Trump Orders DOJ to MISLEAD Federal Judge about Federal Park CLOSING?!?

Original Media · 18m · English · YouTube · Legal AF

TLDR

Federal Judge Anna Reyes issued a temporary restraining order blocking the Trump administration's attempt to close 400 acres of East Potomac Park in Washington DC, including a public golf course. The administration claimed the closure was for safety reasons and loss of a golf operator, but the judge found the real reason was President Trump's directive to redesign the course with architect Tom Fazio. The government had fired the operator themselves, then argued they had to close the park because no operator existed — which the judge called a self-inflicted injury and pretext.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Department of Justice lawyer explicitly admitted in court that they were 'carrying out the president's directive' and that 'that's the way the government works.'

•

The government buried the seawall safety concern near the end of a six-page closure document, despite claiming it was an imminent threat requiring immediate closure.

•

The same lawyer who made these admissions had already faced a credibility crisis with Judge Reyes, who had opened an ethical inquiry into whether DOJ lawyers had lied in her courtroom weeks earlier.

Key takeaways

•

Judge Reyes found the administration's stated reasons for closing East Potomac Park — safety concerns about a seawall and lack of a golf operator — were pretextual, with the real motive being President Trump's directive to close the park for a Tom Fazio golf course redesign.

•

The National Park Service terminated its contract with the golf operator (National Links Trust) effective November 15, the same day Trump demanded closure, and the government's own lawyer admitted this was done 'consistent with the president's direction.'

•

The judge highlighted a contradiction: if the seawall posed imminent danger to life, the Park Service would not have allowed 30,000 runners to use the course for the Marine Corps Marathon two days after Trump's closure directive.

•

The government's lawyer argued that fixing safety hazards depends on 'the nature of the safety issue, the cost of fixing it, and the number of people affected,' which the judge compared to a cost-benefit analysis tolerating preventable deaths.

•

Judge Reyes ruled the closure violated the National Environmental Policy Act, the Administrative Procedure Act, and the National Park Service's own regulations, calling the government's explanations 'irrational.'

•

The temporary restraining order requires the park to remain open to the public as green space — the government does not have to operate the golf course, but cannot block public access to the 400-acre area.

•

The judge made herself available on a Sunday for emergency clarification of the order, signaling the urgency and unusual nature of the government's actions.

Notable quotes

“Yes, we will. No, you won't.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:24

“You tied that knot yourself. You fired the operator and then you come to the court with unclean hands and try to oppose a temporary restraining order.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:34

“They were commanded by Fiat by Donald Trump to close the effing golf course and everything around it so he could redesign it with his favorite golf architect Tom Foazio and take it out of the public domain. Period.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:55

“The government reverse engineers additional justifications for the park's closure.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:37

“The cancellation of the management of the course agreement is an entirely self-inflicted and selfserving injury.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:57

“The court, hopefully not naively, has more faith in the federal government than that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:47

Chapters

•

0:00 — Case overview and Trump's motive: Michael Popock introduces the case: Judge Reyes issued a TRO blocking the closure of 400 acres of East Potomac Park. Trump wants to develop a world-class golf course with architect Tom Fazio; the judge ruled a president cannot close federal parkland by social media fiat without notice and hearing.

•

1:20 — Government's categorical exclusion document: The Park Service issued a categorical exclusion document announcing indefinite closure effective November 15, 2026, citing 20 years of unresolved issues and a crumbling seawall buried near the end — which the judge found suspicious.

•

3:12 — Judge's TRO and core reasoning: Judge Reyes ordered the park kept open as green space. She rejected the government's argument that losing the golf operator required closing 400 acres, noting the government fired the operator themselves and then claimed they had to close.

•

5:12 — President's directive admitted in court: The judge's order quotes the hearing transcript where the DOJ lawyer admitted they were carrying out Trump's directive to close the park for the Fazio redesign, and that the Park Service terminated the operator lease 'consistent with the president's direction.'

•

10:15 — Marine Corps Marathon contradiction: Judge Reyes noted the Park Service allowed 30,000 runners to use the course for the Marine Corps Marathon two days after Trump's closure order, undermining claims of imminent seawall danger.

•

11:34 — Cost-benefit analysis on safety: The government lawyer argued safety fixes depend on cost and number of people affected. The judge rejected this as tolerating preventable harm, comparing it to refusing to stop the Boston Marathon bombing due to cost.

•

12:58 — Judge's final order and violations found: The judge found violations of NEPA, APA, and NPS regulations, calling explanations 'irrational.' The TRO keeps all 400 acres open to the public; the government need not operate the golf course but cannot block access.

Speakers

•

Michael Popock — Host and legal commentator

⋮