TLDR
Heather Mac Donald discusses the firing of Boston Symphony Orchestra conductor Andris Nelsons after he requested that "artistic excellence" be restored to the orchestra's strategic plan. New CEO Chad Smith, hired in mid-2024, pushed a DEI agenda prioritizing "lost voices" and audience self-reflection over musical excellence, reflecting a broader trend where arts administrators outnumber musicians 1:1 and use classical music as a vehicle for political activism.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The BSO had given Nelsons an automatically renewing contract calling his artistic leadership "peerless" just before the new administration fired him for wanting artistic excellence in the strategic plan.
The ratio of administrators to musicians at the BSO is now approximately 1:1, up from roughly 1:16 a few decades ago.
Tanglewood's summer programming included a humanities event on mass incarceration and systemic racism as a concluding feature, not as a side event.
Key takeaways
Andris Nelsons, a universally respected conductor with a joint appointment at the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra through 2036, was fired five months after asking that "artistic excellence" be reinstated as the core mission in the BSO's strategic plan — a phrase the new administration had deliberately removed.
The BSO's new CEO Chad Smith, described as indistinguishable from a university DEI officer, mandated programming that foregrounds "silenced and marginalized voices" and tells audiences they should see themselves reflected in performances, which Mac Donald argues fundamentally misreads artistic experience as narcissism rather than self-transcendence.
Administrative bloat at the BSO has grown from six administrators for 100 musicians to a 1:1 ratio (roughly 100 administrators), driving up ticket prices while the bureaucracy inserts itself into programming decisions to justify its existence.
Tanglewood, the BSO's historic summer home, devoted a concluding humanities program to mass incarceration and systemic racism featuring Bryan Stevenson, illustrating how classical music has become a "jumping off point to get to what really matters, which is fighting racism."
The conflict mirrors universities and medical schools: a leadership class that Mac Donald says betrays its duty to curate civilization, preferring peer approval for fighting "phantom injustice" over preserving cultural inheritance.
Nelsons had already accommodated diversity programming but drew the line at subordinating artistic excellence to it; his insistence that cultivating the core repertoire and the orchestra's sound remain the primary mission was the final straw.
Mac Donald argues audiences should hear music to "lose themselves in the composer's soul" — experiencing real difference like French Baroque — not to see their own identities mirrored, which she calls a "world of narcissism."
A parallel anecdote from Smith College: an English literature professor faced protest simply for including a single white male author on her syllabus, illustrating the zero-tolerance stance toward the Western canon in elite institutions.
Notable quotes
“You should not tell audiences that they go to hear the Bach St. Matthew Passion or a Beethoven late piano sonata — works of terrifying sublimity — because they want to see themselves reflected. They should be hearing music to lose themselves in the composer's soul.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:26“We are losing our civilization. And we are losing the highest aspirations and expression of humanity by a leadership class that is betraying every single day its primary duty which is to curate this civilization.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:56“Classical music is seen simply as a jumping off point to get to what really matters, which is fighting racism.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:13“The conductor kind of has to go along and put up with it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:08“There were any white men was the problem — that there was even a single white man and his work listed on a syllabus for English lit at Smith.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:48Chapters
3:38 — Nelsons firing and artistic excellence dispute: Heather Mac Donald details how BSO conductor Andris Nelsons was fired after requesting "artistic excellence" be restored to the strategic plan, despite universal respect and a peerless contract renewal from the prior administration.
5:54 — New CEO's DEI agenda replaces musical mission: CEO Chad Smith, hired mid-2024, imposed a diversity framework prioritizing "lost voices" and audience self-reflection, which Mac Donald argues misreads art as narcissism rather than self-transcendence.
9:00 — Administrative bloat and programming capture: The BSO's administrator-to-musician ratio has reached 1:1 (from 6:100), driving up costs and enabling bureaucrats to dictate programming, such as Tanglewood's mass incarceration event featuring Bryan Stevenson.
13:16 — Broader institutional parallel and Smith College anecdote: The conflict mirrors universities and medical schools where leadership betrays its curatorial duty; a Smith College professor was protested for including a single white male author on an English literature syllabus.
Speakers
Megan Kelly — Host
Heather Mac Donald — Guest