TLDR
Megan Kelly condemns the UK government's pressure on social media platforms to deplatform Russell Brand following his conviction, and criticizes the London Victims Commissioner's call for platforms and prisons to restrict how convicted offenders communicate. She also highlights the cancellation of musician Ian McNab for merely defending Brand, arguing this proves a chilling effect on free speech and character witnesses.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A government victims commissioner explicitly argued that private platform terms of service should be used to circumvent a convicted person's acknowledged right to proclaim innocence.
A musician was removed from a Hall of Fame induction solely for a mild social media post expressing skepticism about the allegations against Brand, not for any criminal conduct.
The BBC, as state-funded media, published a list of specific punitive measures — including blocking family phone calls — that could be applied to Brand if he continues speaking out.
Key takeaways
The UK government pressured YouTube in 2023 and Meta in 2024 to deplatform Russell Brand after a documentary aired allegations and after his conviction, which Kelly argues is state-backed censorship of a single individual.
London Victims Commissioner Claire Waxman acknowledged Brand's right to profess innocence but said platform terms of service should regulate how he disseminates his message, effectively urging platforms to silence him.
Waxman also proposed reviewing prison rules to require governor approval before any convicted prisoner's messages can be broadcast, targeting Brand's wife reading his statements on social media.
The BBC outlined potential punishments if Brand violated prison rules — including loss of visits, phone access, gym time, and TV — which Kelly characterizes as a veiled threat to cut off contact with his wife and children.
Musician Ian McNab had upcoming gigs cancelled and was stripped of a planned Liverpool Legends Hall of Fame induction after one social media post supporting Brand and questioning the allegations.
Samantha Presy, a comedian who dated Brand and knew the comedy circuit, testified he is not a serial rapist and said the 'open secret' narrative is false; she also explained character witnesses stayed away for fear of cancellation.
Kelly argues the McNab case proves Brand's claim that no one would testify for him due to fear of professional retaliation, creating a feedback loop where dissent from the official narrative is punished.
Kelly frames the entire episode as a abandonment of free speech principles by UK authorities and legacy media, contrasting it with Elon Musk's X, which she says refuses to comply with such pressure.
Notable quotes
“Freedom of expression allows convicted sex offenders such as Bran to profess their innocence, but terms of service of media platforms should regulate the way in which they get their message out.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:10“Thank God Elon Musk owns X. He will never bend the knee ever.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:27“We fought a whole war so I don't have to answer to you. And I'll do whatever the hell I damn well please within the bounds of proper journalism, commentary, and reason.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:42“Nice wife you have here. Shame if anything happened to your ability to see or talk to her. Real shame.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:11“It's not only traumatizing his alleged victims, but all other rape victims.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:07“No one would basically come within a barge pole of me after that documentary so-called documentary of 2023.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:45Chapters
0:00 — UK government pressure on platforms: Kelly details how the UK government pressured YouTube in 2023 and Meta in 2024 to deplatform Russell Brand after allegations and conviction, calling it state-backed censorship.
5:00 — Victims Commissioner's proposals: Claire Waxman says platforms should regulate how convicted offenders disseminate messages and wants prison rules changed to require governor approval for any broadcast communications.
3:40 — BBC outlines punitive measures: The BBC lists specific prison punishments — loss of visits, phone access, privileges — that could be applied to Brand if he violates rules, which Kelly reads as a threat to his family contact.
6:27 — Ian McNab cancelled for supporting Brand: Musician Ian McNab lost gigs and a Hall of Fame induction after one social media post defending Brand, illustrating the professional cost of dissent.
6:54 — Samantha Presy's testimony and chilling effect: Presy denies Brand is a serial rapist, says it was never an open secret, and explains character witnesses refused to testify for fear of cancellation, confirming Brand's own account.
Speakers
Megan Kelly — Host