TLDR
The podcast discusses the Cornell Seven case where a woman alleged sexual assault by seven men at a fraternity house. No criminal charges were initially filed by the Tompkins County DA, who later went on a press tour explaining the woman had said she consented and was voluntarily intoxicated. Governor Hochul appointed AG Letitia James to reinvestigate, but James had already posted on Facebook calling the woman a 'victim' and 'survivor,' compromising neutrality. Mark Bederow explains New York's consent law: voluntary intoxication does not support a mental incapacity theory of non-consent, though physical helplessness (passing out) and forcible compulsion remain viable theories. He analyzes the case as very weak criminally due to all witnesses being intoxicated, inconsistent statements, and text messages that don't prove non-consent. He predicts charges may be filed due to political pressure but conviction is unlikely. The civil suit against Cornell and fraternities will likely settle.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
New York's 'voluntary intoxication loophole' means a person who voluntarily gets drunk or high cannot claim mental incapacity as a theory of non-consent, even if they were too impaired to appraise or control their conduct.
A prosecutor going on morning news shows to explain why they didn't charge a case — and revealing the alleged victim's statements that she consented — is highly unusual and undermines the victim's credibility publicly.
The Governor appointing an Attorney General who had already publicly declared the complainant a 'victim' and 'survivor' before seeing any evidence is a 'horrible mistake' that destroys the appearance of neutrality.
In New York, grand jurors can ask questions of witnesses, and in a high-profile case like this, grand jurors may already know media reports and ask about inconsistencies, potentially derailing a one-sided presentation.
Text messages saying 'come over, there's a girl, it's free' are 'not inconsistent with' non-consensual activity but also 'not nearly proof of it' — they are equally consistent with a consensual group encounter.
Key takeaways
New York law distinguishes between voluntary and involuntary intoxication: voluntary intoxication cannot support a mental incapacity theory of non-consent, but physical helplessness (unconsciousness) and forcible compulsion remain criminal theories.
The Tompkins County DA damaged the case by going on a press tour detailing the alleged victim's initial statements that she consented and voluntarily consumed drugs/alcohol, which Bederow calls 'sabotaging the credibility of the alleged victim.'
AG Letitia James was appointed to reinvestigate days after posting on Facebook 'I stand with the victim... and all the other survivors' and calling the ordeal 'horrific,' which Bederow says is 'disqualifying' for a neutral investigator.
New York grand juries cannot rely on hearsay and grand jurors can ask questions, making the process less of a rubber stamp than in other jurisdictions; the alleged victim would have to testify under oath.
The criminal case is extremely weak: all percipient witnesses were intoxicated, the alleged victim made inconsistent statements about consent, text messages show crude behavior but not admissions of non-consensual acts, and there is a potential motive to fabricate after being disinvited from a party.
The civil lawsuit targets Cornell, the fraternity, sorority, and individual men; Bederow predicts settlements with deep-pocketed defendants like Cornell regardless of criminal outcome.
Bederow predicts criminal charges will likely be filed due to political pressure from AG James, but calls an indictment a potential 'pyrrhic victory' because grand jury testimony will create discovery problems and motions to dismiss.
The case may accelerate the decline of Greek life on college campuses due to liability insurance concerns and public pressure, as seen at University of Arizona which suspended all fraternities/sororities after this case.
Notable quotes
“no means no even in New York and it there it is written into the statute in terms of the definitions of consent that if somebody says, "I don't want to do this." Uh and you do it, well, that's illegal. That's a crime.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:25“voluntary intoxication does not allow this one theory of lack of consent, mental incapacity to be used.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:29“he felt out of his depth. Let's call it what it is. Maybe not ready for primetime.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:45“if you're investigating alleged criminal activity involving that individual, you probably should not be using conclusory terms like she's a victim, she's a survivor.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:40“this is a very weak criminal case. That's that that's doesn't mean I am in favor of you know women as lawyers and analyzing and calling balls and strikes this is not a strong case.”
▸ Notable quotes · 24:35“now is you can't leave, right? Now now you have an indictment and you can't just do that and then walk into court and say, you know what? We don't want to do this anymore.”
▸ Notable quotes · 68:21Chapters
0:08 — Case Overview: Host introduces the Cornell Seven case: a woman alleged sexual assault by seven men at a fraternity house; no criminal charges filed; civil lawsuit filed; DA went on press tour; AG appointed to reinvestigate.
8:05 — New York Consent Law Explained: Bederow details NY's three theories of non-consent: forcible compulsion, mental incapacitation (requires involuntary intoxication), and physical helplessness; voluntary intoxication negates mental incapacity theory.
3:55 — DA's Press Tour and AG Appointment: Tompkins DA went on TV defending non-charging decision by revealing victim's initial statements; Governor Hochul appointed AG Letitia James days after she posted on Facebook calling the woman a 'victim' and 'survivor,' compromising neutrality.
37:00 — Grand Jury Process and Case Weaknesses: NY grand juries bar hearsay and allow juror questions; alleged victim must testify; case is weak due to universal intoxication, inconsistent statements, text messages not proving non-consent, and potential motive to fabricate.
61:00 — Civil Lawsuit and Settlement Dynamics: Civil suit targets Cornell, fraternities, sororities, and individuals; deep-pocketed defendants like Cornell will likely settle regardless of criminal outcome; discovery into institutional practices creates leverage.
65:00 — Impact on Greek Life and Predictions: Case may accelerate end of Greek life due to liability insurance crises; Bederow predicts charges will be filed due to political pressure but calls conviction unlikely and indictment a potential 'pyrrhic victory.'
Speakers
Peter Tragos — Host
Mark Bederow — Guest