DOJ has 'been destroyed, needs to be rebuilt': Maddow on new book on history of Justice Dept.

Original Media · 19m · English · YouTube · MS NOW

TLDR

Rachel Maddow discusses her book 'Department of Fate,' tracing the 150-year history of the U.S. Department of Justice from its founding to crush the KKK through its politicized misuse, arguing that the DOJ has now collapsed under Trump and Bill Barr and must be refounded with structural reforms like supermajority Senate confirmations and bans on political appointees.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The first Attorney General, Amos Ackerman, was a former Confederate officer and slave owner who aggressively prosecuted the Klan.

•

Walt Whitman worked as a clerk in the early, bare-bones DOJ.

•

1920s AG Harry Daugherty ran a '10-story bribe department store' but was ousted not for his own corruption but for failing to police the administration's corruption — a direct parallel to today.

•

The DOJ has been political 'since day one,' not a recent development.

•

Maddow initially predicted Trump would 'supersize' the DOJ into a 'nuclear weapon' in a second term; instead, it collapsed entirely.

Key takeaways

•

The DOJ was created after the Civil War to enforce the 14th Amendment; its first act under AG Amos Ackerman (a former Confederate) was dismantling the Ku Klux Klan.

•

The DOJ has a dual legacy: it has both advanced civil rights and crushed labor, persecuted immigrants, and served presidential political interests.

•

Bill Barr inflicted 'fatal wounds' on the DOJ in Trump's first term by turning its investigative power inward against its own prosecutors and FBI agents.

•

In Trump's second term, the DOJ has collapsed: key divisions (National Security, Tax, Public Integrity) are shuttered, senior staff have resigned en masse, and remaining actions are 'incompetent, flaccid, and often comical.'

•

Maddow proposes Congress refound the DOJ via statute (no constitutional amendment needed) by requiring a two-thirds Senate vote for senior DOJ posts, mandating professional qualifications, and barring personal lawyers or campaign staff from top roles.

•

90% of voters in 2024 cited corruption as their top concern, surpassing cost of living and foreign policy.

•

Current AG Todd Blanche faces likely impeachment investigation for ongoing corruption, including pardon-selling and quashing investigations into political allies.

Notable quotes

“He went to South Carolina and he busted the Klan. And that is the first essentially the first thing that the U.S. Department of Justice did once it was founded.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:40

“He was just wildly corrupt. You can go to every floor of the Justice Department and pay a bribe for a different service.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:28

“I think Bill Barr essentially inflicted the fatal wounds in Trump's first term, and then it took until Trump's second term for it to die.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:17

“The Justice Department needs to be stood back up stronger and more resilient against corruption. So it's totaled has been. It is totaled.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:42

“This Department of Justice wasn't created by the Constitution. It was created. It is a creature of Congress. So if Congress decides you have to have the two thirds vote, then a president can't go to the Supreme Court and get it overturned.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:29

“If there's a crime in progress, I think the American people want those in charge to stop it... if they don't answer for it, they'll keep doing it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:01

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & Book Overview: Hosts welcome Rachel Maddow to discuss her decade-long project, 'Department of Fate,' a 150-year chronicle of the DOJ. The New York Times calls it a 'head-spinning chronicle'; Maddow emphasizes the epilogue as essential reading for Congress.

•

1:00 — Origins of the DOJ: Amos Ackerman & the Klan: Maddow details the DOJ's founding after the Civil War to enforce the 14th Amendment. First AG Amos Ackerman — a former Confederate and slave owner — made the DOJ's first major action the destruction of the KKK in South Carolina.

•

3:00 — Historical Corruption: Harry Daugherty's 'Bribe Department Store': A century ago, AG Harry Daugherty ran a spectacularly corrupt DOJ where every floor sold a different bribe. He fell not for his own graft but for refusing to police the Harding administration's corruption — a 'lightning bolt' parallel to today.

•

6:00 — Robert Jackson's Warning & the Power of Personnel: Maddow cites AG Robert Jackson's 1940 speech: the DOJ's power depends on the character of the person in the chair, not laws or buildings. This underscores why personnel reforms are central to her argument.

•

7:00 — Bill Barr's Fatal Wounds to the DOJ: Maddow argues Barr turned the DOJ's power inward against its own prosecutors (e.g., Strzok, Page, Durham probe), destroying institutional integrity. She says Barr gets too much credit for a last-minute balk on 2020 election subversion.

•

15:00 — DOJ Collapse in Trump's Second Term: Instead of a weaponized DOJ, key divisions are gone (National Security, Tax, Public Integrity, Legislative Affairs). Senior resignations are at a record high; remaining politicized actions are incompetent and farcical.

•

18:00 — Reform Blueprint: Supermajority, Qualifications, Independence: Maddow outlines statutory reforms: 2/3 Senate confirmation for senior DOJ roles, strict professional qualifications, ban on personal lawyers/campaign staff. Because the DOJ is a creature of Congress, this requires no constitutional amendment.

•

20:00 — Danger of Inaction & Impeachment Prospects: Maddow warns that ignoring ongoing corruption (pardons for sale, quashed investigations, killings uninvestigated) ensures recurrence. She predicts AG Todd Blanche will face impeachment investigation.

Speakers

•

Rachel Maddow — Guest / Author

•

Joe — Co-host

•

Mika — Co-host

⋮