and a suspicious 11-minute call where she allegedly listened in on Chris's conversation with detectives. The episode also covers Chris's 2026 prison marriage application to Lizzie Henderson.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Nicole Kessinger searched for Shannan Watts online a year before she allegedly met Chris Watts, contradicting her claim that she didn't know Shannan's name until after the murders.
Chris Watts tried to induce a miscarriage by slipping Shannan OxyContin — obtained through an unknown source — because the pregnancy made him feel trapped, and Shannan suffered severe cramps during the North Carolina trip.
During the murders, 4-year-old Bella asked Chris if he was going to do the same thing to her that he did to Cece, and fought him off while saying 'Daddy, no.'
Chris Watts's prison letters and a self-published prayer book refer to Nicole Kessinger as a 'Jezebel' with 'evil spirits' who manipulated him, yet he also wrote love letters to her and allegedly maintained contact.
The Weld County District Attorney admitted they never independently verified the forensic data showing Kessinger's 2017 searches because Chris Watts's guilty plea 'precluded any need to further probe.'
A neighbor's surveillance footage from the morning of the murders appears to show a woman with long hair and a purse near the Watts home, aligning with Kessinger's phone ping and lack of alibi.
Key takeaways
Chris Watts's marriage deteriorated rapidly in summer 2018 while Shannan was in North Carolina with their daughters; he became cold, stopped communicating, and began an affair with coworker Nicole Kessinger, seeing her 4-5 times a week by July.
Shannan suspected another woman was involved and texted Chris: 'These kids are my world, and I have to protect them from the evil of the world. I shouldn't have to protect them from evil family.'
Chris failed a polygraph, then confessed to his father that Shannan killed the girls and he strangled her in a rage — a story no one believed. He later admitted in a 2019 FBI interview that he smothered the girls first, then strangled Shannan, and drove all three bodies to an oil site.
Bella (4) witnessed her mother's murder, asked 'Daddy, no' before being smothered, and both girls were alive during the 40-mile drive to the disposal site, believing they were taking their mom to the hospital.
Nicole Kessinger's phone pinged at a tower near the Watts home at 6:16 a.m. on the morning of the murders, though she lived 25 minutes away and didn't clock into work until 3 p.m. that day.
Kessinger searched for 'Shannan Watts' on Google as early as September 2017 and January 2018 — months before meeting Chris in June 2018 — and deleted those searches along with queries about whether police can trace text messages.
On the night of the murders, Kessinger had a 51-minute call with Chris that she deleted 8 minutes later; later, during a 10-minute period of 'dead air' on Chris's calls with detectives, he called Kessinger for under a minute, then switched to his work phone while she called his personal phone for 11 minutes — suggesting a three-way listen-in.
Chris Watts applied to marry Lizzie Henderson in August 2026, eight years after the murders; she moved from Ohio to Wisconsin to be near him, goes by 'Lizzie Watts,' and her family appears supportive despite knowing his crimes.
Notable quotes
“These kids are my world, and I have to protect them from the evil of the world. I shouldn't have to protect them from evil family. Our kids deserve the same love and attention that other kids get, nothing less.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:50“I was having an affair with this girl and I ended up in love with two women at the same time. It's what led up to what happened. She is of evil spirits like Jezebel.”
▸ Notable quotes · 72:39“Jezebel was the forbidden fruit and it was costly.”
▸ Notable quotes · 73:15“The words of a harlot has brought me low. Her flattering speech was like drops of honey that pierced my heart and soul, but little did I know all her guests were in the chamber of death.”
▸ Notable quotes · 73:49“You will never see the baby whether you're in prison or not. We don't want you free Christopher Watts because we do know you're a psychotic killer, possibly serial killer.”
▸ Notable quotes · 143:52“Just get a freaking divorce, okay?”
▸ Notable quotes · 150:14Chapters
0:25 — Introduction and Case Overview: Annie Elise introduces the two-part deep dive on Chris Watts, noting recent news of his 2026 prison marriage application and promising new details from phone records, time cards, and investigation files.
6:05 — The Watts Marriage and Deterioration: Details Chris and Shannan's marriage, Shannan's health struggles and high-risk pregnancies, and the rapid breakdown in summer 2018 when Chris became distant, stopped communicating, and began an affair with Nicole Kessinger while Shannan was in North Carolina.
21:37 — The Affair with Nicole Kessinger: Chronicles the timeline of Chris and Nicole's relationship from June 2018, including frequent meetups, a secret calculator app for photos, a trip to Great Sand Dunes, and Chris's continued contact with Nicole while Shannan was missing.
25:05 — The Murders and Discovery: Describes the murders on August 13, 2018, the discovery of bodies at the oil site, Chris's failed polygraph, his initial false confession blaming Shannan, and the recovery of the girls from oil tanks with 8-inch openings.
41:45 — Chris's 2019 FBI Confession: Details Chris's revised account: he smothered the girls first, strangled Shannan, drove all three bodies to the oil site, and killed the girls there after they witnessed their mother's burial — with Bella asking 'Daddy, no' before her death.
51:55 — Nicole Kessinger's Suspicious Behavior: Outlines Kessinger's lies and inconsistencies: pre-meeting searches for Shannan, phone ping near Watts home on murder morning, deleted calls and searches, alleged listen-in on Chris's detective call, and queries about OxyContin and miscarriage.
78:05 — Prison Updates and Chris's Remarriage: Covers Chris's prison life, religious conversion, self-published prayer book blaming 'Jezebel' Nicole, and his 2026 application to marry Lizzie Henderson, who moved to Wisconsin and goes by 'Lizzie Watts.'
135:55 — Nicole Kessinger's Whereabouts and Theories: Discusses Kessinger's disappearance, name change application, alleged Alaska move and baby rumors, a 2025 funeral sighting in Montana, and the unresolved question of whether she was involved or merely complicit.
Speakers
Annie Elise — Host
Chris Watts — Perpetrator
Nicole Kessinger — Mistress
Shannan Watts — Victim
Detective / FBI Agents — Investigators
Sandy Rzucek — Shannan's Mother
Dylan Tallman — Prison Inmate
Lizzie Henderson — Fiancée