The Karen Read 20/20 interview. The Trooper Proctor Problem: will it get worse? The Emily Show Ep309

Original Media · 48m · English · YouTube · Emily D. Baker

TLDR

Legal analyst Emily D. Baker discusses two major developments in the Karen Read case: a Commonwealth notice about Trooper Michael Proctor's work cell phone extraction, and the ABC 20/20 interview with Karen Read. Proctor, the lead investigator, had derogatory personal texts about Read revealed at trial; now his work phone and cloud data have been extracted, raising questions about who should review it for discoverable material given Proctor's embedded role in the Norfolk DA's office. The 20/20 episode, recorded July 2023, features Read maintaining innocence, discussing her cracked tail light and hiring an attorney the day O'Keefe was found, while defense attorney Alan Jackson asserts a conspiracy and cover-up. Both developments complicate a potential January 2025 retrial. Baker emphasizes the need for independent review of Proctor's work phone and notes the 20/20 interview may affect jury selection but contains no clear statements against interest. The Norfolk DA's office is exploring hiring an outside firm to review the phone data. Baker also highlights the broader fallout for State Police credibility across multiple cases, including the Sandra Birchmore investigation. The episode underscores the lack of checks and balances when investigators work hand-in-hand with prosecutors, and the difficulty of retrying a high-profile case after extensive media coverage.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Karen Read 20/20 interview was recorded in July 2023, almost a year before trial, not contemporaneously as viewers might assume.

•

The Norfolk DA's office buried the disclosure that they are exploring hiring an outside firm to review Proctor's phone data in a footnote of their court filing.

•

Trooper Proctor's work phone extraction was provided to the DA's office by State Police on September 4, 2024, but the Commonwealth's notice frames the review as 'ascertaining how to determine what if any information' is discoverable — language Baker finds evasive.

•

Alan Jackson decided to take the case after Karen Read emailed him with the subject line 'Boston cop murder' and attached all the autopsy photos, which convinced him O'Keefe had not been struck by a car.

•

The 20/20 episode showed a reporter describing the crime scene as 'dynamic' with 'evidence changing by the hour' due to weather, which Baker notes is a mischaracterization — weather may destroy evidence, but evidence itself should not 'change.'

Key takeaways

•

The Norfolk DA's office is reviewing Trooper Proctor's work phone and cloud extraction for discoverable material, but Emily Baker argues the review should be conducted by an independent party since Proctor was embedded in the DA's office and worked hand-in-hand with prosecutors on the Read case, creating a conflict of interest.

•

The Commonwealth's notice reveals Proctor's work phone contains information about open investigations, surveillance video, personal identifying information, medical information, location data, and grand jury proceedings — making wholesale turnover impossible, but the question of who decides what is discoverable remains critical.

•

The 20/20 interview with Karen Read was recorded on July 24, 2023, nearly a year before trial, and was edited into the episode rather than presented as a continuous conversation, making it difficult to assess her demeanor or credibility as a potential trial witness.

•

Alan Jackson, Read's defense attorney, made exceptionally strong pretrial statements to 20/20 declaring Read 'absolutely innocent,' asserting a conspiracy and cover-up by people in the Fairview house, and stating he had 'never been more sure of anything' — statements that may complicate jury selection for a retrial.

•

Karen Read told 20/20 she hired an attorney the same day John O'Keefe was found because she believed his mother suspected her due to her cracked tail light, a detail that aligns with the prosecution's theory but was excluded from trial after the judge denied a motion to admit it.

•

The 20/20 episode gave significant attention to the harassment of John O'Keefe's family by protesters outside the courthouse, which Baker condemns as unacceptable regardless of one's view of the case, noting that two things can be true: the investigation may be flawed, but the victim's family deserves respect.

•

Trooper Proctor's credibility issues extend beyond the Read case — he handled murder and unattended death investigations for Norfolk County, and the Sandra Birchmore case revealed State Police missed over 30,000 text messages during their extraction, prompting defense attorneys across Massachusetts to demand similar discovery in every State Police case.

•

The Norfolk DA's office is exploring hiring an outside firm (a 'discovery referee' or 'taint attorney') to review Proctor's phone data, which Baker supports as the only appropriate solution given the entanglement between the DA's office, State Police, and Proctor.

Notable quotes

“the text messages were juvenile and they were jokes but they did not impact the testimony”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:56

“I think two things can be true at once you can have a circumstance where you feel that this was not a well done investigation that law enforcement shouldn't be proceeding with this but that doesn't change how his family should be treated”

▸ Notable quotes · 29:11

“the evidence shouldn't be changing it's snowing the crime scene is dynamic due to weather but that shouldn't change the evidence”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:28

“there is no way she will be found guilty he also said that he has never been more sure of anything he has ever said in court than what he said in this case”

▸ Notable quotes · 35:36

“I'll speak slow so you can understand”

▸ Notable quotes · 42:17

“the Fallout from the Proctor stuff is still going to be bigger than the Fallout from the 2020 interview as to Karen Reed”

▸ Notable quotes · 45:07

Chapters

•

3:02 — Trooper Proctor's work phone notice: The Commonwealth filed a notice about Trooper Proctor's work cell phone and cloud extraction, which contains data from open investigations, grand jury proceedings, and personal information. The Norfolk DA's office is reviewing what is discoverable, but Baker argues an independent party should conduct the review due to Proctor's embedded role in the office.

•

13:00 — Conflict of interest in DA review: Baker explains her concern that the Norfolk DA's office lacks checks and balances because State Police investigators work hand-in-hand with prosecutors, unlike her experience where law enforcement investigated independently and prosecutors reviewed cases separately. This structure allowed Proctor's bias to go unchecked early in the investigation.

•

21:39 — Outside firm disclosure in footnote: Buried in footnote 2 of the filing, the DA's office reveals it is exploring hiring an outside firm to examine the phone and cloud data — a 'discovery referee' or 'taint attorney' — which Baker supports as the only appropriate solution.

•

24:59 — 20/20 interview timing and structure: The Karen Read interview was recorded July 24, 2023, nearly a year before trial. The episode intersperses edited clips of the interview with trial footage, commentary, and coverage of John O'Keefe's family, rather than presenting a continuous conversation.

•

28:10 — Harassment of O'Keefe family: The 20/20 episode showed video of protesters screaming at John O'Keefe's mother, sister, and friends outside the courthouse. Baker strongly condemns this behavior, emphasizing that criticism of the investigation does not justify harassing the victim's family.

•

35:30 — Alan Jackson's pretrial certainty: Defense attorney Alan Jackson told 20/20 there was 'no way' Read would be found guilty, declared a conspiracy and cover-up by people in the Fairview house, and said he had 'never been more sure of anything' — statements that may poison the jury pool for retrial.

•

39:00 — Read's account of hiring an attorney: Read said she hired attorney David Yannetti the day O'Keefe was found because she believed his mother suspected her due to her cracked tail light. This aligns with the prosecution's theory but was excluded from trial after the judge denied a motion to admit it.

•

45:00 — Broader fallout and retrial challenges: Baker predicts the Proctor fallout will exceed the 20/20 impact, affecting every State Police case in Norfolk County. Jury selection for a January 2025 retrial will be extremely difficult, and the defense's appeal of the denied motion to dismiss adds further litigation.

Speakers

•

Emily D. Baker — Host and legal analyst

⋮