TLDR
In this Court of History episode, hosts Sydney Blumenthal and Sean Wilentz speak with Ian Bassin of Protect Democracy about the post-midterm landscape. They argue that while democracy won a battle in the midterms, the constitutional crisis continues as the Trump administration rejects separation of powers, threatens to prosecute Congress for oversight, and ignores court orders. Bassin emphasizes that congressional oversight must go beyond exposure — it must preserve a documentary trail of corruption to enable future civil asset recovery, since criminal accountability is blocked by presidential immunity and pardons. They discuss digital evidence preservation (including Palantir's records), the concept of 'autocratic capture' of private companies, and early signs of corporate realignment like Alex Karp's public shift.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The Supreme Court's US v. Trump decision immunizing the president from criminal accountability means civil asset forfeiture may be the only viable path to recover stolen public funds.
Palantir, a company associated with the far right, holds comprehensive digital records of the administration's actions (every keystroke at DOD) that could be subpoenaed by Congress.
The concept of 'autocratic capture' reverses the usual 'state capture' dynamic: it's the state pressuring private businesses for loyalty, not businesses buying government influence.
Key takeaways
The Trump administration fundamentally rejects the constitutional separation of powers, viewing itself as the only legitimate authority and treating congressional oversight and court orders as optional.
Attorney General Todd Blanche is unprecedentedly acting as Trump's personal attorney and using the DOJ to shield the administration from corruption investigations.
Threats to criminally prosecute members of Congress for conducting oversight are legally baseless due to the Speech and Debate Clause, and have lost their intimidation power after the midterms.
Congressional oversight must now focus on preserving a documentary and digital trail of where ill-gotten gains went, enabling a future attorney general to recover stolen money through civil asset forfeiture and unjust enrichment claims that pardons and presidential immunity cannot block.
Digital records held by contractors like Palantir (which logs every keystroke at DOD) are harder to destroy than paper and could be subpoenaed by oversight committees.
The administration has practiced 'autocratic capture' — pressuring private companies to show political loyalty or face regulatory retaliation, as seen with Disney and the Julie Briskman case.
The midterm elections broke the administration's 'patina of power' that authoritarians rely on for coercion, empowering Congress, courts, and Democratic-controlled states as checks.
Corporate leaders like Alex Karp are already signaling willingness to cooperate with the new congressional majority, suggesting a shift in the political winds that may encourage more private sector independence from regime pressure.
Notable quotes
“Democracy won a battle on election day, but it's uh and and and for the first time won a battle in a while, but the war is far from over.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:27“we need an unconditional surrender by those who would want to impose an autocratic form of government on this country, but we need a magnanimous peace.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:25“the president, the chief of staff, the head of the Office of Management and Budget fundamentally believe that they are the only exclusive, legitimate power in this country and that the constitutional order in which there's a tripartite separation of powers is for suckers and doesn't exist.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:25“a Bush-appointed uh court chief judge in the district of Minnesota who's out there saying that the administration is basically just thumbing its nose at court orders, right? That's not a that's not a liberal judge out there criticizing them for it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:05“the Supreme Court's uh absurd decision in US v Trump that basically immunizes the president from future criminal accountability, the president's promise to pardon everybody on the way out means that the prospect of kind of criminal accountability down the line for violation of laws is going to be dicey at best.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:47“autocratic capture, where it's not the private sector buying the loyalty of the state. It's the state pressuring the private sector to seek its loyalty.”
▸ Notable quotes · 21:08Chapters
0:11 — Post-midterm assessment: battle won, war continues: Blumenthal and Wilentz argue that while the midterms were a victory for democracy, the constitutional crisis persists and accountability for the past decade's abuses is just beginning.
1:55 — Lincoln's Peacemakers metaphor for current moment: Bassin uses the painting 'The Peacemakers' to frame the need for unconditional surrender of authoritarian governance followed by magnanimous peace to reunite the country.
3:34 — Todd Blanche and DOJ as personal shield: Blumenthal describes Attorney General Todd Blanche acting as Trump's personal attorney and using the DOJ to block corruption investigations — an unprecedented arrangement.
4:02 — Threats to prosecute Congress and loss of authoritarian patina: Bassin explains why threats to criminally prosecute members of Congress for oversight are legally baseless (Speech and Debate Clause) and have lost intimidation power after the midterms stripped the administration's aura of invincibility.
6:13 — Administration's rejection of constitutional order: Wilentz and Bassin discuss the administration's belief that it is the only legitimate power, its ignoring of court orders (including by a Bush-appointed judge), and the structural checks now available via Congress, courts, and Democratic-controlled states.
11:52 — Oversight must preserve trail for civil asset recovery: Bassin argues oversight must go beyond exposure to document where stolen money went, enabling future civil recovery via asset forfeiture and unjust enrichment claims that bypass presidential immunity and pardons.
15:15 — Digital evidence preservation and Palantir's role: Discussion of digital records' resilience against destruction, Palantir's comprehensive logging of administration actions, and Alex Karp's public shift signaling corporate realignment.
19:30 — Autocratic capture of private sector: Bassin defines 'autocratic capture' — state pressure on companies for political loyalty — citing the Disney and Julie Briskman cases, and expresses hope that corporate leaders will reclaim independence.
Speakers
Sydney Blumenthal — Co-host
Sean Wilentz — Co-host
Ian Bassin — Guest