Did the Doctor Kill the Doctor? | Full Episode

Original Media · 42m · English · YouTube · 48 Hours

TLDR

This 48 Hours Mystery episode examines the 1993 murder of Dr. Lynn Goudy, a high-risk OBGYN found strangled in her car at Winthrop Hospital. Her boyfriend of 4.5 years, Dr. Timothy Stryker, was the prime suspect but never criminally charged. A 2006 civil trial found him liable for her wrongful death, awarding $15 million to her family. Years later, Stryker was convicted of perjury for fabricating a witness to overturn the verdict, receiving a 4-year prison sentence. The murder remains officially unsolved, though the district attorney continues to pursue the case.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Stryker had Lynn's missing personal items (briefcase, tote bag, jacket) in his apartment, which he claimed he was 'helping' police by providing.

•

Stryker went on the couple's planned scuba vacation alone the day of Lynn's memorial service, which even his sister thought was a terrible idea.

•

The fabricated witness Craig Pisanu was 18 at the time of the murder and claimed he knocked on the car window to ask for a condom during a sexual encounter, seeing Lynn with a man who looked nothing like Stryker.

•

Stryker orchestrated the false alibi through a patient, Richard Chambers, who acted as a middleman; they provided Pisanu with maps, diagrams, prescription pain pills, and antidepressants — with lot numbers traced back to Stryker.

•

Pisanu admitted lying and received immunity; Stryker received 4 years for perjury but still has never been charged with Lynn's murder.

Key takeaways

•

Dr. Lynn Goudy was found strangled in the backseat of her car in a remote hospital parking lot on October 4, 1993; the medical examiner ruled it a violent homicide with injuries at 24 separate sites.

•

Dr. Timothy Stryker, her boyfriend and colleague, was the immediate focus of police due to manual strangulation suggesting she knew her killer, a volatile relationship with physical confrontations, and his possession of her missing belongings (briefcase, tote bag, jacket).

•

Stryker failed a polygraph, went on a planned Caribbean vacation alone days after the murder (missing her memorial service), and stopped cooperating with police.

•

After a 13-year legal battle, Lynn's family won a civil wrongful death suit in 2006; a jury found Stryker responsible and awarded $15 million.

•

In 2008, Stryker produced a witness, Craig Pisanu, who claimed to see a tall blonde man with Lynn the night she died — but investigators proved the story was fabricated, with cell records showing Stryker and Pisanu had communicated for months.

•

Stryker was arrested for perjury and conspiracy to suborn perjury; he pleaded guilty in 2009 and was sentenced to 4 years in prison.

•

Stryker's wife of 14 years, Mikael, filed for divorce after his perjury conviction.

•

District Attorney Jerry Leone vows to continue the homicide investigation personally; the criminal case remains open.

Notable quotes

“Nobody can do that to themselves. You can't even move your arms.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:38

“It's easier to accept suicide.”

▸ Notable quotes · 22:55

“I just put a noose around my neck. I can see my world crumbling.”

▸ Notable quotes · 23:16

“Strangling is grotesquely personal. Requires the hands around the neck and holding the person tight as they're gasping for breath and trying to escape.”

▸ Notable quotes · 29:00

“The affidavit is an utter and complete lie. It's a story that was created by Tim Stryker.”

▸ Notable quotes · 36:59

“This plea today by Tim Stryker may close a chapter, but the book remains open in this case and I will continue to handle the homicide investigation personally.”

▸ Notable quotes · 40:47

Chapters

•

0:00 — Background: Two Doctors, One Relationship: Introduces Dr. Lynn Goudy and Dr. Timothy Stryker, both successful physicians who dated for 4.5 years. Colleagues describe their compatibility and shared adventures.

•

10:08 — Premonition and Planned Vacation: Lynn has a disturbing dream about a plane crash before a planned Caribbean scuba trip with Stryker. She decides not to go; Stryker insists she was still going.

•

16:49 — Relationship Troubles and Final Days: Friends describe Stryker as controlling and rigid; Lynn was burned out and planning to break up. Witnesses report an argument about the trip on September 30, 1993 — the last day she was seen alive.

•

16:49 — Discovery and Investigation: Lynn's body found four days later in her car. Medical examiner rules homicide by manual strangulation. Police immediately focus on Stryker; he fails polygraph and makes incriminating statements.

•

21:00 — Suspicious Behavior: Vacation and Missing Belongings: Stryker goes on Caribbean vacation alone days after murder. Police find Lynn's missing briefcase, tote bag, and jacket in his apartment. He claims he was helping the investigation.

•

24:39 — Civil Trial and $15 Million Verdict: After 13 years, Lynn's family wins civil wrongful death suit. Jury finds Stryker liable for malicious, willful killing and awards $15 million. Stryker vows to appeal.

•

33:12 — Fabricated Witness and Perjury Conviction: Stryker produces witness Craig Pisanu claiming to see a tall blonde man with Lynn. Investigation reveals elaborate fabrication involving patient Richard Chambers, cell records, and prescription drugs traced to Stryker. Stryker pleads guilty to perjury, gets 4 years.

•

40:18 — Aftermath and Ongoing Investigation: Stryker's wife files for divorce. DA Jerry Leone reaffirms commitment to solve the homicide; criminal case remains open.

Speakers

•

Narrator — 48 Hours correspondent

•

Dr. Timothy Stryker — Prime suspect / Defendant

•

Mikael Stryker — Timothy Stryker's wife

•

Jean Stryker — Timothy Stryker's sister

•

Lisa Zolot — Lynn Goudy's friend and former patient

•

Paula Dennett — Colleague / Nutritionist

•

Dr. Stanton Kessler — Medical Examiner

•

Jerry Leone — District Attorney

•

Michael Altman — Attorney for Goudy family

•

Martin Leppo — Stryker's defense attorney

•

Craig Pisanu — Fabricated witness

•

Richard Chambers — Middleman / Stryker's patient

•

Marguerite Reuthus — Lynn Goudy's mother

•

John Rayfuse — Lynn Goudy's brother

⋮