TLDR
Eleven-month-old Koa Sharp was buried alive in a wire dog crate in a shallow grave behind his grandfather's South Carolina home by his father, Michael Comer, who had threatened to take the baby to New York and sent suicidal messages to the mother. After a 24-hour search involving over 100 people, rescuers found Koa alive, covered in dirt but unharmed, leading to attempted murder and other charges against Comer, who has a history of domestic violence and mental illness.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The baby was placed in a wire dog crate, not a solid plastic one, meaning dirt, bugs, and worms entered the crate during the burial.
The towel over the wire crate likely created the air pocket that kept the baby alive, not any intentional ventilation by the father.
Comer's own mother, who called 911, said of her arrested son: 'He's where he needs to be, locked up,' showing no denial of his guilt.
South Carolina may lack a specific torture statute that fits burying a live infant, and attempted murder carries a far lighter potential sentence than murder despite the prolonged suffering inflicted.
The baby stopped crying and sat up 'happy and healthy' on the tailgate moments after rescue, showing no visible physical injuries despite 24 hours underground.
Key takeaways
Michael Comer took his son Koa during a brief window when the grandmother stepped out and a babysitter was en route, exploiting the lack of a court order restricting his unsupervised access despite the mother having full custody.
Comer had previously threatened the baby's mother via messages that he would keep the child, move to New York, and expressed suicidal intent, yet no protective order or supervised visitation mandate was in place.
Surveillance footage showed Comer moving around town without the baby on the day of the disappearance, and he was eventually found hiding in a stranger's shed, refusing to tell police where Koa was.
Searchers noticed a disturbed patch of earth 50 feet into the woods behind the grandfather's house, dug three feet down, and heard the baby crying inside a wire dog crate covered with a towel that likely created an air pocket.
Koa survived approximately 24 hours buried alive in near-freezing temperatures, which may have slowed his metabolism, and was released from the hospital the same night with doctors expecting full physical recovery.
Comer was charged with attempted murder, unlawful conduct toward a child, custodial interference, and burglary, but experts argue the charges don't reflect the torture-like nature of the crime and expect superseding indictments including kidnapping and torture.
Dr. Casey Jordan characterizes this as retaliatory filicide — Comer allegedly tried to kill the baby to punish the mother for gaining full custody, and the methodical steps (crate, digging, towel, pine straw) indicate planning, not a psychotic break.
The case has inflicted community trauma: over 100 searchers, first responders who dug the baby out, and neighbors now live with hypervigilance and distrust, while the baby faces lifelong psychological imprinting from the ordeal.
Notable quotes
“My son Michael, he's where he needs to be, locked up.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:57“He is trying to kill the baby to get back at its mother because she got full custody of little Koa. And apparently he was really angry, furious, jealous.”
▸ Notable quotes · 39:51“There are so many layers and steps to what he did with this child. It does not sound like he heard a voice telling him to do it. It's too methodical.”
▸ Notable quotes · 47:29“The trauma is now ingrained, if you will, in their muscle memory, right? I call it their marrow memory in their bones.”
▸ Notable quotes · 58:18“Community trauma is a real thing and we see it especially when community members... it makes us hypervigilant. It very often makes people more distrustful of their fellow human beings and often more isolated.”
▸ Notable quotes · 59:56“You chose a shallow grave filled with worms and bugs and insects that would easily get into that cage and start eating away at that child even within the first hour. That was your safe hideaway place. Not say, I don't know, the shed that you found for yourself.”
▸ Notable quotes · 51:51Chapters
0:00 — Announcement and case introduction: Host Ashley Banfield announces a members-only Ask Me Anything event, then introduces the disturbing case of 11-month-old Koa Sharp buried alive in a dog crate in South Carolina.
3:03 — Timeline: Monday morning disappearance: Koa was left with his father Michael Comer while grandmother ran an errand; when the babysitter arrived, both father and baby were gone, prompting an immediate 911 call from the grandmother who feared Comer would flee to New York.
10:30 — Father's threats and criminal history: Comer had sent messages threatening to keep the baby, move to New York, and expressed suicidal thoughts; he had a recent domestic violence conviction, was on probation, and had schizophrenia and bipolar diagnoses.
13:50 — Search, discovery, and rescue: Over 100 searchers combed woods behind grandfather's house; eagle-eyed searchers spotted disturbed earth 50 feet in, dug three feet down, and found Koa alive in a wire dog crate covered with a towel, crying and covered in dirt.
29:27 — Hospital release and initial charges: Koa was released from the hospital the same night with expected full physical recovery; Comer was charged with attempted murder, unlawful conduct toward a child, custodial interference, and burglary — charges experts say are insufficient.
38:00 — Interview with Dr. Casey Jordan: Criminologist-attorney Dr. Casey Jordan analyzes the case as retaliatory filicide, discusses the methodical nature of the crime, likely defense strategies including insanity, sentencing challenges, and the lifelong psychological impact on the child and community.
59:54 — Community trauma and systemic gaps: Jordan explains how community trauma creates hypervigilance and isolation, advocates for a child endangerment registry, and emphasizes the need for neighbors to watch for risk factors like custodial disputes and domestic violence.
66:00 — Closing reflections and call to action: Banfield expresses hope for additional charges, urges listeners to subscribe for updates, and reflects on the flock metaphor — society as a flock needing to identify and remove wolves who harm children.
Speakers
Ashley Banfield — Host
Dr. Casey Jordan — Guest expert
Patricia Comer — Paternal grandmother
John Comer — Paternal grandfather
Michael Comer — Father / alleged perpetrator
Desiree Sharp — Mother