TLDR
This 48 Hours Mystery episode examines the 1993 murder of Dr. Lynn Goudy, a high-risk OBGYN found strangled in her car at Winthrop Hospital. Her boyfriend of 4.5 years, Dr. Timothy Stryker, was the prime suspect but never criminally charged. A 2006 civil trial found him liable for her wrongful death, awarding $15 million to her family. Years later, Stryker was convicted of perjury for fabricating a witness to overturn the verdict, receiving a 4-year prison sentence. The murder remains officially unsolved, though the district attorney continues to pursue the case.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Stryker had Lynn's missing personal items (briefcase, tote bag, jacket) in his apartment, which he claimed he was 'helping' police by providing.
Stryker went on the couple's planned scuba vacation alone the day of Lynn's memorial service, which even his sister thought was a terrible idea.
The fabricated witness Craig Pisanu was 18 at the time of the murder and claimed he knocked on the car window to ask for a condom during a sexual encounter, seeing Lynn with a man who looked nothing like Stryker.
Stryker orchestrated the false alibi through a patient, Richard Chambers, who acted as a middleman; they provided Pisanu with maps, diagrams, prescription pain pills, and antidepressants — with lot numbers traced back to Stryker.
Pisanu admitted lying and received immunity; Stryker received 4 years for perjury but still has never been charged with Lynn's murder.
Key takeaways
Dr. Lynn Goudy was found strangled in the backseat of her car in a remote hospital parking lot on October 4, 1993; the medical examiner ruled it a violent homicide with injuries at 24 separate sites.
Dr. Timothy Stryker, her boyfriend and colleague, was the immediate focus of police due to manual strangulation suggesting she knew her killer, a volatile relationship with physical confrontations, and his possession of her missing belongings (briefcase, tote bag, jacket).
Stryker failed a polygraph, went on a planned Caribbean vacation alone days after the murder (missing her memorial service), and stopped cooperating with police.
After a 13-year legal battle, Lynn's family won a civil wrongful death suit in 2006; a jury found Stryker responsible and awarded $15 million.
In 2008, Stryker produced a witness, Craig Pisanu, who claimed to see a tall blonde man with Lynn the night she died — but investigators proved the story was fabricated, with cell records showing Stryker and Pisanu had communicated for months.
Stryker was arrested for perjury and conspiracy to suborn perjury; he pleaded guilty in 2009 and was sentenced to 4 years in prison.
Stryker's wife of 14 years, Mikael, filed for divorce after his perjury conviction.
District Attorney Jerry Leone vows to continue the homicide investigation personally; the criminal case remains open.
Notable quotes
“Nobody can do that to themselves. You can't even move your arms.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:38“It's easier to accept suicide.”
▸ Notable quotes · 22:55“I just put a noose around my neck. I can see my world crumbling.”
▸ Notable quotes · 23:16“Strangling is grotesquely personal. Requires the hands around the neck and holding the person tight as they're gasping for breath and trying to escape.”
▸ Notable quotes · 29:00“The affidavit is an utter and complete lie. It's a story that was created by Tim Stryker.”
▸ Notable quotes · 36:59“This plea today by Tim Stryker may close a chapter, but the book remains open in this case and I will continue to handle the homicide investigation personally.”
▸ Notable quotes · 40:47Chapters
0:00 — Background: Two Doctors, One Relationship: Introduces Dr. Lynn Goudy and Dr. Timothy Stryker, both successful physicians who dated for 4.5 years. Colleagues describe their compatibility and shared adventures.
10:08 — Premonition and Planned Vacation: Lynn has a disturbing dream about a plane crash before a planned Caribbean scuba trip with Stryker. She decides not to go; Stryker insists she was still going.
16:49 — Relationship Troubles and Final Days: Friends describe Stryker as controlling and rigid; Lynn was burned out and planning to break up. Witnesses report an argument about the trip on September 30, 1993 — the last day she was seen alive.
16:49 — Discovery and Investigation: Lynn's body found four days later in her car. Medical examiner rules homicide by manual strangulation. Police immediately focus on Stryker; he fails polygraph and makes incriminating statements.
21:00 — Suspicious Behavior: Vacation and Missing Belongings: Stryker goes on Caribbean vacation alone days after murder. Police find Lynn's missing briefcase, tote bag, and jacket in his apartment. He claims he was helping the investigation.
24:39 — Civil Trial and $15 Million Verdict: After 13 years, Lynn's family wins civil wrongful death suit. Jury finds Stryker liable for malicious, willful killing and awards $15 million. Stryker vows to appeal.
33:12 — Fabricated Witness and Perjury Conviction: Stryker produces witness Craig Pisanu claiming to see a tall blonde man with Lynn. Investigation reveals elaborate fabrication involving patient Richard Chambers, cell records, and prescription drugs traced to Stryker. Stryker pleads guilty to perjury, gets 4 years.
40:18 — Aftermath and Ongoing Investigation: Stryker's wife files for divorce. DA Jerry Leone reaffirms commitment to solve the homicide; criminal case remains open.
Speakers
Narrator — 48 Hours correspondent
Dr. Timothy Stryker — Prime suspect / Defendant
Mikael Stryker — Timothy Stryker's wife
Jean Stryker — Timothy Stryker's sister
Lisa Zolot — Lynn Goudy's friend and former patient
Paula Dennett — Colleague / Nutritionist
Dr. Stanton Kessler — Medical Examiner
Jerry Leone — District Attorney
Michael Altman — Attorney for Goudy family
Martin Leppo — Stryker's defense attorney
Craig Pisanu — Fabricated witness
Richard Chambers — Middleman / Stryker's patient
Marguerite Reuthus — Lynn Goudy's mother
John Rayfuse — Lynn Goudy's brother